0.cached.png

0.cached.png

Newsweek Editors

By Newsweek Editors

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


To most spectators, General Electric's sale of $1.4 billion worth of Genworth Financial stock last week seemed like a typical ho-hum transaction. GE was selling stock in its former insurance subsidiary for the third time since Genworth's initial public offering of stock 19 months ago. Strictly yawn city. But for tax mavens, GE's sale of 41 million Genworth shares was like Michelangelo's final brush strokes on the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel: the conclusion of a masterpiece.

Normally, I criticize convoluted tax deals like this one, but I'm going to depart from form because even the meanest critic occasionally finds something to like. And I like the artistry of Genworth's saving more than $700 million in taxes, mostly by avoiding what amounts to double taxation on some of its bond gains.

But before we go crunching numbers, some background. GE wanted to unload its insurance businesses, which it considered slow-growth. Anyone with a C or better in Taxes 101 could have shown GE how to distribute Genworth to its holders tax-free--but GE wanted to sell Genworth and keep the proceeds to invest in other businesses. We're talking big bucks: GE has raised $11 billion selling Genworth stock, and still has $3 billion left to sell.

Read More on News

Rather than doing a conventional offering of Genworth stock, GE crafted what Lehman Brothers tax expert Robert Willens calls a "supercharged IPO." That's when you sell stock in a new company, endow it with a tax break and split the proceeds. It's like giving your kid a house down payment, then having him kick back some of his mortgage-deduction savings to you. GE's supercharger: a new subsidiary that it created to hold the businesses Genworth was going to own. Genworth bought the businesses from the subsidiary, paying for them by giving the subsidiary Genworth stock. Because Genworth had bought the businesses, it and GE could jointly make what tax types call a 338(h)(10) election--a financial decision, not a political event. It increased the value of Genworth's assets for tax purposes by $2.04 billion, reducing Genworth's future taxes by $718 million. But this won't reduce the income Genworth reports to shareholders. (Don't ask why; it's how it is.)

This is a lot more complicated than dropping off your tax return with your accountant. Under tax rules, Genworth couldn't do a 338(h)(10) unless GE owned less than 50 percent of it immediately after its IPO. But GE didn't think it could get a decent price for a giant company like Genworth if it put more than half its stock on the market in the first offering. So GE promised the Internal Revenue Service that it would cut its stake in Genworth to less than 50 percent within two years of the IPO, and the IRS issued a private letter ruling blessing the transaction. "Brilliant, just brilliant," says Willens, the Lehman tax expert.

GE told me that it paid $1.1 billion in taxes as the result of this transaction, which became a taxable sale of assets. What's more, a GE spokesman told me, the company may well have to pay more tax on its future Genworth sales. Has GE suddenly gotten warm and fuzzy toward the IRS? Not really. It probably would have had to pay the $1.1 billion at some point anyway, because its taxable gains from selling its Genworth stock would have been larger than by going this route. Meanwhile, Genworth's taxes are lower than they'd otherwise be. The spokesman says GE wasn't avoiding taxes, it was making sure it and Genworth "were not subject to an inappropriate double tax."

Genworth has agreed to pay GE $552 million of its tax savings, and will also fork over an additional $88 million of "gross up" payments that are based on calculations so complicated they make my teeth hurt. Bottom line: GE's ahead a lot, Genworth's ahead a little.

As my holiday gift to you, I won't discuss how Genworth saves taxes on its bond portfolio. What matters here is that $75 million to $100 million of its savings come from deducting "intangible assets" from its taxable income. GE's Genworth stake had to be below 20 percent for Genworth to do that--and last week's sale reduced GE's stake to 19 percent.

So there you have it. An example of how you can find artistry in the darnedest places.

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines