
0.cached.png
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The Dylan Legacy
Our Oct. 18 story on Bob Dylan prompted fans to share their memories of growing up with his music. "He showed us that songs could have complexity," recalled one. "He stirred my imagination and challenged my world view," said another. Added a third, "He's the Shakespeare of popular music."
Many thanks, NEWSWEEK, for your Oct. 18 feature on Bob Dylan ("The Book of Bob"). I discovered Dylan's albums in college. Like many others, I was drawn to his music because he showed us that poetry did not have to be relegated to the dustier shelves of the library and that songs could have complexity. Our reaction was "Wow, how does he do that?" Many of us hit the road, stayed up all night writing songs, tried them out on audiences, swapped songs with others and achieved a measure of artistic creation we never would have otherwise. A fact about Woodstock that's not mentioned is the buzz at the time that Dylan would make a surprise appearance. Retreating to the town of Woodstock, New York, he had not appeared publicly for three years. Why would concert promoters pick that location if it weren't some kind of signal? So many of my generation made the trip to Woodstock and endured the rain, mud and misery in the hope that they would finally see again the artist whose music had reached them in a way no others had. Thanks, Bob, for the inspiration.
Michael B. Williams
Roslindale, Massachusetts
Read More on News
My mother forbade me to play her records when I was growing up for fear I'd scratch them. But, as soon as she left the house, I listened to as much "Nashville Skyline" and "Highway 61 Revisited" as I could. I used to marvel at what it must have been like to have an icon who could stand so effortlessly for an entire generation. Your article confirms what my mother told me: there was never anyone in Dylan's league. There still isn't.
Angela Teater
Seattle, Washington
When I was a teenager, my boy-friend, appalled by my adolescent taste for pop music, arrived at my house one afternoon with two vinyl LPs: Gustav Holst's "The Planets" and Bob Dylan's "The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan." Both were intoxicating, provocative, jolting. Holst awakened in me a passion for symphonic music, but Dylan stirred my imagination and challenged my world view. Lyrics from "Blowin' in the Wind," "Masters of War" and "A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall" jarred me out of my narrow, selfish world and moved me to examine the issues of war, politics and civil rights. I began to develop a social conscience and I got involved. My boyfriend (whom I later married) and I continued our social activism throughout college and selected professions that we thought would help improve people's lives: I taught high school for 32 years, and he worked in labor relations until his death in 1995. Would my life have followed the same course had I never encountered Dylan? I can't say. But regardless of Dylan's disdain for "the big bugs in the press" who elevated him to "the mouthpiece... or even conscience of a generation," he must understand that if art does not reflect the times in which it is created or inspire us in some way, the artist is not worthy of our patronage.
Brenda Deily Constan
Decatur, Georgia
I have been a fan of Bob Dylan's music since the '60s, I have a large number of his recordings in my music library and I attended one of his Chicago concerts. So, I looked forward to reading your story on Dylan. But I found the person churlish, self-important, boring and lacking in the ordinary grace and humility of a public performer toward his audience. I'll continue to enjoy Dylan's music, but I doubt if I'll purchase any more, and I won't read his book.
E. A. Cleary
Chicago, Illinois
What has happened to Bob Dylan over the years? He seems to be suffering an identity crisis: his tacky mustache and cowboy clothes, uptight looks and squinting eyes don't seem to fit the creative and sensitive individual one can sense under the mask--a most inappropriate disguise. That he'd equate, in his book, dissent with being an outlaw is perhaps verbal disguise as well and equally absurd. He was never a messiah to me, but a person with a clear mind and enough talent to express himself very originally, verbally and musically. He was a reflection of the times and extraordinarily gifted. It is, however, very unlikely that he could have continued to express his genuinely visionary voice without becoming entangled in ideologies and mired in passing political trivia, so he became, as many of his generation, a star that shone intensely and briefly, dying not physically, but artistically, and apparently willfully. It is not so bad after all, if only he could at last free himself and give up the Clint Eastwood-type duds and steely gaze, and share a good laugh with his fans for having played a trick or two on them.
Raphael Montoliu
Lakeport, California
Many people seem to be in denial about Bob Dylan, including Bob Dylan. He thinks he can change history, and then be able to go out to eat without being noticed. And many people think you can enjoy popular music without owning a Dylan record. Wake up, everyone: Dylan is the William Shakespeare of popular music. If you don't enjoy his music, try harder--it's worth it.
Stan Brown
Victorville, California
Picking up Dylan's "Love and Theft" CD on 9/11, the day it was released, I've wondered why, with his history of social consciousness and searing judgment songs, Dylan hadn't recorded a response to those events. After reading your piece, I understand. Dylan renounced the golden crown of thorns we placed upon him by going his own way. "Masters of War," "Blowin' in the Wind" and "With God on Our Side" speak volumes to the situations we're in today. Dylan doesn't owe us anything. And he's still great in concert!
Tim Grover
Pleasant Hill, Iowa
The Science of Fat Cells
Thank you, NEWSWEEK, for your comprehensive and much-needed article "What You Don't Know About Fat" (Sept. 20). During my more than 20 years of teaching and counseling compulsive eaters and overweight individuals, it has been obvious to me that they are neither simply "lazy" nor "undisciplined," as they often contemptuously call themselves when they cannot control their eating. There is so much misinformed prejudice against fat people that it is vital that they and the public understand the biochemical precursors of gaining weight and becoming overweight. Yes, people can change their behavior around food, but they are also limited by their biology. Personal history, motivation, cultural pressures and physiology all contribute to their size and shape.
Karen R. Koenig, LICSW
West Roxbury, Massachusetts
As a petite woman, I am tired of hearing all the excuses as to why people are overweight. They are overweight because they consume too much food. Period. Whenever I begin to pack on the pounds, I watch what I eat, making sure it is low calorie, low fat and healthy. I count, using a notebook and pen, every calorie and fat gram I consume. It costs nothing, and my reward is that I lose weight. Sometimes I am hungry and it is not fun, but it is a choice I make (once in a while) to remain thin. All the people featured in the article did something (gastric bypass, drugs, etc.) that enabled them to eat less. Imagine if they had had the willpower to lose weight on their own by not eating so much.
Amanda Terembula
Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
An alternative to "stomach stapling" (intervention No. 1 in your article) is laparoscopic adjustable gastric banding, in which the stomach is reduced through a safer, much less invasive and reversible procedure. The LAP-BAND creates an hourglass effect wherein the upper part of the stomach fills and then slowly empties into the larger part. The operation is only about an hour long, post-op recovery takes less than a week and there is little pain or discomfort. I had the procedure done in June 2003 and have lost 149 pounds so far. I am 66 years old and 6 feet 1, have had two heart attacks and have a stent. I also had severe sleep apnea, was on a sleep respirator and was unable to walk more than a few feet at a time. Each day I got worse and was waiting to die. I considered gastric bypass too dangerous, so when I found out about the LAP-BAND I was ecstatic. Since the operation, my wife and I have taken back-to-back cruises to Alaska, where I was able to sightsee all I wanted without difficulty (before, I wouldn't have been able to get down the gangway). I am remodeling two houses, and we are going on another cruise, through the Panama Canal, in December. While any surgery is potentially dangerous and should be carefully considered, I strongly recommend LAP-BAND surgery to anyone who is in the condition I once was.
Bill Bogle
Tillamook, Oregon
What you did not mention in your article is the dramatic effect that one's psyche plays in the weight-loss battle. Whether this battle is won or lost depends on the condition--or reconditioning--of the mind. Beyond mustering up tremendous willpower to effectively lose weight without surgery or diet pills, people must change their minds about the way they view food, their bodies and their efforts to control behaviors that have been with them for 20, 30 or 40 years. It is well documented that providing multipronged, extensive and prolonged support and guidance that includes behavior modification, social support, stress-reduction techniques, nutrition education, low-calorie diets and fitness instruction can yield weight-loss success that lasts. Our patients have had dramatic and significant success with such treatment, including mind-body techniques like acupuncture and meditation. They lose two to seven pounds a week and succeed at eliminating cravings, guilt, depression and yo-yo dieting. We teach them the health principles that obviate the need for traditional diets. In short, they learn precisely how to rev up their metabolism and eat in moderation without feeling deprived.
Andrea Pennington, M.D., C.Ac.
President
The Pennington Institute for Health and Wellness
Silver Spring, Maryland
As a registered clinical exercise physiologist who works with cardiac and obese patients, I thank you for your cover story on fat. I greatly appreciate the depth that the authors went into on the substances fat cells produce that are so detrimental to health. My concern with many articles on obesity is the lack of focus on exercise and the spotlight on new medications and fad diets. I realize the public wants quick fixes, but in my experience people can handle, and actually would appreciate, the honest truth. I urge you to look deep into research on physical activity--not just the epidemiological studies but the physiological studies as well. It would be an excellent springboard for an article in NEWSWEEK that tells the whole story on physical inactivity and its detriments to health.
Janet Lagerman Huehls, M.A., RCEP, CES
Paxton, Massachusetts
The Impasse in Iraq
I agree with Fareed Zakaria (World View, Aug. 23) in his attempt to discuss the rights and wrongs of the United States' going to war with Iraq. However, it should also be emphasized that both proponents and opponents of military action must accept part of the blame for this precarious impasse. Let us not forget that it was peace-loving European leaders who tolerated Saddam Hussein's brutal regime for more than two decades, despite knowing what was going on in that country. Their overriding motive was sheer economic self-interest. When the Clinton administration proposed implementing "smart" sanctions targeting predominantly members of the Baathist elite, France and Russia at the United Nations voiced their objections for obvious reasons.
Werner Radtke
Paderborn, Germany
Once again, Fareed Zakaria is bang on target. Not finding WMDs in Iraq shouldn't be a big enough reason to condemn Bush for invading that country. Understandably, it reflects public opinion, the world over, against the invasion. Public opinion, however, is notoriously myopic and self-centered. As Zakaria pithily puts it, "Once out of his box, Saddam would almost certainly have jump-started his programs and ambitions." In time, that would have given rise to the mother of all worries to the free world. Still, Bush's invasion deserves to be hugely faulted regarding its execution, for all the reasons listed in the article, plus one important omission: the shocking lack of control over prisoner-abuse violations in Abu Ghraib, resulting in a loss of good will between the Iraqi population and the Coalition forces, when it is most needed.
Pesi J. Padshah
Pune, India
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines