10

Loading video...

Jordan King

By Jordan King

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Alabama and Kansas have the most religious freedom, while Washington and Michigan have the least, according to a new report.

The Napa Legal Institute, a Catholic nonprofit that provides legal and financial education to faith-based organizations, ranked each state in its 2026 Faith and Freedom Index, released on Monday.

The rankings come as debates over the role of religion in public life continue to play out across the United States, with states increasingly diverging on policies affecting faith-based organizations, religious employers and exemptions from government regulations. Supporters of stronger religious liberty protections argue they safeguard the constitutional rights of individuals and religious institutions, while critics contend some measures can conflict with anti-discrimination laws and other civil rights protections. The new index highlights how these differing policy approaches have created a wide gap between states that prioritize religious accommodations and those that emphasize regulatory oversight and equal-access requirements.

Read More on News

Scores are based on a combination of religious freedom factors, like limitations on government interference and protections for faith-based employers, and regulatory factors, such as non-profit rules and tax exemptions.

Alabama ranked the highest with an 80 percent score, followed by Kansas with 76 percent and Indiana with 75 percent. Meanwhile, Michigan’s 34 percent placed it at the bottom, after Washington (38 percent) and Massachusetts (41 percent).

The 46-point gap between Alabama and Michigan came down to three criteria – limitations on government interference with religious practice, exemptions from non-discrimination rules for faith-based nonprofits and how much freedom religious employers have to consider faith in hiring decisions. Alabama scored 5/5 for each of these, while Michigan scored -5/5 for them.

Inside Michigan’s Low Score

Napa says that Michigan’s state laws provide “no meaningful religious accommodations or exemptions” to non-discrimination laws, meaning religious non-profits and faith-based employers are often subject to the same rules as other organizations, even if those rules conflict with their religious beliefs.

For example, a faith-based nonprofit would generally still have to abide by Michigan’s Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act, which bars organizations from denying someone services because of their sexual orientation.

Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer and other lawmakers have stood by this – in 2023 they signed into law explicit protections for sexual orientation and gender identity or expression. “Our LGBTQ+ friends, family, and neighbors deserve equal protection under the law so they can live their authentic lives, and I want everyone to know that Michigan is a place that will fight for your freedom to be yourself,” Whitmer said at the time.

Napa Legal senior counsel Frank DeVito argued that Michigan’s non-discrimination laws can make it difficult for Catholic schools and other religious organizations to make hiring decisions based on religious beliefs.

“We need religious organizations to thrive," he told Fox News. "If we are not attentive to the laws being such that these organizations can just do their work rather than spend their time and their money and their resources on administrative burdens that I think are frankly not necessary or fighting lawsuits over, you know, religious liberty issues that they shouldn't have to fight."

He said religious organizations are important as they do “needed work.”

“They educate children often in poor and disadvantaged circumstances,” DeVito said. “They feed the hungry, they help the most vulnerable people in society. They do something with the level of love and attention that the government never can.”

Newsweek contacted Whitmer’s office and the Michigan Department of Civil Rights via email for comment.

How Other States Fared

Other states that scored highly for religious freedom include Texas (71 percent), Iowa and Mississippi (69 percent), Georgia (68 percent), Wyoming and Florida (67 percent), Utah (66 percent) and Arkansas and North Carolina (64 percent).

Conversely, states that scored below 50 percent include Massachusetts (41 percent), West Virginia, Maryland and Illinois (42 percent), Hawaii (43 percent), Vermont (44 percent) and New Jersey (46 percent).

How Scores Were Calculated

Napa looked at 15 criteria in total—six religious freedom factors and nine regulatory factors. Each criterion was weighted differently and eventually converted into a percentage.

The six religious freedom factors were:

• State Constitutional Protection of Free Exercise

• State Religious Freedom Restoration Act

• Religious Freedom for Nonprofits with Public Programming

• Religious Freedom for Faith-Based Employers

• Protections for Religious Exercise During a State of Emergency

• State Blaine Amendments

The nine regulatory freedom factors were:

• Nonprofit Religious Corporation Law

• Prior Notice and Consent Requirements for Major Corporate Actions

• Standards of Conduct for Directors

• Charitable Registration Law

• Audit Requirements Pursuant to Charitable Registration

• Corporate Income Tax and Exemptions

• Sales and Use Tax and Exemptions – Nonprofit Sales

• Sales and Use Tax and Exemptions – Nonprofit Purchases

• Property Tax and Exemptions

What's Next

The index is likely to become part of ongoing policy debates in state legislatures, where lawmakers continue to weigh religious-liberty protections against other regulatory and civil-rights priorities. Future changes to employment, education and nonprofit laws could affect how states rank in subsequent editions of the report.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Tobias Meyjes, Gray R. Thomas

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines