10

Loading video...

Hollie Silverman

By Hollie Silverman

News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Rick Chow, the South Carolina convenience store owner acquitted of murder in the 2023 shooting death of 14-year-old Cyrus Carmack-Belton, now faces a potential civil wrongful death lawsuit from the teenager’s family, creating a new legal battle after the not-guilty verdict came just two days before the anniversary of his death.

Carmack-Belton's family is now pursuing a civil suit following the verdict, family attorney Todd Rutherford announced after court on Monday. Troy Belton, Carmack-Belton's father, stood with Rutherford but did not make a statement to reporters, Columbia news station WLXT reported.

The family was seen hanging their heads, crying and holding each other in the courtroom after the verdict was read.

Read More on U.S.

"The acquittal is obviously a major victory for the defense, but it does not necessarily insulate Mr. Chow from civil liability," Todd Spodek, an attorney and managing partner for Spodek Law Firm, told Newsweek on Tuesday.

"The verdict should not be interpreted as a finding that every aspect of the shooting was justified. It means the prosecution failed to prove criminal guilt beyond a reasonable doubt," he said, adding, "A civil jury evaluating the same facts under a substantially lower standard could reach a different conclusion."

Troy Belton reacts after a not-guilty verdict against Chikei Rick Chow in a murder trial on June 1, 2026, in Columbia, South Carolina.

...

How Did Cyrus Carmack-Belton Die?

Carmack‑Belton died after being shot in the back during a pursuit outside a gas station in Columbia in May 2023.

The encounter began inside Chow’s store, where the teenager was suspected of taking bottles of water. According to evidence presented at trial, Carmack‑Belton left the store and ran, while Chow and his son followed him. Witness testimony and surveillance footage described the teenager fleeing before the shooting.

During the chase, Chow fired a single shot that struck Carmack‑Belton in the back, killing him. Prosecutors argued the teen was attempting to escape and did not pose a threat at that moment, while the defense said Chow acted to protect his son after believing the teenager had a gun.

The fatal gunshot wound, combined with the circumstances of the pursuit, became the central issue in the criminal trial and ongoing legal disputes surrounding the case.

An image of Cyrus Carmack-Belton is displayed during the murder trial against Chikei Rick Chow on June 1, 2026, in Columbia, South Carolina.

...

Rick Chow Found Not Guilty

Chow was found not guilty on Monday, when a Richland County jury acquitted him of murder after roughly eight hours of deliberations following a multi‑day trial. The jury’s decision came after hearing two sharply different explanations for the 2023 shooting.

Prosecutors argued that Chow wrongly accused Carmack‑Belton of stealing water, chased him as he ran away, and shot him in the back even though he posed no immediate threat. They relied on surveillance video and witness testimony suggesting the teenager was fleeing and unarmed during the chase.

The defense, however, said Chow acted in self‑defense and in defense of his son, arguing that Carmack‑Belton had a handgun and that Chow believed his son was in imminent danger during the pursuit.

Because it was a criminal case, prosecutors were required to prove Chow’s guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt,” a high legal standard. The not‑guilty verdict means jurors were not convinced the state met that burden—not necessarily that they found every part of Chow’s actions justified.

Chikei Rick Chow's mug shot.

...

Family Pursuing Civil Suit After Verdict

Despite the not‑guilty verdict, Carmack‑Belton’s family says their legal fight is not over and plans to continue pursuing a wrongful death lawsuit against Chow.

Speaking after the verdict, Rutherford criticized the outcome, saying he could not understand how jurors acquitted Chow, given evidence that the teenager was shot in the back after fleeing the store, WLXT reported.

"There is no way that a child who did nothing wrong, who was shot in his back, how that jury can justify that verdict," Rutherford told reporters, adding, "I've been practicing law for almost 30 years. I've never seen anything like this. I don't understand it."

Rutherford emphasized that the civil case will proceed independently of the criminal trial, in which the burden of proof is significantly lower. In civil court, the family will seek to prove liability by a preponderance of the evidence rather than beyond a reasonable doubt, thereby opening the possibility of a different outcome despite Chow’s acquittal.

A memorial for Cyrus Carmack-Belton is seen on June 2, 2023, in Columbia, South Carolina.

...

Spodek told Newsweek, "What makes this case different from many other self-defense cases is that the legal analysis does not appear to begin and end with whether there was an initial threat."

"The focus is likely to be on what happened in the moments that followed and whether the use of deadly force remained reasonable under the circumstances," he said.

"The burden of proof in a criminal case is beyond a reasonable doubt, which is intentionally very difficult for prosecutors to meet," Spodek said. "In a civil wrongful death case, the family would only need to prove that their version of events is more likely true than not. Those are two very different standards."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines