Condo Building

...

Giulia Carbonaro

By Giulia Carbonaro

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The number of Florida condos on the so-called nationwide "blacklist" maintained by the Federal National Mortgage Association—better known as Fannie Mae—has more than doubled in the past two years, according to recent reports.

That means that a growing number of condo owners in the Sunshine State are struggling to sell their units or get loans for repairs at a time when a new building safety regulation is forcing them to face climbing costs.

Why It Matters

After the deadly collapse of the Champlain Towers South condo in Surfside, Florida, in June 2021, lawmakers in Tallahassee passed a series of laws requiring regular inspections of aging condos and reserve funds for repairs.

Read More on News

While the new legislation was meant to avoid the kind of tragedy that can result from decisions by condo associations not to maintain a building's structure, the new requirements have pushed up costs for condo associations and owners, driving many to put their units on the market in a last-ditch attempt to avoid rising fees.

Those who find themselves with condos on Fannie Mae's so-called "blacklist," however, are going to find it hard—if not impossible—to sell them, as potential buyers would be advised against the purchase and won't be able to get a conventional loan.

Condo Building

...

What To Know

The Surfside collapse led Fannie Mae to require condo associations to be more meticulous in the information they provide about their finances, building conditions and maintenance issues.

As a result, many condos facing critical repairs or material deficiencies ended up on Fannie Mae's list of buildings it would no longer back mortgages for—a list that is accessible to mortgage lenders but not to owners or condo associations.

Lack of adequate property insurance also played a key role in the growing number of condos on the so-called "blacklist."

Even though the vertiginous rise of property insurance premiums in Florida finally slowed down last year, homeowners in the state still pay the highest price for coverage in the entire country, an average of $14,140, according to Insurify. The company expects premiums to increase by another 9 percent by the end of the year as the state continues to recover from the devastating impacts of Hurricanes Helene and Milton last year.

New data released by law firm Allcock Marcus—which obtained the list from a confidential source—reported by the Tampa Bay Times found that 1,438 condo buildings in Fannie Mae's list are in Florida. Nearly half of these—696—are in Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach counties, which have been particularly badly affected by the new building safety legislation.

The most common reason for condos to be on the list was a lack of adequate property insurance, Jake Marcus, a Miami attorney for Allcock Marcus, told the Tampa Bay Times. Deferred maintenance and unmet critical repair needs came a close second, the newspaper reported.

Owners of buildings on the list will have a harder time trying to offload their properties to buyers who are seeking conventional mortgage financing backed by Fannie Mae and sister company Freddie Mac. The two, together, back around 70 percent of all residential loans in the country.

"The impact of this list on the market generally could have significant repercussions where it is becoming challenging on various fronts as far as decreased property values, refinancing challenges, and even building reputation where the Blacklist status serves as a blemish until resolved," Marcus told Newsweek.

"In south Florida, the market has been very cyclical so will hopefully rebound but compounded with the insurance crisis and new legislation additions, this could be dire for some time."

Newsweek contacted Fannie Mae and Allcock Marcus for comment by email on Monday.

What People Are Saying

Marcus told the Tampa Bay Times: "I think it's the perfect financial storm for condominiums in Florida. There is just a lot happening in Florida with all the new requirements."

A spokesperson for Fannie Mae previously told the Wall Street Journal that the new requirements are designed to "help protect borrowers from physically unsafe or financially unstable projects." The company disputed the characterization of its list as a "blacklist," describing it instead as an online tool allowing lenders to check whether it accepts loans from a given project.

What's Next

The latest data on Fannie Mae's list of Florida condos ineligible for its backing suggests that the state's condo crisis can only get worse—unless lawmakers' efforts to address the problems created by the new regulation are successful in relieving homeowners.

While interested buyers could still purchase condos on the so-called "blacklist," non-conforming mortgages are usually more expensive and harder to qualify for. Paying in cash, on the other hand, is a possibility—but only a few are likely to be able to afford this.

Marcus told Newsweek he is observing a growing trend towards condominium termination—or de-condominiumizing—in the Florida condo market.

"We're noticing an increase in inquiries from condominium associations about termination or de-condominiumization, likely driven by several factors, including rising insurance costs [...] and stricter structural integrity and reserve requirements, as well as challenges stemming from the Fannie Mae blacklist, which has made lending more difficult for both unit owners and associations," he said.

"In many cases, especially in Florida, volunteer board members are struggling to manage these growing complexities and financial burdens. Especially aging properties, are struggling to secure a loan or insurance and it becomes an uphill battle to maintain," he explained.

"As a result, termination of the development is becoming a viable option."

Typically, after a condo undergoes "termination," the property is acquired by a developer who is more likely to have the resources to redevelop it more effectively.

"This process can ultimately benefit all parties involved, even though it may be challenging—based on voting requirements of terminating a condominium," Marcus explained.

"Overall, condominium termination followed by redevelopment can provide a practical solution for associations facing mounting pressures. And once a condo terminates, it provides another outlet for developers to swoop in and hopefully be good matches."

Update, 4/16/2025 5:20 a.m. ET: This article was updated with a comment from Jake Marcus.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines