10

Loading video...

Katie Warnock

By Katie Warnock

CEO of Staffing Boutique

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


New York's teacher shortage is a crisis, and no single school system can solve it alone. When schools cannot recruit or retain capable educators, children risk losing consistent instruction, and families face uncertainty.

I believe education policy needs a basic correction. Any plan to expand or improve schools must explain how we will find, prepare, and keep the people responsible for teaching in them.

The problem extends well beyond this city. The National Center for Education Statistics reported that 74 percent of public schools with teaching vacancies had difficulty filling at least one position before the 2024-2025 school year. That was an improvement over the previous year, but it still reflected widespread hiring challenges.

Read More on Leadership Insights

This is a national recruitment crisis, and it should be treated like one. If we stay on this path, we will reach a point where too few people want to become teachers at all, and no expansion plan survives that. Schools should be competing for the same top graduates who take offers from Goldman Sachs, and we should be giving them a real reason to say 'yes.'

We Need to be Pro-education, Not Pro-school

The recent exchange between Nikole Hannah-Jones and Eva Moskowitz reveals how they approach educational inequality differently. Hannah-Jones emphasizes segregation and unequal opportunity. Moskowitz argues that charter schools can offer families an effective alternative.

Both raise serious points, but the debate keeps asking the wrong question. As a country, we have to stop treating this as a contest between public, charter, and private schools. It should not be about being pro-public school, pro-charter school, or pro-private school.

It should be about being pro-education, which means no longer tearing one sector down to lift another or holding any of them back from growing. Every one of those schools is serving children.

The Push and Pull Placed on Teachers

How do we get there? We start by admitting that what we are doing in this country is not working, and that every one of those visions depends on reliable, capable classroom staff. Families should not have to choose between their principles and the instruction their children need.

Meanwhile, the student population is shrinking. Enrollment in New York City Public Schools has fallen in recent years, and a growing number of families are leaving the system altogether to homeschool. That alone should tell us something is broken. Fewer students should also ease pressure on hiring. But it has not.

Right now, charter schools cannot compete with what New York City Public Schools is paying, and that has turned hiring into a tug of war between the two over the same limited pool of teachers. The current New York City Public Schools teachers' contract builds in a raise every year for five years, bringing starting pay above $72,000 by its end.

In my recruitment work, mathematics, science, and special education positions are particularly difficult to fill, and the pay gap makes it harder. I regularly see charters invest in a teacher's development, only to lose that teacher to a better-paid district job. And pay is only part of it.

Most charter schools run an extended school day. When the district offers a shorter day, better pay, tenure, and strong benefits, how can we expect educators not to leave? That is not a knock on the district for paying teachers more. It is proof that staffing policy ignores competition between schools serving the same communities.

Making Teaching More Attractive

This is a systemic problem, and it demands systemic questions. Who are we recruiting into teaching, and are we reaching them early enough, in high school and college, before another career claims them? How do we keep pay competitive across every kind of public school, not just one sector? And are our entry requirements identifying great teachers or simply screening them out? The answers we have now are not good enough.

Teachers deserve better pay. I would never ask them to accept financial insecurity as proof of commitment, and a livable wage should be the floor, not a reward.

But when one school's recruitment success becomes another school's vacancy, the city may simply be moving a limited workforce around. We need to make teaching attractive to more people while helping effective schools retain those already doing the work.

Paying teachers like professionals should come with evaluating them like professionals, and that means rethinking tenure. I just returned from Teach For America's 35th anniversary in Las Vegas, surrounded by alumni who teach in, lead, and have founded charter schools.

They were proud of their work and passionate about their students, and they did it without tenure. What keeps them in the classroom is mission, support, and room to grow. Add competitive pay, and teaching becomes a career top talent chooses instead of one it avoids.

Performance should inform that discussion without becoming a blanket judgment about either sector. The NYC Charter School Center's analysis of 2025 state assessments reported mathematics proficiency of 68.7 percent among Black charter students, compared with 43 percent among Black district students.

That comparison deserves attention, although it does not establish why the difference exists or account for every difference between student populations.

Different Routes Into Teaching

District progress matters, too. New York City Public Schools reported rising reading and mathematics proficiency in 2025. My concern is whether hiring resources and staffing rules help sustain effective instruction wherever children attend. Spending, vacancies, retention, and student growth should be examined together.

Certification belongs in that examination. Success Academy's teacher vacancy posting says teaching certification is not required for that role, while requiring a bachelor's degree and describing training and coaching. That is different from saying the network refuses to hire certified teachers. It raises a legitimate question about whether preparation must always follow the same route.

New York law already permits specified exceptions to charter school certification requirements, subject to numerical limits. I believe those limits deserve review alongside classroom effectiveness. A broader entry route should carry meaningful training, supervision, and accountability. Subject knowledge alone does not prepare someone to teach children.

Early childhood expansion makes these questions more pressing. Mayor Zohran Mamdani's 2-K launch described 2,000 seats this year and 12,000 next year. The need is understandable. Yet providers must recruit staff who meet applicable Health Department requirements, including qualifications, screening, and staffing ratios.

My concern is whether recruitment capacity can keep pace with expansion.

The Problem of Early Childhood Care and Education

The 2-K push also exposes a bigger gap. The United States has no free, universal childcare for children under 5, which means too many children walk into kindergarten already behind and their teachers start the year at a disadvantage.

A city program helps families here, but this is a national problem that needs a national answer. Early childhood care and teacher recruitment are parts of the same system. We cannot fix one while ignoring the other.

Before expanding further, city and state leaders should connect enrollment commitments to funded staffing capacity. They should review certification barriers, support paid routes into qualifications, pay teachers a livable wage, and improve compensation for hard-to-fill roles.

Switching Careers Into Teaching

Career changers and experienced classroom support staff deserve workable paths into teaching. Children deserve adults who are prepared to help them learn.

I am not only asking policymakers to act. There are also practical ways to expand the pool of potential teachers. Staffing Boutique has placed substitute teachers in charter schools since 2011, and this fall we are seeing an opportunity to bring more career changers into the classroom.

These are professionals with established careers in other fields who may have valuable experience to bring to students but have never considered teaching.

With appropriate preparation, including training on student safety and New York City requirements for substitutes, and the required fingerprinting process, substitute teaching can give both schools and candidates a chance to see whether the fit works. Some of these professionals may ultimately become the full-time teachers our schools are struggling to find.

Access becomes meaningful when a school can deliver the education it promises.

Katie Warnock is founder and CEO of Staffing Boutique, a staffing firm serving nonprofit organizations, charter schools, and public agencies in New York. Her work focuses on recruitment and the practical challenges employers face in finding and retaining staff. The views expressed are the author's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines