10

Loading video...

Carine Harb

By Carine Harb

Associate Editor, My Turn

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


President Joe Biden has issued a full and unconditional pardon for his son, Hunter Biden, who was convicted earlier this year of illegally obtaining a firearm and failing to pay over $1.4 million in taxes between 2016 and 2019.

The sweeping pardon also covers any other "offenses against the United States which he has committed or may have committed or taken part in during the period from January 1, 2014 through December 1, 2024."

President Biden previously promised not to use the extraordinary powers of the presidency for the benefit of his family. He defended his decision by stating that Hunter was unfairly targeted for political reasons and that many of his actions were influenced by his struggle with addiction.

Read More on News

While some have praised the decision as a compassionate response to what they see as selective prosecution, the pardon has sparked significant controversy, drawing harsh criticism from President-elect Donald Trump, who accused Biden of abusing his presidential power.

Newsweek has reached out to experts for analysis on the legal and political implications of this.

Should Joe Biden Have Pardoned Hunter?

...

Rogers M. Smith, Emeritus Professor of Political Science, University of Pennsylvania

Though every parent can understand why Joe Biden pardoned his son Hunter, it will go down in history as a serious mistake. I believe that Hunter Biden faced more serious prosecutions for his offenses because he was the son of a prominent political leader. But many Americans have lost all faith in the integrity of their political leaders. This pardon compounds that problem. Biden went back on his repeated promises not to do it. He made it harder for Democrats to claim they uphold the rule of law more than Republicans. He expanded the political space for President Trump to pardon January 6th offenders, creators of phony slates of electors, and many more. Sadly, many will remember the pardon not as an emblem of a father's care but as proof that in America, those who are politically well-connected can get away with anything.

Stephen M. Griffin, Professor of Constitutional Law, Tulane Law School New Orleans

President Biden's disastrous decision to pardon his son should not have happened for a number of reasons. It is part of a pattern of highly questionable pardon decisions made by lame duck Presidents. Unless Democrats quickly repudiate this decision, it undermines, perhaps fatally, their ability to criticize similar decisions made by President-elect Trump, and it deals yet another blow to the public's already low trust in government, especially in its crucially important function of the administration of justice. Everyone who values that system should object to Biden's selfish action.

Dr. Larry J. Sabato, Founder & Director of the University of Virginia Center for Politics

Anyone in politics who is surprised by the pardon should consider moving to another field. Anyone who doesn't understand why Joe and Jill Biden repeatedly denied the pardon would happen should join the others.

That said, the worst part of this is that it will inhibit Democrats from criticizing the slew of Trump pardons to come, likely including some insurrectionists from January 6th. The pardon of Charles Kushner, and Trump's appointment of Ivanka's father-in-law as Ambassador to France, also will probably get muted coverage now.

Finally, is the pardon a regrettable example of the advantages of unearned privilege? You bet. And to quote President Kennedy, life isn't fair. Just look at the Trump family.

Eleanor Clift, Political Journalist & Columnist, Daily Beast

Biden did the right thing as a president and as a father to pardon his son. Trump's picks for DOJ and FBI signal his determination to seek revenge against those he perceives have wronged him. Trump campaigned against "the Biden crime family." Biden has the constitutional right to pardon his son and the parental responsibility to remove him from the line of fire from the incoming administration.

Adam Winkler, Professor, UCLA School of Law

President Biden was wrong to pardon Hunter. It is clear that Hunter violated the law, lying to buy a gun and failing to pay taxes. Although presidents have unlimited authority to issue pardons, this one is wrong. Pardons should be to pursue justice, not to favor the president's family or friends.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines