A split image of the Black Labrador sitting.

...

Lydia Patrick

By Lydia Patrick

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A dog owner thought her black Labrador retriever had mastered a basic command—until she had a sudden realization that left social-media viewers amused.

Summer McCullough (@summermcculloughh), from Atlanta, shared a TikTok video of her dog, Indy, 4, appearing to sit obediently on command. The clip quickly took off, racking up over 323,200 likes and more than 2 million views, according to the platform’s engagement metrics visible on the post itself.

In the clip, McCullough first asks her dog to "sit," which the blackLabrador does immediately. The owner then repeats the test using a series of unrelated phrases—“Taylor Swift," "cheese cake," and even "tax fraud." Each time, the dog sits as if she had heard the original command.

Read More on Life

McCullough told Newsweek: "I thought it would be funny to see if she would sit no matter what word I used. I stood in front of her and started to say the first words that popped into my head and she knows that routine: my mom stands and says a clear word, I sit, then get rewarded! I was surprised how instantly and eagerly she sat with each word! 'Tax fraud' really got me, truly no idea why that popped into my head, but she was down for it," she said.

McCullough added that her dog, Indy, is named after Indianapolis, where her college, the University of Georgia, won the football national championship during her junior year. She added that Indy is 4 years old and a mix of black Labrador and golden retriever, describing her as "the sweetest girl ever."

She added that Indy is also very intelligent, noting that her veterinarian once told her she is one of the smartest dogs he has ever met. However, McCullough said Indy is extremely food‑motivated and has learned that sitting or performing a trick often leads to a treat.

According to McCullough, she began to notice that whenever Indy suspects she might have food, the dog will immediately sit down and wait for her next command.

View on TikTok

View this video on TikTok

"Realizing my dog doesn't actually know what 'sit' means," McCullough wrote in text overlaying the video.

"She just obeys idk [I don't know]," McCullough captioned the post.

Black Labradors are widely known for their intelligence, friendliness, and eagerness to please. The breed is considered highly trainable and is frequently used as service, therapy, and assistance dogs because of its strong motivation to work with humans, according to The Labrador Site.

Breed experts also note that Labradors form strong bonds with their owners and often respond quickly during training sessions, according to Furric’s Black Labrador Breed Overview.

However, animal behavior research suggests dogs do not always understand spoken commands as literal words. Instead, many canines respond to a combination of tone, pitch, body language, and contextual cues, rather than vocabulary alone. Veterinarians at VCA Animal Hospitals say that dogs often rely more heavily on a person’s vocal tone and physical signals than the specific words being spoken.

A split image of the black Labrador sitting on a rug at home, listening to commands.

...

Scientific studies support this idea. Research published by the University of Lincoln in the U.K. found that dogs process both verbal content and intonation, and may perform a learned behavior when they recognize familiar speech patterns—even if the words themselves are different.

TikTok users flooded the comments with theories, jokes, and personal anecdotes about their own pets’ selective listening skills.

"My guess is they recognize the tone," suggested one user.

"I’d sit for Taylor Swift too," said Ellen.

"I would also sit down if accused of tax fraud," joked Allie.

"Labs are so well behaved. My schnauzer knows sit, but only does it when he feels like," said another dog owner.

"He might be responding to the pitch of your voice," suggested one user.

"Omg [oh my God]…. this must be a lab thing…mine is also broken," shared another commenter.

Newsweek reached out to Summer McCullough for comment via TikTok. We could not verify the details of the case.

Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to life@newsweek.com with some details about your best friend, and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines