10

Loading video...

Billal Rahman

By Billal Rahman

Immigration Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A federal judge has ordered the Trump administration to release a migrant who was taken into immigration custody after being mugged in Minnesota in an attack that fractured his skull and cheekbones.

U.S. District Judge Jeffrey M. Bryan ruled that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) unlawfully detained Yener Alexander Garcia Ruiz, 48, finding several problems with his arrest, including markedly different officer signatures appearing on two immigration documents.

The signatures appeared alongside the same surname, "Trevino," and identifying number, "10924," on an ICE administrative arrest warrant and a separate immigration record.

Read More on News

"These obvious differences cast doubt on who the serving officer was," Bryan wrote in his November 19, 2026, order.

ICE agents stand guard in front of protesters outside Delaney Hall which is being used as an Immigration and Customs Enforcement detention center on May 26, 2026 in Newark, New Jersey.

...

The judge found the warrant invalid because the government failed to identify who served it or show that the person was authorized to do so.

Bryan ordered the government to release Garcia Ruiz immediately and without conditions, no later than 4 p.m. Central Time on November 20, according to court filings.

Federal judges have emerged as a key check on the Trump administration’s mass deportation campaign, with courts finding that ICE violated due-process protections for immigrants and, in some cases, flouted court orders. Courts have ordered migrants freed after finding that immigration authorities unlawfully detained them or failed to provide required due-process protections.

Garcia Ruiz entered the U.S. near Sasabe, Arizona, in August 2023. Border Patrol detained him but released him after confirming his identity and that he had no criminal record, according to court filings.

He has a pending asylum application, has attended his immigration hearings, and has two misdemeanor traffic citations, according to court papers.

Garcia Ruiz was mugged and struck in the head and face with a pistol on September 25. The assault fractured his skull and cheekbones, and his phone, passport, and other identification were stolen, according to the court filings.

He later went to the Otter Tail County Sheriff's Office for help, where authorities discovered an outstanding warrant over a missed court appearance for a driving citation. He posted $400 bail and was released around September 27, but an ICE agent took him into immigration custody as he was leaving the jail.

The administration later argued that Garcia Ruiz was subject to mandatory immigration detention. But the judge found that ICE had originally detained him under a different section of immigration law.

"This Court concludes that Respondents cannot now change the basis for the detention of Yener G.," Bryan wrote.

Judge Bryan also questioned the evidence used to support the arrest warrant, saying the government did not explain what records ICE relied on or provide enough information about statements Garcia Ruiz allegedly made during a phone interview.

He said the record lacked information about the officer’s Spanish fluency and Garcia Ruiz’s condition during the interview after suffering skull and facial fractures.

The judge also found no evidence that officers identified themselves or told Garcia Ruiz why he was being arrested, saying the government "violated the plain requirements" of federal regulations.

Bryan also said the government failed to justify the detention as a warrantless arrest. "Here, Respondents make no argument whatsoever that officers satisfied either prong" of the law, he wrote.

"For each of these independent reasons, the detention of Yener G. is unlawful and immediate release is the appropriate remedy," Bryan wrote.

The Trump administration has been ordered to confirm Garcia Ruiz’s release by November 23 and tell the court when and where he was released.

Newsweek contacted the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), ICE, and Garcia Ruiz’s legal team for comment via email.

Since the administration launched widespread deportation operations nationwide, judges have launched scathing attacks on immigration authorities in several cases. One judge blocked ICE from searching an immigration lawyer’s phone, while another accused the agency of "cruelty" after ICE arrested a migrant moments after the judge ordered him released. In a separate case, a judge called additional ICE agents to testify amid concerns that agents could be "willing to lie" under oath.

A federal judge demanded answers from the Department of Homeland Security after a teenager was deported despite a court order and later found DHS in contempt and ordered the teenager returned to the United States.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: John Fitzpatrick and Trevor Davies.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines