By Larry Printz
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Agriculture has a data problem and, increasingly, the people being asked to solve it are the farmers themselves.
As food companies, financial institutions, governments and agricultural technology providers race to digitize farming, growers are being asked to supply an expanding stream of information about their operations.
The data can help measure emissions, monitor soil health, improve yields and demonstrate progress toward sustainability goals. But it also raises an uncomfortable question: Who benefits from all that information, and should farmers be paid for providing it?
Read More on Technology
That question emerged during a panel discussion on the future of digital transformation in agriculture, featuring executives from Oatly, Nestlé and Accenture at Newsweek's Feeding The Future at COP 31 event. Their conversation revealed a tension at the heart of agricultural innovation: Technology promises to make farming more efficient, but it can also create more work for the very people it is supposed to help.
Erin Augustine, vice president of global sustainability at Oatly, highlighted that companies must address data ownership, privacy and compensation when designing agricultural programs. “We as brands need to be willing to pay for that data,” she told the assembled crowd.
It’s a straightforward proposition with potentially significant consequences. Agricultural information has commercial value to companies seeking to document sustainability efforts, evaluate supply chains and direct investments. Yet farmers often bear the responsibility for collecting and entering it.
Dave Bellman, an agronomist and regenerative agriculture leader at Accenture, described the administrative burden. A farmer might have relationships with 10 to 12 organizations, including food companies, processors, government programs and banks, each requesting information. During planting and harvesting, farmers may already work extraordinarily long hours. Adding 20 to 40 hours of administrative work, Bellman suggested, is hardly an attractive proposition.
One possible solution is a trusted third-party data exchange that would allow farmers to submit information once and authorize multiple organizations to access it. Such systems could reduce duplication, although Bellman said they remain several years away. The larger challenge is ensuring that technology solves problems farmers actually have.
Florence Henry, global head of sustainability at Nestlé, emphasized that digital tools should be developed with farmers, not simply delivered to them. She cited programs in coffee-growing regions of Mexico and Honduras that provide accessible soil-health measurements, understandable reports and training to help growers interpret the results. Nestlé also assists farmers financially access the information.
The distinction matters. A straightforward soil-testing tool that helps a grower make better decisions may deliver more value than an elaborate digital platform requiring additional training and paperwork.
There are also limits to what technology can tell us. Bellman cautioned that artificial intelligence can produce impressive-looking results from flawed or incomplete information. Satellite imagery obscured by cloud cover, inaccurate measurements and other data errors can undermine conclusions that appear perfectly credible. Farmers' firsthand knowledge of their land, he argued, remains indispensable.
Ultimately, the panelists suggested digital transformation should be judged by something more consequential than the quantity of information collected. For all the talk of artificial intelligence, predictive analytics and digital platforms, agriculture faces a decidedly old-fashioned problem: making farming economically sustainable.
If technology can’t help farmers manage costs, improve productivity and earn a living, its value is difficult to measure. The real test of agricultural innovation may not be how much data companies collect, but whether the people producing the world's food can afford to keep doing it.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines