10

Loading video...

Amanda Castro

By Amanda Castro

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The Lindsay Clancy murder trial delivered a short but consequential day of testimony Thursday, with jurors hearing emotional accounts from a hospital chaplain, while attorneys clashed over whether the jury should be instructed on intoxication.

Judge Robert William Sullivan said during Day 17 of the trial that closing arguments are likely early next week.

Clancy was charged with three counts of murder (with potential sentences of life in prison without parole or life in prison with parole eligibility after 15-25 years) and three counts of strangulation (with potential penalties of up to five years in state prison per count) in the deaths of her three children—Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months—in 2023.

Read More on News

Representatives for the prosecution and defense are restricted from commenting outside Plymouth County Superior Court in Plymouth, Massachusetts, because of the ongoing trial.

Here are the biggest moments from Day 17.

A chaplain said on August 20, 2026, that Lindsay Clancy, shown during her murder trial, described a commanding male voice as the prosecution questioned why it was never documented.

...

1. Chaplain Says Clancy Described a Commanding Male Voice

Sheila Cavanaugh, a chaplain at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, testified that during her early visits with Clancy, the defendant told her she had heard a "persistent male voice" issuing commands.

According to Cavanaugh, Clancy said the voice warned that “if she did not follow the command, neither she nor her children would be safe.” Cavanaugh said the topic surfaced “several times” across roughly 14 visits at Brigham and continued during Clancy’s stays at Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital and Tewksbury State Hospital.

The testimony adds another layer to the defense’s argument that Clancy was experiencing a severe mental break in the days leading to the killings.

2. Prosecution Presses Cavanaugh About Why She Never Documented the Voice

During cross‑examination, prosecutors zeroed in on a key inconsistency: Despite Cavanaugh’s claim that Clancy repeatedly discussed hearing a voice, none of her hospital notes mention it.

Prosecutors pointed out that Cavanaugh’s notes include other direct quotes from Clancy—including fears about walking again and feelings of hopefulness—but nothing about auditory hallucinations.

Cavanaugh responded that chaplain notes are not “verbatim transcripts” and that her role is to “bear witness to suffering,” not evaluate patients clinically. The prosecution countered that she still chose to include other quotes, raising questions about why this one was omitted.

3. Cavanaugh Describes Clancy’s Grief and Emotional State

Cavanaugh testified that Clancy frequently spoke about her children and carried “immense grief,” a characterization the prosecution objected to but the judge allowed.

She described Clancy as “covered in medical armor” during their first meeting—intubated, bandaged and wearing a neck brace—and said Clancy told her, “I am so glad my children are safe.”

Cavanaugh said she continued visiting Clancy weekly at Tewksbury, estimating that she has seen her “perhaps 200 times,” and that Clancy’s grief “continues presently.”

4. Prosecution and Defense Clash Over Intoxication Instructions

After jurors were dismissed for the day, attorneys returned for a preliminary charge conference that quickly turned tense.

Prosecutors argued that the judge should not instruct the jury on intoxication, saying that “there’s been no evidence of intoxication by drugs or alcohol during the killings.” They emphasized that Clancy’s prescribed medications were low‑dose and that any side effects occurred weeks before the incident.

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington pushed back sharply, calling the case “clearly an involuntary intoxication defense.” He argued that overprescription, medication changes and abrupt cessation could have directly affected Clancy’s mental state.

The judge did not rule but indicated he would provide a draft set of instructions Friday.

5. Judge Says Closings Expected Monday or Tuesday

Sullivan told attorneys that he anticipates closing arguments early next week, likely Monday or Tuesday, though he’s open to giving both sides an extra day if needed.

“There’s been a lot of evidence, and there’s a lot of witnesses,” he said, adding that the case remains “on schedule if not ahead of schedule.”

The jury was excused early Thursday and will return at 9 a.m. Friday for what is expected to be a full day of testimony, including expert witness forensic psychiatrist Dr. Phillip Resnick.

Prosecutors and the defense clash over intoxication instructions on August 20, 2026, as the judge eyes closing arguments early next week.

...

Notable Mention: Clancy Supporters Rally Outside Courthouse

Hundreds of supporters rallied outside Plymouth County Superior Court on Thursday as Clancy continued to stand trial. Many in the crowd wore pink shirts printed with phrases like “Believe,” “She Needed Help,” and “Peace For Lindsay,” saying they hoped to draw attention to how the mental‑health system treats women in crisis.

Roughly 300 people—mostly women, with a handful of men—said Clancy’s case reflects broader failures in postpartum and psychiatric care. Her attorney acknowledges she killed her children but argues she was in the grip of postpartum psychosis and bipolar disorder, conditions he says left her unable to understand her actions. After the killings, Clancy attempted suicide and is now paralyzed from the waist down.

Supporters pointed to her long trail of attempts to get help: multiple outpatient providers, medication changes, a suicide hotline call, an ER visit, and a voluntary psychiatric admission. Prosecutors, however, say Clancy planned the January 24, 2023, killings and manipulated circumstances to get her husband out of the house. They’ve also questioned whether her suicide attempt was genuine and noted testimony that she didn’t always take her prescribed medications.

Thursday marked the largest public show of support since the trial began nearly a month ago. The crowd stood silently for more than an hour before proceedings, then applauded defense attorney Kevin Reddington when he appeared outside the courthouse. Organizer Renee Kimball urged attendees to trust that he “has Lindsay’s fight.”

Before dispersing, supporters formed a circle, recited the Lord’s Prayer, and raised their hands in heart shapes, some holding international flags to signal global solidarity.

Aimee Breault livestreams a demonstration in support of Lindsay Clancy outside Plymouth Superior Court on August 20, 2026.

...

What Happens Next

The trial resumes Friday at 9 a.m., with the defense expected to call Resnick, whose testimony will be central to Clancy’s criminal responsibility claim. Once the defense rests, prosecutors plan to call three rebuttal experts.

If testimony concludes by the end of the week, Sullivan said closing arguments will likely take place Monday or Tuesday, followed immediately by jury instructions and deliberations.

The judge said he is willing to give attorneys an additional day to prepare closing arguments if needed, given the volume of evidence and expert testimony.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech, Dave Siminoff, Sam Wilson.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines