10
Loading video...

By Joe Edwards
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Republican senators are trailing challengers in two new polls from Arkansas and Idaho, two of President Donald Trump’s strongest states in the 2024 presidential election.
In Arkansas, a Talk Business & Politics-Hendrix College poll found Democratic Senate candidate Hallie Shoffner leading Republican Senator Tom Cotton by 47.4 percent to 44 percent. Libertarian Jeff Wadlin received 3 percent, while 5.6 percent were undecided.
Shoffner’s 3.4-point advantage falls within the poll’s 4.7-point margin of error, however. The survey of 1,217 likely voters was conducted by text message from August 11 to 12.
Read More on News
Cotton, a two-term senator who was first elected in 2014, received support from 82 percent of Republicans. But Shoffner led him 59 percent to 29 percent among independents, according to the poll. She also held advantages among women, younger voters and college graduates.
The result is particularly striking because Trump carried Arkansas by 30.6 percentage points in the 2024 presidential election, winning 64.2 percent of the vote to then-Vice President Kamala Harris’ 33.6 percent. It was the largest Republican presidential margin in Arkansas since Richard Nixon’s landslide victory in 1972.

...
A second poll produced an equally surprising result in Idaho. Independent Senate candidate Todd Achilles led three-term Republican Senator Jim Risch by 38 percent to 33 percent in a head-to-head matchup, according to figures released Wednesday by the Bullfinch Group. A substantial 29 percent were unsure.
The same survey placed Risch’s job approval at 32 percent, compared with 39 percent who disapproved. His favorability rating stood at 39 percent favorable and 44 percent unfavorable.
Idaho was one of Trump’s strongest states in 2024. He won 66.9 percent there, compared to Harris's 30.4 percent. Only Wyoming, West Virginia and North Dakota gave Trump a higher share of their votes, with North Dakota narrowly exceeding Idaho at 67 percent.
Related Story

After Iran, Trump and His Republicans Face Their Own Economic D-Day
Trump’s 10 highest state vote shares in 2024, according to Associated Press figures, were:
- Wyoming: 71.6 percent
- West Virginia: 70.0 percent
- North Dakota: 67.0 percent
- Idaho: 66.9 percent
- Oklahoma: 66.2 percent
- Alabama: 64.6 percent
- Kentucky: 64.5 percent
- Arkansas: 64.2 percent
- Tennessee: 64.2 percent
- South Dakota: 63.4 percent
Newsweek reached out to spokespeople for Cotton, Shoffner, Achilles and Risch for comment via email on Thursday, outside of office hours.
Polls Consistently Overestimate Democrats
Republican pollster Patrick Ruffini said in a post published on his Substack that he has identified a recurring tendency for Senate polls to overstate Democratic candidates’ eventual performance, particularly when surveys are conducted during the summer.
Ruffini, a co-founder of Echelon Insights, examined 3,312 Senate polls from the previous four election cycles using the former FiveThirtyEight polling archive. He said that the Democratic candidate’s margin was overstated in each of the four cycles. Across all the surveys analyzed, he said the average error favored Democrats by 3.7 percentage points, while 73 percent overstated the Democrat’s performance relative to the final election result.
Ruffini said that the disparity was most pronounced during the summer. The average error favoring Democrats approached six points in late July before beginning to decline in late August. By Election Day, it had narrowed to an average of 2.6 points, he said.
Update, 08/20/26 08:09 a.m. ET: this article was updated with further information.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines