Composite image created by Newsweek.

...

Aliss Higham

By Aliss Higham

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


New federal work rules are set to tighten access to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), raising concerns from experts who warn that the changes are unlikely to improve employment outcomes but could result in a drop in participation among low-income Americans.

Stricter Rules Take Effect

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), passed earlier this year, expands the age range for able-bodied adults without dependents who fall under SNAP’s three-month time limit. The new law pushes the upper cutoff to 65, up from 59.

Read More on News

Under the rule, individuals who do not prove at least 20 hours per week of work or participation in training programs can only receive benefits for three months within a three-year period. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), which administers SNAP, has instructed states to begin enforcing the new criteria from November 1, though rollout timelines may differ across state agencies.

The Congressional Budget Office estimates that around 1.4 million people who are newly covered under the expanded rules could lose access to SNAP in a typical month once the policy is fully implemented.

The Trump administration has argued that work requirements will reduce dependency on federal welfare programs and will help save taxpayer dollars.

In a May 2025 opinion piece for The New York Times, prior to the OBBBA being passed, Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz, and Housing Secretary Scott Turner, said that widened work requirements for SNAP will "will prioritize the vulnerable, empower able-bodied individuals, help rebuild thriving communities and protect the taxpayers."

"Our agencies are united in a very straightforward policy approach: Able-bodied adults receiving benefits must work, participate in job training or volunteer in their communities at least 20 hours a week. Limited exceptions will be made for good cause, like caring for young children and health issues, but the principle is clear—those who can work, should.

"Some will argue that work requirements create barriers to resources. We disagree. We believe that welfare dependency, not work, is the barrier," they said.

But regardless of the intentions, the new rules are almost certain to bring new challenges to SNAP beneficiaries.

Composite image created by Newsweek.

...

Do Work Requirements Increase Employment?

While the adjustment has been framed by lawmakers as an effort to encourage work, past attempts to enforce stricter rules have produced limited evidence of increased employment among SNAP users.

A January 2025 analysis from the Economic Policy Institute found that previous work requirements had “largely failed to boost work in significant ways” because they do not address “the core problems of weak macroeconomic conditions, the volatile nature of low-wage work, and other barriers to work like caregiving responsibilities.”

Lauren Schulyer, assistant research director for family welfare research at the University of Maryland School of Social Work, said her team documented similar results in a study that examined the effects of potential work requirements in Maryland. “The research is clear: SNAP work requirements do not improve employment or earnings outcomes. Instead, they result in benefit loss for low-income individuals and families,” she told Newsweek.

Experts have argued that the policy overlooks the instability that often comes with low-wage work and the various challenges some SNAP recipients have, which could result in recipients losing their benefits if they cannot fulfill the 20 hours a week rule.

Take the services industry, which employs 17 percent of all working SNAP recipients, according to the left-leaning Center for Budget and Policy Priorities. A May 2025 study by The Hamilton Project found that steady full-time work is uncommon in the service industry. As a result, 64 percent of low-income service workers fell below 80 work hours in at least one month of 2022. Even among those who averaged 80 hours or more per month across the year—the level required under current work rules—34 percent still dropped under that threshold at least once due to reduced shifts or a spell of unemployment.

Cindy Long, former undersecretary at the USDA's Food, Nutrition, and Consumer Services, told Newsweek that "the volatility of these jobs means that workers are more frequently underemployed and may struggle to consistently document 20 hours per week of work, increasing the risk that they are cut off SNAP by the three-month time limit."

Barriers To Employment

“Many barriers keep people from being able to consistently work 80 hours or more in a month: caregiving responsibilities, inconsistent scheduling in low-wage jobs, a lack of job-protected sick leave, and lack of jobs due to a lagging economy are just a few,” Jennifer Greenfield, associate professor at the University of Denver, told Newsweek.

A 2023 study published in the American Economic Journal found that participation among adults subject to work requirements that when faced with a loss of benefits, there were “no effects on employment” and pointed to disproportionate impacts on people experiencing homelessness.

Greenfield added that this can become even more difficult for older adults who may now be subject to the new requirements, those aged between 59 and 65, who often face specific challenges competing for jobs.

“People who are 55 plus often face age discrimination in hiring, as do those who have already been unemployed for 6 months or more—and the overall state of the economy worsens these challenges.”

Extra Bureaucracy

Schulyer also warned that beyond the direct loss of benefits, the policy introduces new layers of bureaucracy that could see eligible recipients losing their benefits.

“Recipients who are unfamiliar with these new processes must navigate complex rules that are new to them, track and report work hours,” she said. "These are learning costs. There are also compliance costs, such as gathering documentation, attending mandatory appointments, etc., all of which require time, resources, and digital literacy."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines