10
Loading video...
By Oliver Trapnell
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Natalie Harp, a key White House aide, could be prohibited from posting on President Donald Trump’s Truth Social account as part of a potential remedy in a federal lawsuit challenging his subscription service, according to new court filings.
The suggestion comes from plaintiffs including The Intercept, which is suing the Trump administration over Truth API, a premium service that gives paying subscribers early access to certain posts from Trump's Truth Social account.
In a filing submitted on Friday, the plaintiffs argued that if the court is unwilling or unable to directly restrict Trump's own posting activity, it could still reduce the alleged harm by ordering White House staff members, including Harp and Trump's deputy chief of staff Dan Scavino, to stop posting on Trump's behalf.
Read More on Politics
The case is due back in court on Thursday for a hearing on the administration's motion to dismiss. Newsweek has contacted the attorney for Trump and Harp and the attorney for Trump Media for comment via email.

...
Why It Matters
The dispute centers on whether government information should reach paying subscribers before other news organizations and members of the public. In addition, the lawsuit could test the extent to which White House communications conducted through social media platforms are subject to scrutiny.
The plaintiffs argue that Trump's Truth Social posts constitute official government communications and that paying subscribers receive an unfair advantage when they gain access to "market-moving" presidential announcements before the public.
Truth API subscriptions can cost as much as $100,000 per month, according to the filing, and provide earlier access to posts from Trump and other administration officials.
The administration is seeking to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing the court cannot meaningfully redress the plaintiffs' alleged injuries and that the platform's subscription model does not violate constitutional protections.
How Natalie Harp Became Central to the Case
Harp features prominently in the new filing because plaintiffs say she is among the aides, alongside Scavino, who "regularly" publish posts to Trump's Truth Social account.

...
What The New Filing Says
The opposition brief asks the court to reject the administration's dismissal request and argues that injunctions directed at White House staff could still provide meaningful relief.
According to the plaintiffs, Harp and Scavino help increase the number of official announcements published through Truth Social. Preventing them from posting while Trump's account remains tied to the Truth API system would reduce the flow of government information reaching paying subscribers before everyone else, they argue.
Plaintiffs also maintain that Trump's exclusive use of Truth Social for certain official announcements helps drive demand for the API service and is essential to its commercial value.
What Happens Next
U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken is expected to hear arguments on Thursday as the court considers whether the case can move forward. The hearing will focus on the administration's motion to dismiss and whether the plaintiffs have standing to pursue their constitutional claims.
If the case proceeds, the court could examine how official White House communications are distributed through Truth Social and whether aides such as Harp and Scavino can continue posting on Trump's behalf.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Ben Kelly and Emma Lee-Sang
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines