WASHINGTON, DC – APRIL 10: Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) walks off the House floor before a vote on the Republican budget plan at the U.S. Capitol on April 10, 2025 in Washington, DC. U.S. Speaker of the House Mike Johnson (R-LA) said that U.S. President Donald Trump didn’t get involved in getting support from fiscally conservative Republican members who were against the plan. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

...

Anna Commander

By Anna Commander

News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Republican Congresswoman Nancy Mace of South Carolina said she thinks that former Democratic Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi was a "more effective" leader than any Republican has been "this century."

Newsweek also reached out to GOP Speaker Mike Johnson's office via email on Monday for comment.

Why It Matters

Recent statements by Republican lawmakers, including Mace and Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia, highlight significant turmoil and introspection within the House Republican caucus as the party faces impending retirements, and a looming midterm challenge.

Read More on News

Both GOP figures have publicly recognized Pelosi's effectiveness as a legislative leader—an uncommon acknowledgment amid deeply divided partisan politics. These remarks arrive as a wave of retirements threaten the party's razor-thin House majority, compounding existing fissures over policy and strategy under Johnson.

What To Know

In an opinion piece in The New York Times on Monday, Mace critiqued the U.S. House’s procedural dysfunction and contrasted it with the leadership once exercised by Pelosi.

Mace said in part: "Here’s a hard truth Republicans don’t want to hear: Nancy Pelosi was a more effective House speaker than any Republican this century. I agree with her on essentially nothing. But she understood something we don’t: No majority is permanent. When Democrats hold the majority, they ram through the most progressive policies they can. They deliver for the coalition that elected them while they are in power."

"Republicans do the opposite. We get the majority, then become petrified of losing it. We pass the most moderate policies we can pressure conservatives to accept, betraying the coalition that delivered us here. Ms. Pelosi was ruthless, but she got things done," Mace added.

The South Carolina Republican also detailed how the current system lacks accountability and regularly sidelines rank-and-file voices. Mace wrote, “Leaders of both parties have systematically silenced rank-and-file voices.” She noted the collapse of open rules and meaningful amendment processes under multiple Congresses, emphasizing a trend that has spanned decades but has not been reversed—and has at times worsened—under the current leadership.

"Speaker Mike Johnson is better than his predecessor. But the frustrations of being a rank-and-file House member are compounded as certain individuals or groups remain marginalized within the party, getting little say," Mace said.

U.S. Republican Representative Nancy Mace of South Carolina walks off the House floor before a vote on the Republican budget plan at the U.S. Capitol on April 10 in Washington, D.C. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

...

Greene, who recently announced her retirement, went further in a televised interview. Appearing on CNN in November, Greene said, "I served under [Pelosi’s] speakership in my first term of Congress, and I’m very impressed at her ability to get things done. I wish we could get things done for our party like Nancy Pelosi was able to deliver for her party.” She acknowledged Pelosi’s “incredible career for her party” and also stated in part, “I wish her well in her retirement,” while noting that she wished politicians left Washington sooner.

Their remarks come amid notable discord within the Republican caucus. Several members—including Greene, along with Representatives Troy Nehls, Jodey Arrington and Elise Stefanik—have either announced retirements or decisions to seek other offices. Disagreements over government funding, health care reform and internal House rules have further exposed fractures in the GOP, as Johnson contends with public rebukes from both moderate and Trump-aligned members.

What People Are Saying

Stefanik, on X this month: "I just walked out of a briefing on this issue this morning CONFIRMING everything I posted yesterday. That yes, in fact, the Speaker is blocking my provision to root out the illegal weaponization that led to Crossfire Hurricane, Arctic Frost, and more. He is siding with Jamie Raskin against Trump Republicans to block this provision to protect the deep state. This is an easy one. This bill is DOA unless this provision gets added in as it was passed out of committee."

Greene, reacting to Stefanik's post: "No surprises here. As usual from the Speaker, promises made promises broken. We all know it."

Johnson, on X this month: "When Republicans stay unified, we can achieve ANYTHING! Even with one of the smallest majorities in history, we’ve delivered the most productive Republican Congress of our lifetimes — lowering costs, strengthening welfare, improving health care, and advancing President Trump’s America First agenda for working families. Democrats voted against ALL of it. The record shows the Republican Party is for working Americans."

Columbia University professor Robert Y. Shapiro, to Newsweek via email on Monday: "I think Johnson can fairly say he has been doing the best he can, since he not only has to deal with splits within his party in Congress but also has to do the bidding of President Trump, who can end his leadership position and support a candidate against him in the next primary.

"Mace had, for example, wanted Johnson to release the Epstein documents earlier, but he could not do that due to Trump's opposition. She doesn't give Johnson credit for getting all the legislation Trump has wanted through the House--especially the Big Beautiful Bill--whereas Pelosi was given full credit for all the legislation she accomplished, including the clever maneuvering to pass the Affordable Care Act, and later all of Biden's major budget legislation. Johnson now may get some blame from Mace and Trump if Republicans lose control of the House in the 2026 midterm elections."

What Happens Next

The retirement of seasoned lawmakers and open intraparty criticism leaves House Republicans with a narrowing majority and an uncertain legislative future.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines