
...
By Sybil Adelman Sage
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Curious if there were surprises in my past, I sent saliva to a DNA site and received a message from a stranger named Ruth, saying, "My grandfather Sam was your biological father." Clearly, she was trying to prepare me, as this was preceded by several messages that were less candid.
"My husband is a physician," she wrote this time, "and his cousin is a molecular biologist. They each concluded from the amount of DNA you and I share that my father was your half-brother and I'm your half-niece." Despite her sensitivity, this wasn't breaking news—it was heartbreaking news. I would have argued that my parents were extremely conventional and that this was impossible if her last name wasn't the same as their best friend, Sam.
Devastated, I needed the mother I'd lost years ago more than ever. She'd helped me through many crises. "You do the right thing," she would hug her toddler daughter after a hurtful incident. "It's his loss," she'd insist to me, the teenager whining over a guy's rejection. To end my agonizing at our wedding that the caterer used the wrong chairs, she whispered, "Nobody cares." The words were unconvincing, but her desire to comfort me had been a panacea. She was my rock, the one I counted on to bandage every wound.
Read More on My Turn
My father, hearing impaired because of a childhood case of scarlet fever, showed his love with his eyes. He died eight years after she did. Anyone who might have been aware of the situation with Sam was dead. I was on my own to cope with this.
I took a second, more careful, look at the genetics report, scrolling down to where it showed that the 11.49 percent DNA Ruth and I shared was meaningful and that of the over a thousand relatives linked to me, not one was an "Adelman," my surname, two findings I'd ignored.
"The tests showed that my father wasn't my biological dad," I told my husband, Martin. He pointed out that Joe and Jack, my brothers, fraternal twins eight years older than I was, looked like my father while I didn't. "Are you sorry you know?" Martin asked.
"I'm sorry I don't know more," I answered, frustrated that my questions would never be answered. Ruth and I started exchanging messages, hoping to make sense of this. She mentioned seeing an online video of me, noting some resemblance to her family, adding that she and I had both worked in television and that our sons had physical features in common.

...
She lived two hours away and agreed to come to dinner with her husband, Rob. "Do you think your father knew your mother was having an affair with Sam?" she asked. I shrugged. That was everyone's first question and my biggest fear. "Now that you've found out," my newly acquired half-niece wanted to know, "can you recall anything that would have been a clue?"
Long before this story surfaced, my mother said something that struck me as peculiar. Recovering from abdominal surgery in her late seventies, she'd told me, "The problem might have resulted from my carrying twins." Maybe because it was our first adult conversation, I seized on the opportunity to ask if my brothers and I were her only pregnancies though I had no reason to imagine she had any secrets. "Let me think," she said, avoiding giving me an answer. A woman her age forgets a name or where she left her eyeglasses, but not a pregnancy. Her response was so weird, I repeated it to Martin the moment I got home.
"What she said puzzled me," I told Ruth. Now it seems likely my question triggered her to think about the secret she'd been keeping from me and consider confessing, then decided not to." DNA wasn't an issue during her lifetime, so she didn't expect the truth would come out, nor did she appreciate the relevance of one's medical history.
Wasn't I entitled to the truth? I've wanted to scream in the three years since the disclosure, but my mother wasn't around to hear it. It's conceivable she wasn't certain whose child I was, but she could have been honest about that. What this changed eluded me though it was unnerving and raised trust issues. I was indignant and self-righteous until I realized it would have been far worse for everyone if I'd heard this at an earlier age from my mother. Whatever the explanation, I'd have been burdened with a staggering amount of anger or compassion. I'm sure I'd have probed and likely created a family crisis.
Martin wanted to know what I'd have done in her situation. I had to admit I'd not revealed to her when I dated someone of a different religion, that another boyfriend was twenty years older and didn't let her know that the guy she said would be a good husband was cheating on his wife. Okay, so maybe honesty can be tempered by discretion. Living with a monumental secret couldn't have been easy for my mother, who wasn't in the habit of thinking before she spoke. She might well have been protecting not only herself, but everyone else she loved. The resentment I'd been harboring was replaced by gratitude.
Trying to come to grips with the new reality, I felt I was channeling my mother, whose resilience I was lucky enough to get. I also attributed my gregariousness to her and the ability to return items, like bathing suits, that aren't returnable. Determining whose genetics I'd received was now more complicated though my love of comedy surely came from my father. He liked nothing better than a hilarious joke.
Sam may have been responsible for my fear of heights or distaste for cilantro, but it's also conceivable his genes made me bold enough to pursue a career as a comedy writer when it was impossible if you weren't named Mel, Mort or Mickey. To make me comfortable about his part in this, I chose to see him as the poodle who'd contributed some genes to the breeding process.
I realized this was my parents' story, not mine, and that forgiving a dead person is the gift that keeps on giving—if only to yourself. I knew I'd succeeded when I joked to Ruth, "I'm a born again—literally." The big perk was gaining two terrific friends—Ruth and her husband, Rob.
Oddly, I was physically and emotionally more like Ruth than any other family member. Prior to meeting, she'd said to me, "Do you think we'll feel close to each other immediately?"
"What you asked," I responded, "makes me sure we will." And we did. Like a script, life is constantly being rewritten. It would be naïve to think this is the final draft.
Sybil Sage is working on a book about being one of the first women to break into scriptwriting. Among her credits are The Mary Tyler Moore Show, Maude, Alice, Barney Miller, Growing Pains and Northern Exposure. She received an Emmy nomination and Writers Guild of America for a special starring Lily Tomlin. Her essays have been in The New York Times, The Boston Globe, The Forward, Redbook, Good Housekeeping, The Paris Review and many other publications.
All views expressed are the author's own.
Do you have a unique experience or personal story to share? See our Reader Submissions Guide and then email the My Turn team at myturn@newsweek.com.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines