10

Loading video...

Lydia Patrick

By Lydia Patrick

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A Shakespeare professor’s breakdown of Taylor Swift’s new hit The Fate of Ophelia has gone viral, striking a chord with both Swifties and literature fans alike.

Mary Bly, 63, who writes under the pen name Eloisa James, is both a Shakespeare professor at Fordham University as well as a historical romance author. Her Instagram analysis of the first single off Swift's new album, which had received 854,000 views on the Meta platform at the time of writing, delves into how Swift reimagines one of Shakespeare’s most tragic heroines.

“As a Shakespeare professor, I love the embedded fragments of the play—not just Hamlet’s ‘venom’ that drives Ophelia mad, but the way he leaps into her grave,” Bly, @eloisajamesbooks, told Newsweek.

Read More on Life

In her viral video, Bly explains that Swift draws on the doomed love story of Hamlet and Ophelia, where the young noblewoman is rejected and humiliated by Hamlet, spirals into madness, and ultimately drowns. In Hamlet, it’s never made clear whether her death was accidental or suicide—a detail that has long symbolized female despair and lack of agency.

A split image of Mary Bly aka Eloisa James analysing Taylor Swift's The Fate of Ophelia.

...

“She brilliantly tied together what we know of Ophelia and what we know of young women who drowned in that kind of venomous, scorpion-ridden sexual morass with the man who comes along to save you, the man who comes along and digs you out of your grave,” Bly continued.

The Fate of Ophelia, also the opening track from Swift’s new album The Life of a Showgirl, references the Shakespearean character as a metaphor for being consumed by love and reborn through it. Lyrics such as “The venom stole her sanity” and “You dug me out of my grave and saved my heart from the fate of Ophelia” fuse tragedy with redemption—a shift that Bly says mirrors the structure of great romance storytelling.

“Taylor switches so deftly from the ex-lover whose insanity causes madness to the new Hamlet who brings love. Romance novels move from dark to light, but to do it so quickly is incredibly challenging,” she said.

Swift’s song, Bly notes, transforms that narrative into one of rescue. “Taylor Swift uses that almost as shorthand to go from there, the fate of Ophelia, to the question of a love story…of the person who comes and saves you,” she said.

Bly also pointed out that Swift’s “hero” figure represents what romance writers call a “protective alpha.” “Protective alphas pledge allegiance and are faithful to their loved ones,” she explained. “They jump in to save the heroine from bullies, from madness, or from death.”

NEW YORK, NY - OCTOBER 7: Taylor Swift is seen on October 7, 2025 in New York City.

...

Reflecting on the criticism Swift has faced for her latest album, Bly said: “With every novel I publish, a reader tells me, ‘I love your novels, but this one is rubbish.’ But another reader says that the book got them through chemo, or through divorce. A long career in pop culture means you inevitably delight and disappoint parts of your audience at once.”

She added that Swift’s song “Us,” co-written with Gracie Abrams, holds personal resonance—indeed, it references a book by her late father, poet Robert Bly.

Fans React

Instagram users flooded Bly’s post with praise for her thoughtful breakdown.

“Thank you! I love your wisdom on Taylor’s lyrics—you’ve perfectly articulated why it’s so impressive,” said Marine.

“Also, the play leaves unclear whether Ophelia drowned by accident (as in: she was so deep in her sorrow, maybe even in shock, she didn’t realize she was drowning) or by her own hand, as a way to ‘escape’ her suffering. In Medieval Catholicism, people who commit suicide were condemned to remain in purgatory,” added Marie.

“And THIS kind of thinking and writing of lyrics is exactly why I’m so fascinated with Taylor’s music!” wrote Holly. “I’m an English major and have always loved how words can evoke a feeling, a color, a sentiment, a mood—Taylor is brilliant at linking and imagery. It’s truly an art put to musical expression and style.”

Another user, Lisa, said: “I love hearing this from somebody who has studied Shakespeare and can also read into Taylor Swift’s writing. You don’t have to be a fan of her music, but if you listen to her writing, it’s so well thought out—she is just masterful at telling a story.”

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines