
...

By Khaleda Rahman
National Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Prosecutors for the Southern District of New York have denied "eavesdropping" on Luigi Mangione's calls with his attorney.
Mangione's attorney Karen Friedman Agnifilo told Judge Margaret Garnett during an arraignment hearing on Friday that prosecutors had inadvertently listened to a call she had with Mangione.
In a letter to Garnett on Tuesday, federal prosecutors said that "no one" at the New York County District Attorney's Office (DANY) or the Government had "'eavesdropped' on the defendant on a live basis."
Read More on U.S.

...
Why It Matters
Prosecutors listening to calls between a defendant and their attorney can be a violation of the defendant's Sixth Amendment right to counsel and attorney-client privilege, and could threaten their case against Mangione.
Mangione, 26, is facing federal and state charges in the fatal shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson outside a New York City hotel in December.
He pleaded not guilty to a federal murder charge on Friday. Federal prosecutors have declared their intent to seek the death penalty. Mangione pleaded not guilty to state murder and terrorism charges in December.
What To Know
The judge had ordered prosecutors to submit a letter within seven days confirming that Mangione would have access to a secure line and that his calls aren't accessible to any member of the prosecution team.
The letter from prosecutors said that "consistent with well-known practice in federal and state jails, many of the defendant's calls are recorded, with notice of the recording provided to him and the person on the other side of any calls."
The Metropolitan Detention Center, where Mangione is being held, sent records of calls between Mangione and his attorney to prosecutors because they were made on the recorded and monitored jail line and not the line specially designated for attorney calls, the letter said. It added that the phone number Agnifilo was using "was not identified as belonging to counsel."
A paralegal at the district attorney's office who was reviewing the recordings encountered the call between Mangione and Agnifilo and recognized it as an attorney call, the letter said.
The paralegal "immediately stopped listening and reported the issue to the prosecution team at DANY, who promptly notified Ms. Agnifilo and one member of the prosecution team at the Government," the letter added.
"No one else from DANY and no one at all from the Government ever reviewed this or any other attorney call. The Government has now segregated this specific audio recording to prevent any further inadvertent access, and it understands DANY has done the same."
What People Are Saying
The letter from prosecutors also said: "To ensure that this issue does not arise again, the Government has reminded defense counsel that the defendant and counsel can choose not to use Trufone's recorded and monitored lines. Instead, the defendant and defense counsel can use the options described above to have completely unrecorded and unmonitored communications with each other."
It also said that if they "wish to continue using Truffle, they can confirm with the MDC that any numbers used by defense counsel are identified to the MDC as attorney telephone numbers on the defendant's contact list of approved numbers for Trufone."
Agnifilo told Garnett during Friday's hearing: "We were just informed by the state court prosecutors that they were eavesdropping on all of Mr. Mangione's calls. They were listening to his attorney calls and his other calls that are going on, and they said that it was inadvertent that they listened to a call between Mr. Mangione and me."
She added: "We would just ask that the Southern District put something in place to ensure that no calls to his legal team and among the legal team are either recorded or listened to, certainly not provided to the Manhattan DA's Office or the U.S. Attorney's Office."
What's Next
Mangione's next appearance in the state case is set for June 26. He is next due in federal court on December 5.
No trial date has been set in either case, but Mangione's defense team have said they want the federal case to take precedent because it involves the death penalty.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines