NYPD Commissioner Jessica S. Tisch (l) stands beside New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani as he speaks during a security briefing ahead of the United Nations General Assembly, One Police Plaza, New York, NY, September 17, 2026.

...

Anna Rahmanan

By Anna Rahmanan

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani has ordered the dissolution of the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, a specialized force deployed to confront terrorist threats, major emergencies and disorder at mass demonstrations.

The unit had acquired a reputation for aggressive policing, particularly against protesters. Mamdani wants it gone, which is hardly surprising given his longstanding criticism of aggressive policing. But can NYC dispense with its methods without sacrificing its capacity to contain violence?

The roughly 500-officer unit was built for situations in which ordinary policing might prove inadequate. The unit's record might give Mamdani ample grounds for reform, but the abuses of a police unit and the necessity of its original mission are separate questions.

Read More on Analysis

In recent years, after all, New York has confronted demonstrations that descended into assaults, looting, destruction and generalized violence.

Given that history, what evidence can Mamdani offer that his replacement will be capable of containing the violence for which the Strategic Response Group was deployed?

The Violence Behind the Demonstrations

During New York's 2020 George Floyd demonstrations, more than 400 NYPD officers were injured, over 250 were hospitalized and nearly 300 police vehicles were vandalized, according to the department.

The city's Department of Investigation documented violence, looting and property destruction, while emphasizing that most demonstrators remained peaceful. Some looters appeared to have no connection to the protests themselves.

The national picture has since become more complicated.

Related Story

Scary Intel Drops Are Their Own Kind of Dirty Bomb

Scary Intel Drops Are Their Own Kind of Dirty Bomb

Related Story

The FAA’s Explanation Is More Terrifying Than a Cover-Up

The FAA’s Explanation Is More Terrifying Than a Cover-Up

Related Story

A Makeup Bill Is Testing Who Owns the GOP

A Makeup Bill Is Testing Who Owns the GOP

The conflict-monitoring organization ACLED recorded a 77 percent increase in U.S. demonstrations in 2025 compared with 2024, the highest annual total since 2020. Approximately 97 percent involved neither violence nor police intervention.

Yet firearms appeared at more than 50 demonstrations, over twice the previous year's number. Roughly 17 percent of those armed demonstrations became violent.

These figures do not establish that violent protests are increasing in New York, but they certainly suggest that the scale of public demonstrations has grown nationally, while a small minority still presents a serious policing problem.

Even if only a small fraction of protesters resort to violence, New York's experience in 2020—when hundreds of officers were injured and police vehicles were vandalized—makes the need for a dedicated response impossible to dismiss.

Mamdani is entitled to overhaul a unit accused of abusing its powers, but he must still account for how his replacement will confront people who assault officers, attack bystanders or destroy property.

The new Patrol Support Division may prove capable of doing so, but its existence alone offers no assurance that it can handle violence on the scale New York has already experienced.

The Case Against the Old Unit

Following the 2020 demonstrations, New York Attorney General Letitia James documented allegations of widespread excessive force, including improper arrests and retaliation against constitutionally protected expression.

The Strategic Response Group became associated with the aggressive tactics that reformers wanted eliminated.

Under Mamdani's restructuring, a civilian-led dialogue division will work to defuse tensions, alongside a 30-officer First Amendment Support Team and a new Patrol Support Division trained in crowd management. Counterterrorism responsibilities will be reassigned within the NYPD.

Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch endorsed the changes, saying she would reject any restructuring that compromised public safety. The administration says police staffing will remain unchanged.

It all makes sense: an intimidating police presence can aggravate an otherwise peaceful demonstration and if evidence shows that SRG officers used excessive force without any corresponding public-safety benefit, the case for changing their tactics becomes stronger still. But New York has also seen demonstrations turn violent, with officers injured and property destroyed.

The question for Mamdani is whether his replacement can prevent unnecessary police violence while still giving officers the training, numbers and authority to intervene when force is genuinely required.

Until those arrangements face a comparable emergency, their effectiveness remains an open question.

The Unproven Replacement

The city's investigation of the 2020 protests criticized police misconduct but also recorded the NYPD's assessment that additional officers helped curb violence and property damage. Which is all to say: in reality, it's possible that the police is using excessive force and that violent crowds may require a forceful police response.

Mamdani's new Patrol Support Division is intended to handle such disorder. But how many officers will it have? How quickly can they be deployed? What will they do when protesters begin assaulting people or destroying property?

These are questions the mayor's restructuring must answer. During the 2020 demonstrations, hundreds of NYPD officers were injured. Even if only a small minority of protesters become violent, the police still need the capacity to stop them.

Mamdani may be right that the Strategic Response Group needed to go. His replacement could prove better at protecting peaceful protesters while containing rioters, but, until the city demonstrates that capability, the central concern remains: New York has changed how it polices demonstrations without yet showing that it can handle the violence that sometimes accompanies them.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines