
INA FASSBENDER/AFP via Getty Images

By Suzanne Blake
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A new report suggests that a number of items have not dropped to historical low prices during Amazon’s annual Prime Day.
According to a recently released analysis from Visualping—an automated site that analyzes webpages to detect changes—looking at price histories for approximately 2,500 Amazon US products from May 22 to June 23, the vast majority of items did not see new lowest prices on Prime Day.
Fewer than 13 percent of discounted products in the analysis hit a new low during the sales event.
Read More on Business
A spokesperson for Amazon told Newsweek the report was based on a "misleading" analysis of deals that are not related to the Prime Day event.
"This report willfully ignores the facts by not even analyzing Prime Day deals, and its claims about Prime Day deal quality are categorically false," a spokesperson for the company told Newsweek. "It is based on a misleading analysis of a limited third-party dataset that examined approximately 2,500 products—a tiny fraction of the hundreds of millions of items in our store."
Why It Matters
Prime Day is widely marketed as one of the biggest shopping events of the year, often encouraging consumers to act quickly to secure limited-time savings.
“Prime Day is not primarily a ‘new lowest price’ event,” the report said in a release of its findings. “Many discounts reflect previous promotional price floors rather than new reductions. A substantial share of products were actually cheaper at some point before Prime Day.”
What To Know
The report, which tracked pricing data for roughly 2,500 products sold on Amazon in the lead-up to Prime Day 2026, found that most discounts on those products fell into one of two categories: prices that the item had already appeared at, or prices that remained higher than earlier lows.
Among the roughly 1,070 products that the report said had price changes on Prime Day:
- 12.5 percent were what they called “genuine deals,” reaching a new low recorded price.
- 44.7 percent matched previous promotional lows.
- 42.8 percent were priced higher than earlier low points.

...
Overall, more than 87 percent of price changes analyzed did not represent a new low, according to the report.
"Identifying genuine deals versus fake discounts during major sales like Prime Day can be very challenging without a price tracking tool,” Serge Salager, the CEO of Visualping, told Newsweek.
“Consumers should focus on categories with the best deals, like health and beauty, and do some research by comparing to other retailers before buying electronic and tech products from Amazon this week simply because they appear discounted."
A spokesperson for Amazon pushed back on the report, saying that it "conflates products that saw any price reduction with those that are clearly labeled Prime Day deals."
"Prime Day deals are clearly identified for customers, subject to strict requirements, and designed to deliver meaningful savings," the company spokesperson told Newsweek. "We also provide customers with verified reference prices and year-round price tracking features so customers can shop with confidence.
The company said more than 80 percent of Prime Day deals are at their lowest price of the year so far, with hundreds of thousands of deals discounted by 40 percent or more.
Where Deals Were Weakest
Not all product categories performed equally.
The report found the highest share of “not genuine deals,” meaning prices were higher than previously observed lows, in the following categories:
- Movies & TV: 66.7 percent
- Toys & Games: 64.3 percent
- Industrial & Scientific: 61.5 percent
In those categories, most cuts on Prime Day did not improve on earlier low prices.
By contrast, some categories showed relatively stronger deal quality, with fewer inflated discounts:
- Health & Personal Care: 20 percent not genuine
- Camera & Photo: 25 percent
- Beauty & Personal Care: 26.3 percent
“These findings are to be expected when you're dealing with companies whose primary goal is profit maximization. It's a classic example of anchoring bias,” Kevin Thompson, the CEO of 9i Capital Group and the host of the 9innings podcast, told Newsweek.
“A retailer shows you a product marked down from a higher price, making it feel like a bargain, even though the same item may have been selling for less just days or weeks earlier. The discount grabs your attention, but it isn't always the deal you think it is.”
While the dataset included only products with available pricing history and does not represent Amazon’s full pricing ecosystem, most discounts with the information available were revealed to be repeats of past promotions or, at times, even less competitive than earlier pricing.
Across the board, fewer than 1 in 8 Prime Day price changes represented a true new low price.
“Consumers need to remember that Amazon is a for-profit business, not a nonprofit. Its job is to maximize revenue, and it's exceptionally good at it. Whether it's dynamic pricing or behavioral psychology, Amazon understands how people shop,” Thompson said.
“Prime Day can absolutely have real bargains, but don't assume every ‘deal’ is actually a deal.”
What This Means for Shoppers
Experts say consumers should generally not assume Prime Day offers the lowest price of the year, and instead, they should check the price history tools before purchasing.
“It's always wise to use price history features to see what the past cost trajectory of an item is before feeling the rush to purchase during the current event,” Alex Beene, a literacy instructor for the University of Tennessee at Martin, told Newsweek. “Doing so could be the difference between saving a few dollars and actually paying the true lowest price.”
What Happens Next
While the report provides a snapshot of pricing during the 2026 Amazon Prime Day event, there could be larger issues around price transparency in retail, Beene said.
“These promotions are typically used to draw attention and a sense of urgency to making purchases rather than actually providing the lowest price,” Beene said.
“While many customers use Amazon routinely, few more than likely search the storefront daily for pricing changes and don't realize that some prices this week may either match the previous lowest amount or be slightly above past costs.”
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Gray R. Thomas
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines