10

Loading video...

Aliss Higham

By Aliss Higham

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


SNAP junk food restrictions are spreading across the United States, with 12 states now blocking purchases of soda, candy, and other foods deemed unhealthy.

The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, supported around 41 million Americans per month in 2024, providing a monthly stipend to buy groceries at participating stores. With the conservative Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) movement leading the charge, there has been a renewed push to limit what SNAP users can buy with their benefits.

So far, Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Louisiana, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Texas, and Utah have had approval from the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to ban certain types of unhealthy foods from being bought with SNAP benefits. All, barring Colorado, are Republican-led states.

Read More on U.S.

Supporters say restrictions curb diet-related disease and prevent taxpayer dollars from funding unhealthy choices. Critics argue limits won't change eating habits and reflect an ideological effort to control how low-income families shop.

The Case for Restrictions

Diet-related diseases cost the U.S. an estimated $1.1 trillion annually, according to a Tufts University study, with 85 percent of health care spending tied to chronic conditions linked to diet. Poor nutrition is also associated with roughly 500,000 deaths per year. A 2022 study found that children participating in SNAP consumed more sugary drinks and processed meats compared with income-eligible children who were not enrolled in the program.

"SNAP has looked essentially the same for over 60 years, despite scientific consensus that sugary drinks are harming our health," Christina Roberto and Alyssa Moran from the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine wrote in an opinion piece for Newsweek. "By subsidizing sugary drinks with SNAP, we are rewarding an industry that limits choices for lower-income families, ensuring the lowest-quality food is the most available and affordable option."

Republicans also frame restrictions as protecting taxpayers from footing the bill for diet-related illness. Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders called for action against soda, candy, and dessert in 2024, linking them to obesity, diabetes, and heart disease.

Republican Representative Josh Brecheen said earlier this year: "Don't ask the taxpayer to pay for it and then also expect the taxpayer to pick up the tab for the resulting health consequences."

"For years, SNAP has used taxpayer dollars to fund soda and candy—products that fuel America's diabetes and chronic disease epidemics," Health and Human Services Secretary and MAHA spearhead Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said after six more states gained approval for restrictions earlier this month, adding that the restrictions help put "real food back at the center of the program."

Grocery shopping

...

The Case Against Restrictions

But experts say SNAP limits alone won't improve health. Stephanie Hodges, public health dietitian at The Nourished Principles, told Newsweek: "Restrictions alone are unlikely to improve eating habits. The primary barrier to consuming healthier food is affordability...Banning certain foods, without incentives, is not going to have the impact many policymakers think it will."

A 2018 PLOS Medicine study found that a 30 percent financial incentive for fruit and vegetable purchases could prevent more than 300,000 cardiovascular events and cut health care costs by over $6 billion, showing that incentives may be more effective than bans.

"SNAP benefits average $187 per person per month. Restrictions don't make people healthier; they reinforce stigma and control. If the goal were improving health outcomes, we'd see expanded Medicaid, reopened rural hospitals, and investment in food deserts," Kavelle Christie, a health policy expert and CEO of Orion 360 Health, told Newsweek.

What's more, USDA data from 2016 shows SNAP and non-SNAP households spend similarly. SNAP users spend 40 percent of each dollar on basics like meat, fruits, and vegetables, 20 percent on sweetened drinks, desserts, and candy, and the remaining 4 percent on other groceries.

"Restrictions don't change diets," Christie said. "With $187 a month, families often choose calorie-dense foods that stretch further than fresh produce. That's survival, not preference."

Access, Freedom and Equity

Critics highlight access barriers in rural and underserved areas. Christie said that those in rural communities often live without reasonable access to healthy foods, sometimes known as "food deserts," which are low-income areas lacking access to affordable, healthy food options.

According to the USDA, "53.6 million people, or 17.4 percent of the U.S. population, live in tracts that are low-income and low access and are more than one-half mile or 10 miles from the nearest supermarket."

"Rural communities have lost over 100 hospitals in the past decade and often rely on gas stations or small markets. Restrictions can leave families with almost nothing usable. That's the real equity issue: communities are losing access on both the healthcare and nutrition fronts," Christie said. "That's not a path to better health; it's an erosion of autonomy and dignity. What these communities need is more investment in grocery stores, better jobs, healthcare, and preventive services, not more barriers designed to control them."

Registered dietitian Staci Gulbin, who is a former SNAP user, told Newsweek that restrictions will likely deepen food access issues.

"For those in rural areas, or in inner city regions where there are few grocery stores with healthy food options, restrictions on food purchases could lead to further food access issues," she said. "I feel a more effective solution to try and combat chronic disease in these food insecure populations is to educate them on how to eat healthier, empower them to do so, and increase their access to healthy food rather then placing further stigma and restriction on what they can eat."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines