
...

By Lydia Patrick
Life & Trends Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Reddit has rallied behind a pregnant woman who refuses to name her unborn baby after her late brother, despite her family's wishes.
The 28-year-old woman, u/Pitiful-Rate-8266, shared her dilemma in the subreddit "AITAH [Am I The A*****]," where it garnered 10,000 upvotes. She explained how her mom had suggested naming her son after her brother, Ethan, who died in a car accident at age 20.
"While it was tragic, he and I were not close," the OP explained. "In fact, he bullied me a lot growing up, calling me names, mocking my interests, and even getting physical a few times. My parents always brushed it off as 'siblings being siblings,' but it left me with a lot of resentment. When my mom suggested we name the baby Ethan, I politely said no. She got upset and said it would be a beautiful way to honor my brother's memory."
Read More on Life

...
The couple had already decided on a name they both loved. When OP explained how she felt about Ethan, her mom accused her of being "cold-hearted" and "disrespecting the dead," with other family members also calling her selfish.
"My husband is completely supportive of my decision and says it's our baby, so the name should reflect what we want, not what others want. But now I'm starting to wonder if I'm being unfair to my mom, who's clearly still grieving. AITA for refusing to name my son after my late brother?" she asked Reddit.
The post has since been removed from the site.
Expert Insight
Kristin Anderson, a licensed psychotherapist, explained that the OP's mother is likely seeking a way to cope with grief.
She told Newsweek: "It's not surprising that OP's mother probably still has profound and lingering pain, and that she's looking for some sort of symbolic gestures, like naming a baby, as a way to cope, find meaning, or maintain a connection with her son.
"However, even if OP were to name her son after her late brother, it wouldn't resolve her mother's grief or heal the pain of such a devastating loss. What's really needed is space for her mother—and perhaps the entire family—to examine and process their grief, even if that means confronting feelings they may be avoiding."
Dr. Max Doshay, a licensed psychologist and CEO of Monima Wellness, gave further insight into name-giving more generally.
He told Newsweek: "When picking a name for a child, parents not only think about their preferences but also have to manage the pressure from their wider family who, for example, want to continue their family tradition or name newborn children in memory of someone. That's why picking a name is not the easiest task, after all.
"The bigger the family, the more difficult it will be to navigate between all suggestions and pick a name that everyone will be happy with. That's why it's important to set boundaries from the very beginning. I advise parents to recognize and thank their family for their help and reminders about traditions and cultural heritage, but they also need to leave the name choice only to them and their partner."
Reddit Reacts
Reddit users were quick to support the OP with her decision.
"No, you're entitled to name your son whatever you want to. Definitely NTA," said one user.
"NTA in any capacity. It's weird that your family are insisting that you name your child something because of 'how much it would mean to your mother'—your child is not a tribute or a shrine," another viewer chimed in.
"NTA. Since your parents preferred your brother, naming your child after him could lead to a very unhealthy situation there," added another commenter.
Newsweek reached out to u/Pitiful-Rate-8266 for comment via Reddit, but the account has since been suspended. We could not verify the details of the case.
If you have a family dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines