
...
By Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, Stephen Henriques and Steven Tian
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Biden's likely medically induced debate debacle earned the harsh media review that followed. However, Biden may be right in pointing the finger at elite media for their denial of his obvious immediate, sustained rebound.
A jarring split juxtaposition has grown between the press magnification of a gradual trickle of political voices calling for President Biden to step aside, and the strong resurgent voter support for Biden's resistance and resilience. The suggestions that an elite set of voices should impose alternative compelling younger candidates, overriding primary voters and key constituencies, reflect a schism between a grassroots Democratic Party and an emerging Plutocratic Party.
Consider what we've seen from Biden recently. As we wrote, President Biden appears to be recovering his mojo after his disastrous debate; with the triumphant hosting of NATO leaders in DC and the stream of successfully unscripted public exchanges across prominent TV interviews, donor calls, and an effective hour-long press conference along with 20 demanding campaign appearances around the nation in two weeks. While he has visibly aged, and cannot run a 5 minute mile anymore; his mental acuity and ability to govern are readily apparent for all to see. Biden is hardly giving any new ammunition to his critics.
Read More
Joe Biden Stung By New Wave of Democratic Rebels4 min read

Did Cold Medications Affect Biden’s Debate Performance?4 min read

In what many expected would be the most challenging appearance, this week's press conference at the NATO Summit, Biden spoke extemporaneously and thoughtfully for over an hour, well past his supposed bedtime of 8 pm. More than proving his competence, cognitive acuity, and knowledge, Biden's sagacious wisdom was on full display as he riffed impressively about foreign policy challenges as varied as fortifying Pacific alliances, countering China's rise, supporting Ukraine against Putin, a possible ceasefire in Gaza, peace in the Mideast, not to mention economic prosperity and domestic policy wins, all while engaging in witty repartees with journalists ranging from New York Times foreign policy correspondent David Sanger to foreign press from Poland.

...
Sure, Biden stumbled over names at several points, and perhaps rambled on too long, but young politicos forget that these types of meandering gabby gaffes have always been Biden's trademark, irrespective of age. A notorious career long "gaffe machine", old profiles of Biden from the 80s feature Senate colleagues such as Orrin Hatch poking fun at his motor mouth. No one should forget his youthful legendary pre-White House gaffes: sixteen years ago, during one of their joint rallies in the 2008 campaign, Biden flubbed his big introduction of Barack Obama, mis-introducing him as "Barack America" – on top of his memorably hilarious malapropisms, mistaking a university chancellor with the soft drink "Dr. Pepper," or when Biden awkwardly implored a paraplegic state Senator to stand up and take a bow.
Common presidential gaffe traps as laugh tracks
Commentators freaking about Biden's newest gaffes should be reassured that the real Joe Biden is really all still here, warts and all, with Biden's gaffes more a time-tested reflection of typical Biden-speak than his age. Biden is not the first President to struggle with basic English at times. Both President Bushes were renowned for their own tortured syntax and jumbled, idiosyncratic speaking style, rarely finishing a sentence themselves. For example, the senior Bush was infamous for his inadvertently comedic trailing off, ***"*Not gonna do it. Wouldn't be prudent" denials to the press, not to mention his vomiting in the lap of Japan's prime minister at a 1992 state dinner.
Similarly, in 2004, President George W. Bush declared America's enemies "never stop thinking about new ways to harm our country and our people, and neither do we" and then a few years later announced "we really snatched defeat out of the jaws of those who are trying to defeat us in Iraq."
Jimmy Carter drifted into space during his acceptance speech at the 1980 Democratic Convention intending to pay tribute former Vice President Humbert Humphrey, a progressive pillar, as Hubert Horatio Hornblower! We should not forget President Ronal Reagan's meandering closing remarks during his second debate of the 1984 election against Vice President Walter Mondale. In an election where this president himself was facing questions about his age and fitness for a second term, Reagan went into a soliloquy about his drive down a California coastal highway that seemingly had no ending, much less meaning. The moderator eventually had to cut Reagan off mid-sentence after two full minutes because the president spent so much time talking about his picturesque road trip.
Trump himself has a long list of gaffes just as embarrassing, repeatedly confusing presidents Biden with Obama, memorably calling Apple CEO Tim Cook "Tim Apple" and Lockheed CEO Marillyn Hewson "Marillyn Lockheed," confusing unrelated countries such as Iraq and Syria, confusing Nancy Pelosi with Nikki Haley, wondering why Haley didn't call the Capital Police, and insisting that the 1776 Continental Army quickly took control of British airports, among many other malapropisms. His ridiculous "Sharpiegate" when in 2019 he tried to redraw a US Weather Service map by hand to cover his error pronouncing a hurricane's path through Alabama where it was not actually headed, make Biden's occasional flubs look positively innocent in comparison.
Reinforcing real bases of support
In the past week, Biden has wisely fortified the support of the heads of most NATO allies, as well as virtually every major constituency in the Democratic Party, ranging from the unified support of all 22 Democratic US governors, 100 major city Democratic mayors, and trade union leaders to the enthusiastic backing of Congressman Jim Clyburn and the Congressional Black Caucus, not to mention effusive support from the grassroots communities which have always formed the core of Biden's base, far away from Beltway salons and New York boardrooms.
NYT columnist Charles Blow captured the emotional reflexive response of redemption and resilience when Biden visited black churches in Philadelphia who advised that:
"I believe that Black people see something suspicious and unseemly in the rush to abandon Biden. They see a system – an establishment – turning on him, and it instinctually feels off, like being abandoned by allies. And that feels eerily, unsettlingly familiar....I believe it is because Black people understand unfair persecution in their bones. They know it ancestrally and contemporaneously. And so there isn't the same rush to condemn that others may have."
No panic regarding donor dollars
Now consider what we've been seeing from Biden's critics recently, starting with the elected officials. Of the 20 Democrats in Congress who've called for Biden to drop down, only 4 are women, and only 1 is non-Caucasian. Not only are these critics almost entirely white men, some of whom ironically just as old as Biden, but even more importantly, they tend to disproportionately represent affluent, wealthy districts that are far from representative.
These voices may be cognizant of the fact that certain donors have come out against Biden, and these donors-turned-critic have received plenty of media attention. Some donors such as Mike Novogratz have even pledged to donate $2 million to Biden objectors in Congress. But what many miss is that the donor community is not monolithic; and for every donor who is against Biden, there are plenty more, such as Reid Hoffman and Jeffrey Katzenberg, who continue to stand strongly behind him. As we saw firsthand from our participation in two top donor calls with Biden and our continued discussions offline with many top donors we've been in close touch with, the over 500 members of the National Finance Committee of the DNC could easily replace the lost donors' funds many times over.
July fundraising numbers from big donors will likely be down significantly, but not due to lack of support. The real reason is that many donors, understandably, may be personally agnostic on whether Biden should drop, but are temporarily pausing donations until there is greater clarity over the path forward – after all, no pragmatic donor wants to throw good money after bad money and donate to a candidate who may not run. But there is no doubt that they will give once there is greater clarity that Biden is in it to win it, motivated by their dislike of Donald Trump as much as anything else.
The resilient pattern in the polling
Biden's critics point to polls as supposed proof that Biden should step down, but what they are ignoring is that many of the polls have actually turned in Biden's favor over the last few days, with Biden leading Trump in the latest Marist-NPR-PBS poll, and tied in the Washington Post-ABC-Ipsos and Emerson College polls; furthermore, some of the initial polls favoring Trump in the days after the debate were riddled with dubious methodologies and questionable subjectivity.
Group-think in the media gaggle
Regrettably, despite these facts, the messaging of Biden critics is loudly amplified by media commentators, some of whom are hardly representative themselves – not to mention they have chronically underestimated Biden's grassroots popularity dating back decades leading to mutual resentment. An actual, groupthink cynical orthodoxy has taken hold of many in the club of Washington DC café society. In particular, when we looked up the track records of three prominent political journalists who have been loudest in peddling stories about Biden's supposed decline, we found in our original analysis that over their last 100 stories, they have published only 2 stories which could be remotely construed as favorable to Biden, but at least 50 stories which were harshly critical – and this pattern stems back decades, suggesting a possibly unfair, unconscious class consciousness in some media circles.
The media has similarly been enraptured by some celebrities jumping ship, such as George Clooney or Ashley Judd. However, Biden is surely not losing sleep over the devasting effect of these defections, let alone the potential horrors of Barbra Streisand possibly needing other people or Milli Vanilli coming out of seclusion for lip synched cynicism.
The continued persistence of the chattering class in loudly calling for Biden's exit raises questions over whether the Democratic Party is still truly democratic or whether it can be bent to the will of plutocrats. As Biden himself points out, he is the legitimately selected nominee of the grassroots voters of the Democratic Party, winning over 14 million votes in the primary, equivalent to 87% support, and raised a record $33 million in the first 48 hours following the debate from small donors. His continuing popularity amongst Democratic voters is apparent.
The redemption of empathy and authenticity
The heroic civil rights icon, Reverend Andrew Young once told the first author, "In every religion, there is something redemptive through unearned suffering as we often learn to appreciate precious gifts to humanity we'd previously taken for granted."
If anything, Biden's recent debate implosion and familiar gaffes along with family struggles may actually be a positive for his grassroots relatability and authenticity. Many American families struggle with the same set of challenges every day, just out of the glare of the public spotlight. There is a surge of empathy for the grieving over the passing of young loved ones; the challenges of having a loved one struggle with addiction, as many families deal with themselves every day; likewise, matched by the reassuringly familiar image of a sagacious loving grandfather who can no longer sprint to the finish line, but whose patriarchal wisdom abounds.
American democracy is by nature, cacophonous and pluralistic. Many on all sides will continue to comment on the topic of President Biden's age and fitness to serve, as they should. But there is a line between expressing one's own beliefs, and undermining elections. If a plutocratic establishment is allowed to undermine the democratic process and push out a nominee selected legitimately by millions of voters without their input, then perhaps it is time the Democratic Party rebrand to the Plutocratic Party.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines