10
Loading video...

By Andrew Stanton
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Republicans may be completely locked out of California's Senate election, as recent polls ahead of the March primary suggest there is a chance two Democrats could advance to the November general election.
California voters will head to the polls on March 5 to vote in the primary elections, including the crucial Senate race that has seen candidates spar over key issues, including the state's housing crisis, economy, climate, and immigration. On the Democratic side, three current members of Congress—Representatives Barbara Lee, Katie Porter and Adam Schiff—are running. Republicans have largely rallied around former baseball star Steve Garvey as their top candidate.
However, recent polls are split on whether Garvey will advance to the general election. The possibility of Republicans being locked out of the race is due to the electoral system used by California.
Read More
Democrats’ Chances of Flipping the House in 2024 Election3 min read

Ted Cruz Says He’s Democrats’ ‘Number One Target’3 min read

Republicans Get Promising News in Fight Against Donald Trump’s Enemy4 min read

California is among the few states that use the "jungle primary" system, in which all candidates, regardless of their political party, will run on the same ballot during the primary election in March. The two candidates who receive the most votes will then go on to the general election, creating a challenge for Republicans as the state's voters select two Democrats to run in November.
Christian Robert Grose, academic director at the University of Southern California Schwarzenegger Institute, told Newsweek on Tuesday that the dynamics of the race are being driven by the state's Democratic-leaning electorate. He said the race in November would be more competitive if two Democrats, rather than Garvey, advance in March.
Four public polls have been released into the race so far in 2024, with two showing Garvey advancing to the general election while the others show a two-Democrat race in November.
An Emerson College poll released Tuesday found Schiff and Garvey advancing to the November election, with Schiff receiving 28 percent of the vote and Garvey winning 22 percent. Meanwhile, Porter trailed with 16 percent, with Lee earning 9 percent of the vote.
The poll surveyed 1,000 registered voters from February 16 to 18 and has a margin of error of plus or minus 3 percentage points.
Ellie Hockenbury, a spokesperson for the California GOP told Newsweek on Tuesday that polls placing Garvey placing or tied for second is a "great sign" of his chances of advancing to the general election.
"I have no idea how coming in second place or tying for second in the three most recent polls can be seen as anything but a great sign that Republicans will make the top two. Voters are understandably fed up with the radical policy failures championed by the three Democrat congressmembers in this race," Hockenbury said.
Garvey is "surging at the right time and putting Republicans in a strong position to advance to the general election this November," she said.
Garvey, in a statement forwarded to Newsweek by his campaign, said the poll "signals loud and clear that our message resonates."
"Californians are demanding common-sense solutions to tackle our most pressing issues—enough of the endless talk and inaction from career politicians," he said.
A separate Emerson College poll, conducted from January 11 to 14, similarly found both Schiff and Garvey receiving the most votes, with Schiff winning support from 25 percent and Garvey 18 percent of respondents. Porter again placed third with 18 percent of the vote. That poll surveyed 1,087 registered voters and had a margin of error of plus or minus 2.9 percentage points.
Other polls, however, suggest Garvey may not make it to the November election.
A California Elections & Policy Poll found Schiff receiving support from 25 percent of voters, while Porter and Garvey each received 15 percent.
This poll was conducted by the University of Southern California Dornsife/Price Center for Urban Politics and Policy, California State University Long Beach and California State Polytechnic University, Pomona. It surveyed 1,416 voters from January 21 to 29 and had a margin of error of plus or minus 2.6 percentage points.

...
Meanwhile, a University of California, Berkeley poll found that 21 percent of voters would support Schiff, 17 percent would back Porter and 13 percent would vote for Garvey. The poll surveyed 4,470 likely voters from January 4 to 8 and had a margin of error of plus or minus 2 percentage points.
Even if Garvey advances to the general election, the race is unlikely to become competitive in the deeply Democratic state, which backed President Joe Biden by more than 29 points in the 2020 election.
Grose said that "it is irrelevant if the Rs are on the ballot in the general or not as they are unlikely to win the Senate race given the Democratic lean of the state," but that Schiff and Porter advancing would "provide an opportunity for a truly competitive race."
He noted that Schiff has run ads boosting Garvey, as he would rather face him over Porter, and that polls show it may be paying off. Still, he said Porter has sought to elevate another Republican, Eric Early, and that there is still a "fairly good" chance that she and Schiff face off in November.
What Will Republican Voters Do if Only Democrats Advance From California Primary?
Republican voters will still play an important role in the general election, even if no Republican candidate makes it past the primary, Grose said.
"The way the top-two primary works is that when two same-party candidates are on the ballot, the winner sometimes is able to draw a coalition of Democrats and independents and even other-party voters," he said.
He said that research shows 80 to 90 percent of Republicans vote for the same candidate in a race between two Democrats, meaning they still hold influence over the candidates and may incentivize candidates to be less extreme.
"If the U.S. Senate race in 2024 ends up with Democrat Schiff versus Republican Garvey, it will be an uncompetitive snoozefest where Schiff is likely to destroy Garvey. There simply are not enough Republicans in the state to push Garvey over the finish line that is it highly unlikely that Garvey or any Republican would be competitive in the states' current environment," he said.
Republicans were locked out of the 2016 California Senate election when Kamala Harris, then serving as the state's attorney general, was elected over Congresswoman Loretta Sanchez.
Update 2/20/24, 1:37 p.m. ET: This article was updated with comment from Christian Robert Grose and a statement from Steve Garvey.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines