10

Loading video...

By Suzanne Blake

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.

The larger state of unemployment and the economy could become key issues in several of the Senate races that Democrats hope will help them win back control of the chamber in the upcoming midterms.

The battleground includes six states with vastly different labor market conditions—five where Democrats are aiming to flip Republican-held seats (Alaska, Iowa, Maine, Ohio and Texas), and one key battleground, Michigan, where they are defending an open seat.

While Iowa, Maine and Ohio currently have unemployment rates well below the national average, Michigan, Texas and Alaska are all running hotter than the U.S. rate, according to the latest Bureau of Labor Statistics data.

Read More on Politics

Voters in states with historically low unemployment may be more focused on inflation and wages going into the midterms, while candidates in states where joblessness is higher are confronting questions about layoffs and the broader direction of the economy.

“What strikes me about these races is that unemployment is not really the economic language of the 2026 campaign. Jobs still matter enormously, but the old political shorthand around unemployment has lost some of its power,” Matt Watkins, the CEO of Watkins Public Affairs, told Newsweek.

“For decades, a campaign could point to low unemployment, strong GDP growth, or a booming stock market and make a fairly straightforward argument: the economy is doing well. But does a low unemployment rate mean much to someone who has a job and still cannot afford rent, groceries, health care, or child care?”

Why It Matters

Economic concerns consistently rank among voters' top issues, and unemployment is one of the clearest indicators of a state's economic health.

The latest BLS figures showed the national unemployment rate was 4.1 percent in August, unchanged from July.

Republicans have pointed to low unemployment in several states as evidence that the economy remains resilient, while Democrats are looking at layoffs and concerns about job security in manufacturing- and energy-dependent regions as proof that Congress needs to move in a different direction.

Michigan, Texas and Alaska all have unemployment rates above the national average, which could make economic concerns more salient during the midterms.

Which Battleground States Have the Highest Unemployment?

Among the six states at the center of major Senate races, Michigan currently has the highest unemployment rate at 5 percent.

Battleground State Unemployment Rates

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

The gap is notable because three of the states Democrats are targeting are operating in very different labor markets.

Michigan's 5.0 percent unemployment rate is nearly two percentage points higher than Iowa's 3.2 percent rate.

“I would be careful about making unemployment itself the story across these races. The states aren't moving in one direction, and in several cases unemployment has actually declined. What may matter more politically is the gap between the unemployment rate and people's lived experience of the labor market,” Tara Furiani, CEO of Not the HR Lady and SAIL for Leaders, who was also a former Chief People Officer for 16 years, told Newsweek.

“Someone can technically be employed and still feel economically insecure. They may have spent months looking for a better job, watched colleagues get laid off, seen hiring freezes at their company, taken work below their skill level, or discovered that the salary they could command a few years ago isn't available anymore. None of that necessarily shows up cleanly in the unemployment rate.”

...

Have Conditions Improved Since Trump's Second Term Began?

While economic conditions vary by state, unemployment generally has been relatively low by historical standards.

However, Michigan, Texas and Alaska now sit above the national unemployment rate, while Iowa, Maine and Ohio remain below it, marking very different economic backdrops for the Senate races.

"Unemployment is a great indicator, but you can't treat it alone as a major driver of how people are going to vote because they are likely to take into consideration a lot of other factors like job availability, salary, hiring/layoff trends and the cost of living, rather than if the unemployment rate has moved up or down,” Matthew Marks, the co-founder and partner at New York-based employment legal firm Ricotta & Marks, P.C., told Newsweek.

Layoffs Could Become a Campaign Issue

Layoffs have continued to affect major employers over the last few years, especially in the manufacturing and tech sectors.

“I wouldn't assume voters are walking into a voting booth thinking, ‘My state's unemployment rate is 4.4 percent,’” Furiani said. “They're much more likely to be thinking: Can I find a good job? Can my kids find one? Do I feel secure in the job I have? Is my paycheck actually keeping up with my life?”

Michigan, a state with heavy automotive exposure, is especially vulnerable to manufacturing downturns.

This year, Spirit Airlines filed a WARN notice affecting 643 workers in Detroit, while General Motors also filed a notice affecting 350 workers in the Lansing region.

Texas has also experienced workforce cuts across several industries despite its continued population and business growth.

Chevron announced plans last year to lay off 799 workers in Midland County as part of a broader effort to reduce up to 20 percent of its global workforce by the end of 2026.

This year, Tyson Foods also filed a warning for layoffs of more than 3,500 workers in its Amarillo operations.

“The stock market provides a useful parallel. Politicians have long treated a rising market as shorthand for prosperity. But a record S&P 500 means relatively little to a renter whose housing costs keep rising, a family spending more on groceries and health care, or a worker wondering whether AI will eliminate part of their occupation,” Watkins said.

“Both things can be true at once: the traditional indicators can look strong while people remain deeply dissatisfied with their economic circumstances.”

Swing-State Unemployment Rates vs. National Average

Above U.S. Average (4.1 percent)

• Michigan: 5.0 percent
• Texas: 4.4 percent
• Alaska: 4.3 percent

Below U.S. Average (4.1 percent)

• Ohio: 3.3 percent
• Maine: 3.2 percent
• Iowa: 3.2 percent

Despite some of the more positive unemployment rates, Furiani said politicians could get themselves into trouble by treating a relatively low unemployment rate as proof that workers feel good about the economy.

“I've spent decades talking to employees, candidates and executives, and people experience the economy personally before they experience it statistically,” Furiani said.

“So will unemployment influence voting? Potentially... I would frame the issue more broadly as employment security and economic confidence rather than unemployment alone. The political question isn't simply whether someone has a job. It's whether they believe good jobs are available, whether their own employment feels secure, and whether working is allowing them to build the life they expected.”

When Does Midterm Election Voting Begin?

The 2026 midterm elections will be held on November 3, but voting in many states begins well before Election Day through absentee and early-voting periods.

Deadlines vary by state, but Senate candidates are likely to continue emphasizing economic issues around unemployment and job growth as they make their final pitch to voters.

"As a shop teacher's son, I learned how to get my hands dirty and earn my paycheck," Republican Michigan senatorial candidate Mike Rogers said in a recent ad. "Then, something happened in America. Politicians started looking down on the trades. College debt soared. And now, we have six-figure jobs that companies like Ford can't fill. Let's put shop class back in every high school and train our kids for real jobs—jobs AI can't eliminate. Jobs China can't steal."

Maine Democratic candidate Troy Dale Jackson has also centered his campaign on the working class.

“Working people are getting crushed while billionaires and corporations buy power in Washington,” he said previously. “I’ve spent my life fighting that same rigged system—from the logging woods to the Maine Senate.”

What Happens Next

With just weeks remaining before voters begin casting ballots in some states, candidates will likely intensify their focus on economic issues as a final plea to Americans.

If unemployment stays elevated in states like Michigan, Texas and Alaska, Democrats could effectively argue that voters need a check on the White House and congressional Republicans.

But Republicans could likewise argue that unemployment remains historically low in much of the country.

“When the middle and working class are essentially living in economic serfdom because we have an administration lurching from crisis to crisis, that’s (unemployment) the least of those worries,” political strategist Christopher Lee told Newsweek.

“What voters feel right now is the price of groceries, gas and health care and a paycheck nowhere near what it takes to cover those costs. And Dems are running on costs and the failure of this administration nor a GOP-controlled Congress to do anything about it.”

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Anna Skinner and Emma Lee-Sang

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines