10
Loading video...

By Khaleda Rahman
National Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The family of a man murdered in Wisconsin more than 25 years ago is urging Governor Tony Evers to reject a commutation request from his killer that could lead to his release.
Matthew Schumacher, 44, is serving a life sentence after being convicted in the December 1999 killing of Frank Lawrence Fazio, a restaurant owner and married father of four. The 52-year-old was beaten with a baseball bat and stabbed in the apartment above his restaurant in Sugar Creek Township, according to court records.
Schumacher, who was 17 at the time, was among four people charged and convicted in Fazio’s death. He was tried as an adult and sentenced in September 2000 to life imprisonment and a consecutive 55 years of conferment.
Read More on News
His application for a commutation is due to be heard by the governor’s Commutation Advisory Board on Friday morning.

...
Fazio’s eldest son, Jack Fazio, 50, told Newsweek ahead of the hearing that the possibility that Schumacher could have his sentence reduced and be released has reopened his family’s wounds.
"To think that this less-than-human animal might be let loose is just unfathomable," he said. "It's just shocking. Just shocking. And this is bringing it all back out."
Friday’s hearing for Schumacher and other applicants comes a week after Evers, a Democrat, announced commutations for 14 people, marking the first time a Wisconsin governor has issued commutations since 1995. The crimes involved include homicide and armed robbery and five were convicted when they under 18.
All 14 of those people had their commutations recommended to the governor by the Commutation Advisory Board after hearings over the summer, according to Wisconsin Public Radio. Evers denied the commutation applications for 10 others who had hearings before the board.
Evers reinstated the state’s commutation process and created the new Commutation Advisory Board in April, allowing inmates to apply to have their sentences shortened for the first time in decades.
It’s not clear when Evers could make a decision on Schumacher’s application. But a spokesperson for the governor previously told Wisconsin Watch that he intends to approve or deny every application that receives a hearing before he leaves office in January. Democrat David Crowley will be the state’s next governor, after defeating Republican Representative Tom Tiffany earlier in November.
Newsweek has contacted the governor’s office for comment via email. Crowley’s transition team has been contacted for comment via email.
‘Traumatized All Over Again’
Fazio's sister, Carmella Daly, 76, told Newsweek that she learned that her brother’s killer could be released after Republican state senator Van Wanggaard released a report in April, warning that Evers’ plan could lead to the early release of Schumacher and other inmates who were handed sentences of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole for murders they committed as teenagers.
Daly, of East Troy, Wisconsin, said the news brought back feelings she thought had been buried decades ago.
"I was traumatized all over again about the idea that this person could possibly be out in the streets," she said.
Daly recalled the relief she had felt when Schumacher was sentenced.
"That day, that such a relief came over my body when I heard the judge say that he was going to get life without the possibility of parole. I thought those words meant something. I really believed it, you know.
"And after all these years to have it turned around or have the possibility of it turning around, it just ripped my heart out all over again."
She launched a Change petition, calling on Evers and the board to reject Schumacher’s application.
"Frank was taken from us in the most heinous way possible, beaten with a bat and stabbed 20 times," the petition says. "Schumacher was 17 years and 8 months old, nearly an adult, when he committed this horrific act and was tried as an adult. His sentencing, life without the possibility of parole, reflected the magnitude of his crime. He caused irrevocable loss to our family and poses a danger to society."
As of Friday, the petition has garnered more than 8,600 signatures.
Daly said her message to Evers is to ask him why he would consider commuting the sentence of someone who committed such a brutal crime.
She said Schumacher showed no signs of remorse in court.
"We went to a year-and-a-half of court hearings and went to court for the sentencing that day," she said. "There was never a sign of remorse, never."
She added: "There’s no way I would feel safe for him to be out on the streets. I’m concerned that he's going to do it again."

...
A Profound Loss
Jack Fazio said his father’s murder had a profound impact on him and his three siblings, as well as their mother.
"They were high school sweethearts. She was never with another man her entire life. Never, until the day she died," he said. "It just destroyed her."
He said his father’s murder also altered the trajectory of his and his siblings’ lives.
"Talk about the butterfly effect that this had on each and every one of our four lives," he said. "You can't even put into words, how it altered the path of all of our lives. It just devastated all of our lives."
Daly said she believes the murder of her only sibling led to the deaths of both of her parents. Her mother died in June 2007, followed by her father that August.
"My mother was brokenhearted over my brother. My father was brokenhearted over losing his son and my mother," she said. "I'd heard about people dying of broken hearts, but I'd never thought I'd witness it in real life."
She said her brother was someone who had been a pillar of the community and helped those he could.
He had hired Schumacher to work at his restaurant, Daly said.
"He knew he was a troubled kid but he was trying to help him," she said.
She said the possibility of a commutation for Schumacher had prompted her to reopen a box of old newspaper clippings about the case, which featured interviews with people who described her brother as a mentor.
"I didn’t realize that he had such an impact on the community, being a restaurant owner. He did a lot of nice things for a lot of people," she said.

...
Why Evers Revived Clemency Process
Evers signed an executive order creating the Commutation Advisory Board in April as part of an effort to reinstate the state’s process for issuing commutations amid his wider efforts to reform the justice system.
Evers also signed an executive order establishing a separate "Juvenile Life Sentence Commutation Process" for juveniles who were sentenced to life imprisonment.
His executive order cited scientific research into adolescent brain development and the U.S. Supreme Court's 2012 decision in Miller v. Alabama, arguing that those who committed crimes in their youth have "increased potential for rehabilitation, a diminished degree of culpability, and a lower chance of reoffending once they have reached maturity."
His office said the board must consider several things when evaluating commutation applications, including the impact of a commutation on victims, survivors and members of the community; whether it would threaten public safety; the applicant’s prison conduct record and their personal growth and development since conviction.
His office said applicants must have served at least half their sentence, or at least 20 years of a life sentence and have a record of rehabilitation and good behavior during their time in prison.
Evers has framed the revival of the commutations process as part of his effort to reform the justice system to improve public safety, reduce costs to taxpayers, lower rates of recidivism and stabilize the state’s prison population.
"Wisconsin cannot wait for criminal justice reforms," Evers said in April. "As our prison population continues to skyrocket, increasing costs to taxpayers on overtime and other resource needs, the Legislature must start working toward making long-term justice and corrections reforms a priority, including efforts to help stabilize our state’s prison population that our institutions already are struggling to accommodate."
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Matthew Cannon and Tony Phillips.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines