In this handout, the mug shot of hotel magnate Leona Helmsley, 21st April 1988.

...

Christopher Roberts

By Christopher Roberts

Vice President, Publishing & Subscriber Strategy

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


“We don’t pay taxes. Only the little people pay taxes.” So said Leona Helmsley, the billionaire, hotelier and “Queen of Mean,” according to her housekeeper in 1989. Helmsley always denied it, but then she also denied tax evasion, and a jury convicted her anyway.

Mug shot of hotel magnate Leona Helmsley, April 21, 1988.

...

The quote doesn’t ring true, in any case. It’s always been far more than the little people. Under the “golden age” of Eisenhower, America’s top marginal federal income tax rate was 91 percent. America wasn’t alone; Britain in the 1970s hit an equivalent marginal top rate of 98 percent.

Read More on Analysis

Reagan cut the top rate to 28 percent, and today it is 37 percent federally. Add in state taxes and the average top rate is 42.1 percent, and despite what DSA candidates might have said in the midterms, that’s barely below the European Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development’s average of 43.4.

Yet the supposed socialist paradise of Europe, with its lagging rates of productivity and growth, does indeed collect far more. America’s tax revenue is 25.6 percent of GDP, against an OECD average of 34.1. Europe doesn’t get to that figure by soaking billionaires but by taxing everybody more. Only three European countries still have a wealth tax.

Enter Gavin Newsom. The California governor (as well as several Californian tech titans) opposed Proposition 40, a one-time 5 percent tax on billionaires’ wealth which was subsequently rejected by voters in the state. It was a victory for Newsom that also exposed the Democratic divide, a fact that didn’t go unnoticed in our story. Curiously, 29 percent of readers rated that story right-leaning on our Fairness Meter, and zero rated it left-leaning.

A poll we ran pointed in the same direction. Eighty-five percent of voters supported a billionaire tax. Yet reactions among Newsweek Members were more nuanced.

“Why do we need billionaires in the U.S. at all?” asked one. Another warned that extreme inequality “is a threat to democracy itself,” and a further correspondent wryly noted that since 1913, “not a soul has died” from progressive taxation. “Shucks,” they added, “we have a trillionaire.” What you aren’t in favor of is the Prop 40 approach. “No, we don’t need a wealth tax as California had proposed,” one reader wrote, asking instead for a tax code without “thousands of loopholes.”

“Why the resentment against people who have more money than you?” asked an actual Californian. A Washington reader warned that “the rich can also afford to move.” Another put it simply: “It would be an attractive idea if it worked. It never will.”

In life, death and taxes, it’s not always easy to find a common thread. Perhaps the only unifying comment was this: “They should not have a lower tax rate than a middle-class American.”

Now that’s a real complaint. A 2021 study by Biden White House economists counted unsold stock as income and found America’s 400 wealthiest families paid an average federal income-tax rate of 8.2 percent. Critics countered that once corporate taxes are counted, the figure is nearer 23 percent. Either way, Helmsley would be proud.

Democrats will need to answer this question in the next two years: Whose side are you on, anyway?

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines