
...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Rhode Island has the highest number of so-called "lemon" homes in the country, according to a new study by nationwide moving network MovingPlace.
These are properties that often hide bitter surprises for buyers, including costly repairs and maintenance work for problems that are overlooked during inspections or are left unresolved in the sales process. These issues can drag on for years, weighing on their new owners’ finances.
It can be hard to identify a "lemon" home before buying one. On social media platforms like Reddit, U.S. homebuyers exchange their experiences purchasing a "lemon" home and having their lives "ruined" by it. Some bought flipped homes, others new properties—and yet they all ended up facing issues that soured their dream of homeownership and cost them thousands of dollars they did not plan on spending.
Read More on News
What Do We Mean When We Talk About ‘Lemon’ Homes?
To identify "lemon" homes in its study, MovingPlace looked at proprietary data from PGM’s Home Factors data set, which has insights covering approximately 90 percent of residential properties nationwide. The data, updated as of August 1, tracks the presence of common property issues, such as water damage, roofing needs, and foundation problems.
Using this information, MovingPlace calculated the share of homes with known issues in each state and across the 200 largest metropolitan areas in the country. These incidence rates were then converted into point values to allow for standardized comparisons across geographies, and these were then aggregated into a composite score to produce a ranking of states and metros.
Where Do Homeowners Face the Highest Risk of Buying a ‘Lemon’ Home?
The states with the highest risk of buying a "lemon" home are those where homebuyers are likely to face the most hidden—often major—issues after buying a property.
These are, according to MovingPlace's analysis:
- Rhode Island, with a lemon home risk of 86/100
Half the homes identified in Rhode Island by MovingPlace have foundation issues, while 86 percent have window problems, which can be a sign of widespread structural and exterior challenges. Plumbing and electrical issues are slightly less common, with 42 percent of "lemon" homes in the state needing electrical wiring repairs, 77 percent having plumbing pipe concerns, and 46 percent roof issues.
- Ohio, with a lemon home risk of 81/100
Ohio has a high number of homes with both structural and water-related issues, according to MovingPlace. Some 54 percent of homes have foundation problems, 36 percent need roof repairs, and 75 percent present water intrusion in lower levels. Additionally, 47 percent of the homes are in need of electrical wiring repairs and 60 percent need plumbing work done.
- Massachusetts, with a lemon home risk of 77/100
The main problems with Massachusetts homes have to do with plumbing and roofing. Eighty percent of these homes in the state have plumbing problems, 38 percent need roof repairs, and 80 percent show water damage in some areas. About 48 percent have electrical issues.
- Connecticut, with a lemon home risk of 75/100
Eighty-two percent of homes identified by MovingPlace in Connecticut experience water intrusion, 41 percent require roof repairs, and 81 percent have plumbing issues.
- Iowa, with a lemon home risk of 72/100
Over half the homes in Iowa have foundation problems, the highest in the country at 56 percent, according to MovingPlace. Some 70 percent have window issues, and 27 percent need roof repairs. Some 66 percent of the homes show signs of water intrusion in some areas of the property, especially in the kitchen (22 percent).
- New York, with a lemon home risk of 68/100
New York has the highest share of homes with plumbing issues, at 83 percent. On top of that, 30 percent of the homes require roof repairs, and 69 percent show window repair or replacement needs.
- Pennsylvania, with a lemon home risk of 66/100
Over two-thirds of homes in Pennsylvania need plumbing repairs, according to MovingPlace’s analysis, 67 percent require window work, and 68 percent show some form of water intrusion.
- Indiana, with a lemon home risk of 65/100
Forty-three percent of homes in Indiana need wiring repairs, while 41 percent have foundation issues, and 54 percent have water intrusion in the top level of the house.
- West Virginia, with a lemon home risk of 65/100
Almost half the homes (49 percent) in the state have foundation problems, 22 percent need roof repairs, and 75 percent show water intrusion at some level.
- Michigan, with a lemon home risk of 60/100
A majority of 66 percent of homes in the state are affected by hydraulic problems; 65 percent report water intrusion.

...
What Do These Places Have in Common?
Many of the states with the highest risk for homebuyers to find a "lemon" home are in the Rust Belt, a region spanning from the Midwest and Great Lakes. These states have a higher stock of older, industrial-era homes than others, due to their historical development—and the weather is not clement on them.
The coastal location of states like Rhode Island and New York brings about that sort of high humidity that can be damaging to properties, especially older ones. Ohio has cold winters characterized often by heavy snow which can be brutal for homes in older urban neighborhoods like Cleveland and Columbus.
States like Connecticut and Indiana present a combination of seasonal extremes, with icy winters and summer storms.
Homebuyers shopping around in these states should carefully study listings to see what regional risks properties are exposed to, how old they are, and what kind of hidden defects they might have. Experts also advise against skipping the inspection, considering instead hiring specialty inspectors which could flag any potential risks.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines