10
Loading video...

By Marni Rose McFall
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Nate Silver, the statistician and founder of election analysis site FiveThirtyEight, suggested that Vice President Kamala Harris wasn't the right choice for Democratic presidential nominee.
In an interview with Big Technology Podcast host Alex Kantrowitz on Tuesday, which covered the impact on the election of President Joe Biden dropping out of the race, Silver said, "I'm not sure they should have picked Kamala," when asked why the Democratic Party had consolidated so quickly around Harris following Biden's decision.
"In a perfect world, I might've had more of an open audition process," he said.
Read More on News
Harris is not the Democratic nominee yet, though she has earned several high-profile endorsements, including Biden's. The party is set to pick a nominee on August 7 via an online vote, according to Democratic National Committee Chair Jaime Harrison.
Silver acknowledged the reasons behind the decision: "She's the vice president, she was endorsed by Biden, she has buy-in from lots of different groups in the Democratic Party, you might as well do it fast and not have recriminations about it."
Silver called Harris a "smart and capable person" but expressed some doubts. "She was not necessarily chosen to be the most compelling candidate in a swing state, but Trump is a flawed candidate too," he said.
Silver recognized that Harris could generate significant enthusiasm, mentioning record numbers of donations and improvements in her candidacy since 2020. "I think she's probably an underdog if you look at the polling for now. But it was, as we would call in poker, like an EV [expected value] increasing."
Newsweek has reached out to a representative of Harris via email for comment.

...
Silver rose to prominence with his blog FiveThirtyEight, which he began writing in early 2008. The blog takes its name from the number of electors in the Electoral College and was used to publish Silver's election predictions based on polling data, first for the 2008 Democratic primaries, and then that year's general election. His model's success in correctly predicting the results in nearly all 50 states in 2008, followed by all 50 plus D.C. in 2012 cemented his reputation and credibility as an election forecaster.
Like many other pollsters and election prediction models, FiveThirtyEight was wildly off on the 2016 result, having forecast a 71 percent chance of Hillary Clinton winning. The former secretary of state lost to Donald Trump. The model went on to correctly predict the outcome of the 2020 election.
FiveThirtyEight was bought by ABC News in 2018 and Silver left the company in 2023, taking his prediction model with him. He now publishes his prediction and forecast model on a new blog, Silver Bulletin.
Newsweek has reached out to Nate Silver via email for comment.
During the interview with Kantrowitz, Silver was also asked if the Democrats had increased their odds of winning by having President Joe Biden step down from the race. Silver said, "I think so."
He elaborated that although Biden would likely insist the decision was his own, there was significant pressure from prominent Democrats, including former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi. "I think they improved their chances, probably still to below 50 per cent," he added. "But in our model, Biden's chances had fallen to around 25 per cent."
"He was incapable of campaigning in a normal way without risking things becoming a big, you know, senior moment, social media disaster," Silver said.
He also noted that while the Democrats acted rationally in their timing, an earlier decision might have been more beneficial.
Silver's model was switched off after Biden dropped out. A message on his blog, posted July 21, says, "We'll turn the model back on in a week or so once we've gotten enough polling on Kamala Harris and/or other prospective Democratic nominees."
Do you have a story we should be covering? Do you have any questions about the presidential election? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines