...
By Soo Kim
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A post showing what appeared to be a "fake chimney" on a new-build home has sparked discussion on why such architectural features are added—even when they don't serve their traditional function.
The Reddit post, shared on August 4 by user u/nosajn in the r/AskUK subreddit, included an image of a home under construction behind fencing, with a chimneylike structure visible on the roof. The title read: "Walking past some new houses being built and spotted what I think is a fake chimney. Is this common on new builds now? Why?"
Isfira Jensen, CEO and principal designer of Jensen & Co. Interiors in New York, told Newsweek that purely decorative chimneys are becoming increasingly common. "In some communities, homeowners association or local planning guidelines actually require chimneys to maintain a cohesive streetscape," Jensen said.
Read More on Home & Garden
"Even where they're not required, many builders include them because they keep the classic silhouette of a home, which increases curb appeal and perceived property value of a home."
The choice is often financial as well. "Real masonry chimneys are expensive and require specialized labor," Jensen said. "Opting for a decorative version lets developers and homeowners achieve the same visual charm at a fraction of the expense and without the need for a functional fireplace inside."
Americans are facing a housing crisis. A 2024 report from the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University found that millions of potential homebuyers have been "priced out of the market by elevated home prices and interest rates."
The home price surge was reported in 97 of the top 100 markets, with higher rises in the Northeast and Midwest regions, the report found.
For Ruben Gutierrez, principal interior designer at Errez Design, the design trend plays into familiar symbolism. "Fake chimneys: you see them sprouting from rooftops like set pieces from a stage play," Gutierrez said.
"They're there because the outline of a chimney still hits a nerve—home, history, a promise of warmth. Today's houses run on sealed systems and heat pumps, not open flues. So, developers chase the look without the mess."
Gutierrez added that fake chimneys can even hide vents, though they are mostly about selling a feeling. "Are they harmless? Usually—if detailed right. Get the flashing wrong, and water finds the gap and will leak. That's the real story here—nostalgia meeting value-engineering on a windy roof."
Architect Mark Holmquist told Newsweek that, while he doesn't see them often, fake chimneys appear in both decorative and functional roles. "Sometimes, these are actually practical, hiding air intakes or exhausts for modern heating and cooling systems," Holmquist said. He recalled one case in upstate New York where a fake chimney concealed cellphone equipment.
Holmquist also tied the practice to architectural history, adding that famed architects Robert Adam, Charles Rennie Mackintosh and John Nash often placed chimneys to "keep façades balanced and symmetrical" and, "sometimes, the chimneys weren't functional but were important to the overall 'look.'"
"Architectural elements often mean more than just what they do physically," Holmquist added. He said that, "to a lot of people, chimneys stand for 'home and hearth,' warmth, and a sense of security … so, even a chimney that doesn't actually work can help a house feel more welcoming and familiar from the curb."
Many Reddit users agreed that it was a matter of local aesthetics.
U/WhatYouLeaveBehind commented that it was about "Fitting in with the village's rustic aesthetic."
Another, u/dpk-s89, posted: "It's to match the vernacular of the local area. If the sites surrounding homes have chimneys the developer will be conditioned to provide them to match the surroundings."
Others pointed to nostalgia and tradition. U/nikhkin wrote: "People like the look of a house with a chimney. It's what a 'traditional' house looks like. When a kid draws a house, they'll often include a chimney. Most people do not use an open fire to heat their home anymore, so implementing a functional chimney is a waste of time, resources and space. It may also be to keep the style of the houses in keeping with the local area."
Some Reddit users were less charitable in their assessments, such as u/Fragrant-Attorney-73 who said: "The best is when the fake chimneys are (almost always) placed in positions where there couldn't possibly be a chimney."
U/cougieuk joked that they could be a problem "if they're casting shadow on your solar panels!"
Newsweek has contacted the original poster for comment via the Reddit messaging system.
...
Do you have a design or architecture-related story to share? Let us know via life@newsweek.com and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines