
...

By Loree Sutton
Brigadier General (Ret.)
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
At Quantico last week, the president and secretary of war strode into a hall packed with generals and admirals, stars glittering on shoulders. They did not come to listen. They came to deliver a tirade: that the essence of America’s military is to “kill people and break things.” The room was thick with silence.
I imagine what passed through the minds of those leaders as they sat at attention. A general who once urged his daughter toward West Point now wonders whether he could still make the same recommendation. An admiral recalls his son’s football coach, once proud to send athletes into ROTC, perhaps now unsure. The message from the podium was clear: the honorable profession of arms should be recast in the mold of a movie caricature—reckless, violent, unaccountable. Rambo as a role model.
This is not a straw man. Secretary of War Pete Hegseth has long extolled those he calls “warriors,” even when the men in question faced charges of war crimes. “They’re not war criminals, they’re warriors,” he declared during Donald Trump’s first term, pushing for presidential pardons. In truth, the ethos he glorifies is the opposite of what our profession teaches: a lone wolf who uses violence as a universal tool, sneers at restraint, and believes law stops where his authority begins.
Read More on Opinion

...
The Army already has a creed, a Warrior Ethos that rests on four tenets: I will always place the mission first, I will never accept defeat, I will never quit, and I will never leave a fallen comrade.
This ethos is not about vengeance, brutality, or impunity. It is about discipline, resilience, loyalty, and selfless service. It is the opposite of the “Rambo politics” Hegseth celebrates. And it has enabled diverse units of Americans—women, men, Black, brown, immigrant, native-born—to succeed together on the battlefield for generations.
But that ethos is at risk. If women, Black and brown Americans, and immigrants were driven out of the ranks, recruitment would crater, readiness would erode, and cohesion would collapse. Nearly half of today’s enlisted force are racial or ethnic minorities. Women now serve in nearly every combat role. Immigrants have long punched above their weight, trading sacrifice for citizenship. To excise these communities is to strip away the strength of the modern force.
Worse, a military purged of pluralism would no longer resemble the nation it serves. It would become insular and brittle—a praetorian guard, not a people’s military. And when senior leaders suggest turning “blue cities” into training grounds for the “war within,” the line between national defense and authoritarian suppression grows perilously thin.
History has shown us this movie before, and it does not end well. In South Africa, apartheid’s military turned inward, destabilizing society for decades. In Weimar Germany, embittered veterans of exclusionary traditions fueled fascism. In our own history, the failures of the Vietnam and Iraq wars owed less to insufficient brawn than to arrogance, cultural blindness, and the hubristic dismissal of diplomacy as weakness. The through-line is unmistakable: exclusion and militarized nationalism hollow out, rather than strengthen, armed forces.
Today’s conflicts demand the opposite of what Hegseth prescribed at Quantico. Space warfare, cyber defense, mass migration, corruption, and illiberalism require fluency, adaptability, empathy, and collaboration. In such contests, the most lethal weapon is not a rifle, but a mind attuned to complexity. Pretending otherwise is strategic malpractice.
President Trump and Secretary Hegseth cling to the illusion that “might makes right.” But in the 21st century, American power depends on principled leadership, allies, and legitimacy. To double down on brute force and exclusion is to abandon the foundations of durable strength.
That reality is not lost on military families. I think again of that room at Quantico, and of the private doubts, multiplied across thousands of households, that become a quiet referendum on the military’s future. A force that cannot earn the trust of its own families will struggle to earn the trust of the nation.
Beyond Quantico, the reckoning deepens. Teachers, coaches, and parents—once supportive of their students and children choosing to take up the profession of arms—may now hesitate. What does it mean to entrust a young person to an institution increasingly defined by exclusion and aggression?
But words are not enough. Action is required.
Congress must hold hearings to expose the dangers of reshaping the military into a force of exclusion and intimidation. Veterans’ groups must raise their voices—not only to defend those who serve today, but to safeguard the principle of a representative force for tomorrow. Military families must speak plainly about their hopes and fears, reminding the country of who fights and dies in our wars. Concerned Americans must press candidates in this election season to state, unequivocally, whether they support a military that reflects the nation—or a praetorian guard that serves only the few.
I recently received an email from a fellow soldier whose husband was killed while serving in Iraq, leaving her and their infant son on the home front. She describes feeling a conflicted pride in her now 20-year-old son’s decision to join the National Guard and go active duty in three years when he finishes college. Pride, because he is continuing the family’s tradition of service. Conflict, because she struggles with saying goodbye and worries that the institution into which he steps may no longer honor the values for which his father gave his life.
Her words are a reminder that the stakes are not abstract. They are personal. Generational. Irrevocable.
The honorable profession of arms is not built on Rambo politics. It is built on the Warrior Ethos: mission first, never accept defeat, never quit, never leave a fallen comrade. The question now is whether enough Americans—leaders and citizens alike—will recognize the difference and act before it’s too late.
Loree Sutton is a psychiatrist, retired brigadier general, and combat veteran with nearly 30 years of military service.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines