Luigi Mangione Law & Order Episode Similar

...

Aila Slisco

By Aila Slisco

Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The storyline of a 22-year-old Law & Order episode has clear "parallels" to the alleged actions of UnitedHealthcare CEO shooting suspect Luigi Mangione, according to the show's co-writer.

Mangione, 26, has received an unexpected amount of support online since being arrested in Pennsylvania earlier this week. He is currently facing murder and other charges rated to the fatal shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in New York City on December 4.

A manifesto allegedly written by Mangione refers to health insurance executives as "parasites," while New York City Police Department Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenny has suggested that "ill will toward corporate America" may have played a role in Thompson's death.

Read More on News

A 2002 Law & Order episode titled "Undercovered" begins with the body of a murdered health insurance executive found on a street in Manhattan. It is later revealed that he was killed by a man whose leukemia-stricken daughter was denied an insurance claim for potentially lifesaving treatment.

Luigi Mangione Law & Order Episode Similar

...

Writer Wendy Battles, who penned the episode alongside Noah Baylin, told Vanity Fair in an article published on Wednesday that she noticed similarities between her storyline and Thompson's killing "right away" when news of the slaying emerged last week.

"Noah and I exchanged texts," Battles said. "We just both recognized right away that there were parallels. When the murder first occurred, it looked like it could have something to do with the fact that the victim was involved in the insurance agency—but it could also be a professional hit, a disgruntled employee."

"But it wasn't a very well-organized crime," she added. "He left DNA and fingerprints. And that does not speak to a professional hit man."

Battles said that the Law & Order episode was inspired by her own father's struggles in being denied coverage by health insurance companies after being diagnosed with type 1 diabetes.

The end of the episode, which features the suspect being set free after a hung jury fails to convict him, is still reflective of current public opinions on the insurance industry, according to Battles. She said that "anger" towards the industry also explains why some cheered on Thompson's death and are supporting Mangione.

"The outrage and the anger that people were feeling about health insurance in this country was around, alive and kicking even back then, 22 years ago," said Battles. "You can see on social media the outrage, [and] people laughing and clapping. It's just unbelievable."

"So it's obviously a very, very polarizing issue that I would really hope some day that we can deal with," she continued. "I mean, no other industrialized country has this problem."

While the suspect in the Law & Order episode walked free, Battles said that she did not "see any world where [Mangione] will be getting off like the man did in our episode."

Newsweek reached out for comment to the office of Mangione's attorney Thomas Dickey via email on Thursday.

Battles went on to say that Mangione allegedly carried a manifesto and a "ghost gun" at the time of his arrest suggesting that he "sacrificed his own life to bring more attention to this matter." She said she hoped the case "galvanizes awareness around this issue," while also stressing that she does not "condone violence."

"Obviously a lot of people are in pain, but I don't condone violence, and shooting this man in cold blood is not the answer," she said. "The answer is changing your vote—voting people into office who will put nationalized health care into practice... That's the only way that this situation can be changed—not by shooting people."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines