10

Loading video...

Jenni Fink

By Jenni Fink

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The Supreme Court is deciding a case that could have far-reaching implications for people whose employer-sponsored retirement funds underperform, but justices appeared skeptical of issuing a wide-ranging opinion.

Anderson v. Intel centers on whether Intel operated irresponsibly in investing employees' retirement funds. Plaintiffs argue the company's fund underperformed compared to other funds, leaving employees with less money for retirement, but Intel argued that underperformance doesn't automatically mean there was a lack of care in how investments were made.

Justice Neil Gorsuch cautioned his fellow justices against weighing in on whether underperformance is the standard of proof for whether a company acted irresponsibly.

Read More on News

"We should take care to bracket that question about the relative importance of underperformance in a prudence, imprudence claim. We're not going to answer that question," Gorsuch said during oral arguments on Tuesday.

Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch stands during a group photo of the Justices at the Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., on April 23, 2021.

...

Instead, Gorsuch told justices to focus on the question of what the benchmark is for comparing funds when trying to determine if a fund acted irresponsibly.

Newsweek reached out to Intel and Anderson for comment.

At the heart of the case is how imprudence with regard to retirement funds can be determined under the confines of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which sets standards for private sector retirement and health benefits for employees.

ERISA focuses more on the process a company or fund followed and not the actual results. A fund can act responsibly if it earns less than another fund because of differing strategies, a point Intel's attorneys argued.

So, the justices are deciding what the benchmark for imprudence should be in these cases. Early in the oral arguments, Justice Clarence Thomas asked Anderson's attorney whether he agreed that "you can't compare apples and oranges." While the attorney agreed, he asked, "What is an apple and what is an orange?"

Later, Kagan brought the conversation back to Thomas' analogy. She noted that the apple doesn't have to be identical in color and texture and taste. But, she added, "it's got to be kind of an apple."

Other justices didn't use the fruit metaphor, but still raised the issue of comparisons. Gorsuch pointed out that comparison is necessary when a claim is based on underperformance, and Justice Amy Coney Barrett pressed attorneys on whether a comparator was necessary to sustain allegations of underperformance.

Intel argued that plaintiffs need a comparable fund when accusing a fund of violating ERISA. They argued that just because a fund was less successful than another, it doesn't mean anything irresponsible happened; it could reflect differing strategies, and that's not a violation of ERISA.

Plaintiffs, however, argued that Intel's heavy allocation to hedge funds and private-equity investments hurt performance and so it should have been handled differently. Instead of requiring a comparator, the plaintiffs argued courts should look at all of the allegations together.

Everyone involved in the case seemed to agree that a meaningful benchmark was necessary, but the disagreement was over what qualified as meaningful and how important it was.

The Supreme Court's ruling could determine how easily workers can challenge investment decisions made by the people who oversee trillions of dollars in employer-sponsored retirement accounts.

If the Supreme Court establishes a low bar for what a "meaningful benchmark" is in these cases, it could open the door for more lawsuits to proceed. However, if the Supreme Court raises the bar on the benchmark, employers could have an easier time getting judges to dismiss cases before they even reach discovery.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here. Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Jason Lemon and Gray R. Thomas

Correction 10/06/26 2:44 p.m. ET: A quote in this article has been updated to correctly attribute it to Kagan instead of Kavanaugh.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines