A mother and eight month old baby girl asleep.

...

Jenni Fink

By Jenni Fink

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Sleep sound machines have been a staple of nurseries and baby registries for years and parents rave about them in terms of helping their kids sleep. But a recent study raises questions about whether they could actually hinder bedtime.

New research from the University of Pennsylvania found that nights listening to pink noise while sleeping is associated with less deep sleep and an abbreviated stage of rapid eye movement (REM) compared to those when people slept without it. The study was only done with adults but researchers believe that a study with babies or toddlers would yield similar results, meaning the noise machines that so many parents rely on to help their kids sleep could actually be contributing to less deep sleep.

"The likelihood is high that they do translate to some extent, even if not in a 1:1 fashion," Dr. Mathias Basner, the study's lead author, told Newsweek. "Also, the findings may be more relevant for newborns and toddlers as they spend more time in REM sleep."

Read More on News

Why Is Pink Noise Potentially Harmful for Baby Sleep?

In the laboratory study, 25 healthy adults were observed over multiple nights. When exposed to pink noise at 50 decibels—roughly the volume of moderate rainfall—participants experienced nearly 20 fewer minutes of REM sleep per night compared to quiet conditions. REM is the stage of sleep that's critical for emotional regulation, learning and brain development.

Pink noise is often described as a gentler, more natural alternative to white noise—similar to steady rain or wind through trees.

When participants were exposed to aircraft noise alone, they spent about 23 fewer minutes in the deepest sleep stage. When pink noise was combined with aircraft noise, both deep sleep and REM sleep were significantly shorter compared to nights that people slept with no noise.

Participants also reported that their sleep felt lighter, they woke up more frequently and their overall sleep quality was worse when exposed to aircraft noise or pink noise, compared to nights without noise.

While infants were not included in the study, the researchers specifically cautioned that the results could be concerning for children. Babies and young kids spend a much greater proportion of the night in REM sleep than adults, making that stage especially important for early brain development.

"I am concerned about the REM sleep deprivation portion and the potential for broadband noise to affect hearing and the way young children process sounds," Basner told Newsweek. "Our study found some minor benefits of pink noise for enhancing deep sleep and preventing sleep fragmentation in the presence of environmental noise. This is what parents might be noticing and may be after. I am still concerned about the REM sleep reduction and the potential long-term hearing consequences."

A mother and 8-month-old catch some shut-eye.

...

Is Pink Noise the Same as White Noise?

Despite often being lumped together, pink noise and white noise are not identical.

White noise contains all audible frequencies at equal intensity, creating a steady, static‑like sound similar to a fan or radio hiss. Pink noise also includes all frequencies but emphasizes lower ones, resulting in a softer, deeper sound that many perceive as more soothing.

Nationwide Children’s Hospital notes that pink noise tends to sound more “natural” than white noise, but each child will have different preferences in terms of what helps them settle. Parents are told to keep the volume low and make sure the sound machine is away from the bed or crib.

Why Do Babies Like White Noise

White noise remains popular in nurseries for a reason. Pediatric sleep experts generally agree that steady background sound can help babies fall asleep by masking sudden environmental noises—from traffic to a closing door—that might otherwise wake them. It's also possible that once a routine is established with white noise, it starts to signal to babies that it's time for bed.

Experts increasingly emphasize the importance of the manner in which white noise is applied. A 2014 study from the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) found 14 sound machines designed for infants exceeded recommended noise limits for hospital nurseries. The study found regular exposure could be damaging to a baby's hearing and auditory development.

Based on the study's findings, the AAP recommended that all noise machines should be placed at least 7 feet from the baby's crib.

Basner told Newsweek that "fighting noise at the sources is always the best solution." So rather than relying on white noise to mask environmental noises, it's better to try to remove a baby or toddler from that environmental noise. For example, choosing a bedroom that doesn't face the street or installing windows that insulate the room for outside noise.

"There is certainly a trade-off between 'what does the sound environment in the bedroom do to the sleep of my child' and 'what does broadband noise generated by sound machines do to the REM sleep and hearing of my child,'" Basner told Newsweek.

When Do Babies Sleep Through the Night?

Unfortunately for sleep-deprived parents, there's no firm answer on when a baby will sleep through the night. Each baby is different and some babies start sleeping through the night as soon as 3 months old and others can still be waking up multiple times a night at 1 year old. There's also no firm definition of "sleeping through the night," though many doctors and experts describe it as a six- to eight-hour stretch of continuous sleep.

A baby's ability to sleep through the night also depends on how much they're eating during the day because a baby that isn't eating enough could struggle with shut-eye. Frequent night wakings are biologically normal into the first year and even babies that are able to sleep through the night can go through tough periods where they start waking up more during bedtime.

Baby Sleep Regression Ages

Sleep regressions, periods when a baby who previously slept well suddenly wakes more often, are common and developmentally normal. During these phases, experts recommend focusing on consistent routines and sleep hygiene rather than introducing louder or more persistent sleep aids.

Well‑recognized regression windows occur around:

Not all babies experience sleep regressions at these ages or even at all, and there's nothing parents can do to prevent the phase, since it's a natural part of a baby's growth.

When Can You Start Sleep Training?

Sleep training is when parents teach their baby to fall asleep by themselves, either at the beginning of the night or when they wake up in the middle of the night and need to go back to sleep. Like most things related to parenting, people have strong feelings on sleep training and some argue that it's harmful to babies to let them self-soothe. But the Cleveland Clinic said there's no evidence to indicate that babies are harmed psychologically or physically through sleep training as long as they're old enough to be capable of self-soothing and don't need to feed overnight, which usually occurs around age 4 to 6 months.

“At this age, babies are typically old enough to learn to self-soothe, and they may no longer require night feedings,” Dr. Noah Schwartz told the Cleveland Clinic. "It’s also around this time that your baby’s sleep cycles begin to mature, and their circadian rhythm starts to take effect.”

How Long Should a Baby Sleep in Parents’ Rooms?

The AAP recommends that babies sleep in the same room—but on a separate surface—for at least the first six months, and ideally up to one year, to reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome. It's deemed safer because parents can respond more quickly to emergencies that develop with their child's breathing.

Sleep is one of the hardest parts of being a parent of a newborn and young baby and many parents are often looking for ways to help their babies sleep longer overnight so they can get rest as well. And there are few things more disheartening than an exhausted parent who just got their baby to sleep, only to have them woken up by a sudden noise. It's part of the reason sound machines for babies are so popular. Basner told Newsweek more research is needed to determine the effects of noise on infant and baby sleep.

Basner also wants to continue studying the impact of sound machines on adult sleep in the real world and recommended that people use timers so the noise turns off after they go to sleep, in an effort to promote deep sleep.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines