
...

By Anna Rahmanan
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
For a few hours, plague was the word Russian officials were willing to use. Then it disappeared.
On October 3, officials in Baikalsk warned residents away from nearby Shelekhov, citing reports of plague, before deleting the post. Broadcaster REN TV removed five posts about the plague. Alexey Tsydenov, head of neighboring Buryatia, initially wrote that a woman had died of plague before later amending the post to say she may have died of plague.
Russia’s eventual federal explanation was different again—pneumonia of unknown etiology.
Read More on Analysis
Now, Secretary of State Marco Rubio is pressing Moscow to explain the gap. Speaking in Iceland on Tuesday, Rubio said Russia should provide more information about the death and that Washington was monitoring the case “very closely, hour by hour.”
The woman was Darya Shipilova, a 28-year-old laboratory technician at the Irkutsk Anti-Plague Research Institute who was hospitalized on September 29 and died on October 2. Russia’s health watchdog says testing found neither microorganisms linked to her work nor evidence of a laboratory accident.
WHO said on Tuesday that no identified contacts have developed symptoms and that Russia reported finding no dangerous infectious pathogens among them.
But three inconsistencies between the original and amended responses and explanations paint a different story.
- Russia Can’t Settle on What Killed Shipilova
Plague entered official accounts before federal health authorities rejected it. Once the word was out, officials faced a second problem—getting it back out of the public conversation.
Regional officials first described a suspected “particularly dangerous infectious disease.”
Tsydenov went further, saying a woman had died of plague before amending the post and the officials in Baikalsk later issued their warning before deleting it.
Then the federal account changed.
Rospotrebnadzor said expanded testing found no microorganisms connected with Shipilova’s professional activity and that an official commission identified no accident involving pathogenic microorganisms. Her death was recorded as pneumonia of unknown etiology.
Diagnoses change in a fast-moving emergency so that alone isn't suspicious. But there is a gap here.
Russia has explained why it now says Shipilova’s death was unrelated to her laboratory work; it has not, however, explained why plague entered official accounts so quickly, or what caused the pneumonia instead.
- The Exposure Stories Do Not Fit Together
People of Baikal reported that Shipilova broke a tube containing Yersinia pestis at work on September 25. That account has not been independently confirmed, and Rospotrebnadzor says its inspection found no laboratory accident.
The pro-Kremlin Telegram channel Mash reported that Shipilova had recently traveled for work to Buryatia, a region containing natural plague foci. But Tsydenov said she had never entered the republic and another early account had her returning from Thailand.
Former colleagues dispute that version on specifics, telling RFE/RL’s Siberia.Realities that glass tubes were not used in the safe zone, protective equipment was mandatory, and plague vaccination was required even of interns.
The timing is also at issue here. Shipilova was reportedly last at the institute on September 25 and hospitalized four days later. The CDC says primary pneumonic plague usually incubates for one to three days, while Russian guidance gives an average of two to four days, with longer periods possible in some circumstances.
Four days neither proves nor excludes plague exposure.
- The Response Looked Like Officials Feared Something Serious
Russia’s response to whatever this is was substantial.
Over 60 institute employees were confined inside the facility after Shipilova’s death, according to Siberia.Realities, with one source describing workers sleeping on floors and chairs while relatives passed food through a checkpoint.
Around 200 possible contacts were initially placed under medical observation or isolation.
Shelekhov’s district hospital restricted inpatient operations. The Irkutsk Aluminum Plant introduced masks, with its director citing “contradictory information” about plague.
A patient at Irkutsk City Clinical Hospital No. 1 also said patients had been told restrictions could last up to six days. Russian sanitary rules use six-day observation periods in plague-related settings.
But if plague and a laboratory accident have both been excluded, why run plague protocol?
The Case Against the Panic
The reactions have a plausible, innocent explanation. A young scientist at a facility handling dangerous pathogens developed catastrophic pneumonia. Colleagues say doctors initially treated her illness as severe COVID until testing established what they were dealing with and authorities prepared for the worst-case scenario.
That would be prudence rather than evidence of a cover-up, and the epidemiological evidence increasingly supports it.
As far as we know, no identified contact has developed the suspected infection, and Russia has told WHO that testing found no dangerous infectious pathogens among them.
But the response here is telling. Officials used measures consistent with precautions for a suspected plague case while later saying that plague and a laboratory accident had been ruled out.
WHO has continued to seek information from Russia about the testing performed and the rationale for the contact tracing.
That leaves a narrower question than the early speculation suggested, but a significant one: why did Russia respond as if plague remained a serious possibility while its eventual public explanation said Shipilova died of unexplained pneumonia unrelated to her work?
The most striking feature of Russia’s plague story is the amount that remains unexplained even after the immediate epidemiological danger appears to have receded.
The Kremlin should heed the global cry for transparency, or else most people will assume the worst.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines