Disabled Woman Insurance Payments “Hellish” Social Security

Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Disabled Woman Insurance Payments “Hellish” Social Security

Kate Plummer

By Kate Plummer

Senior US News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A woman who fought for seven years to receive Social Security Administration (SSA) disability benefits has been left unable to access other insurance programs after the compensation she received made her financial assets appear higher than those programs' maximum permitted threshold.

Speaking to Newsweek, Amy Smith*, a 43-year-old woman with a rare connective tissue disorder who lives in Muncie, Indiana, detailed her "hellish" experience with the SSA which saw her Medicaid and other insurance payments discontinued after a lengthy legal battle with the administration resulted in her receiving a one-off compensation payment that rendered her bank balance too high to be eligible for the insurance plans. Smith said her bank balance would have been under the threshold had her Social Security payments been approved initially, without the need for compensation.

"My experience was hellish, and I wouldn't wish it on anyone else," Smith told Newsweek over the phone as she explained the sacrifices she's been forced to make as a result of the bureaucracy she faced to ensure "every day is not a constant struggle."

Read More on U.S.

More From Newsweek Vault: Checking Account vs. Savings Account: Which is Best for Your Finances?

"I won't have children, and I don't date or seek out a partner because of my financial and physical drawbacks," she said. She only affords food and other expenses because she is "incredibly thrifty".

Disabled Woman Insurance Payments “Hellish” Social Security

...

Smith's experience may sound striking, but she is just one of the hundreds of thousands of Americans who have been impacted by record waiting time at the government agency in what the SSA itself has called a "crisis."

More From Newsweek Vault: Best Place to Put Your Benefits: CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account

Smith won her compensation case with the support of an attorney in October 2023 having originally been rejected for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) in April 2017 for spinal problems caused by Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS), a rare syndrome she received a diagnosis for in 2019 that affects connective tissue and causes joint pain, fatigue, digestive problems and problems with internal organs. She also has fibromyalgia, degenerative disc disease, lumbar disc herniation, insomnia, major depressive disorder, osteoarthritis of both knees, hip bursitis, spondylosis of the spine, and scoliosis, documents she provided to SSA and seen by Newsweek show.

After her last hearing, the SSA decided Smith would receive $897 a month and seven years of backpay in SSDI, amounting to $73,000. This left her with $54,000 after she paid her lawyers a 25 percent fee. But following this payment, she was then told she was no longer eligible to receive Medicaid, a health insurance program that provides benefits to low-income individuals and people with disabilities, and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), payments for grocery spending, because she had more than $5,000 in assets in her bank account, as is the cut-off in the state. Had she received SSDI on an ongoing basis she would not have more than $5,000 in assets in her bank account, she said.

This came after she spent years wrangling with the agency.

The SSA originally denied Smith's application, saying her symptoms were not severe enough for her to be considered disabled.

"The medical evidence shows that your conditions would still allow you to perform some lighter activity," a letter sent to Smith by the SSA in September 2017 and seen by Newsweek said. "The evidence does not show any other condition which would significantly limit your ability to work. Additionally, any symptoms, such as pain, were considered in deciding this claim."

It continued: "We do not have sufficient vocational information to determine whether you can perform any of your past relevant work. However, based on the evidence in file, we have determined that you can adjust to other work."

"Based on your age (036 years and 06 months), education (16 years), and past work experience, we have determined that your overall medical condition allows the performance of other work."

Smith then faced a number of hearings as she appealed the decision, confronting many roadblocks along the way.

A May 2019 hearing was canceled the day before it was due to be held because the judge who was to oversee it had a family emergency, she said. In another instance, a judge retired and Smith had to wait 18 months until he was replaced. Meanwhile, during this period, she was forced to file for bankruptcy in 2018 because she could not pay her bills despite living "penny to penny" and doing part-time copywriting jobs from home. She also had to move in with her mother, who then died of lung cancer in May 2020.

Another decision letter sent in August 2020 said "the claimant had the residual functional capacity to perform sedentary work" and that her "statements concerning the intensity, persistence and limiting effects" of her symptoms "are not entirely consistent with the medical evidence," despite Smith alleging pain and other limiting symptoms.

Social security

...

Smith had three appeals and five total hearings before she won her case.

Reflecting on her experience, she told Newsweek: "My message for the Social Security Administration would be that people literally die or become homeless waiting for disability to come through. I was lucky that I had a family members that was willing to allow me to live with her while I waited through this process. Not everyone is fortunate enough to have that. The SSA needs to be more willing to help people through this process instead of essentially outsourcing it to lawyers who take 25 percent of the back pay. I had to do so much of my own legwork and my attorneys took every single penny they were allowed to."

A spokesperson from the Indiana Family and Social Services Administration told Newsweek it could not comment on specific cases. It said that non-recurring lump sum payments are usually considered resources and that households should apply for SNAP when resources are less than $5000.

A Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) spokesperson told Newsweek: "While CMS does not comment or speculate on individual cases, individuals who believe their coverage may have been denied or terminated improperly have a right to appeal the decision by requesting a fair hearing. Each state operates its own fair hearing process within federal rules."

A U.S. Department of Agriculture Food and Nutrition Service (USDA) spokesperson told Newsweek:

"Federal law and regulations require State agencies include certain resources when determining SNAP eligibility. This includes lump-sum payments, such as retroactive SSDI payments.

"Only households with countable resources under a certain amount are eligible for SNAP. The Food and Nutrition Service (FNS) determines the national SNAP resource limit annually as required by Federal law. For Fiscal Year 2024, the SNAP resource limit is $2,750 or $4,250 if at least one member of the household is age 60 or older or is disabled. However, the resource limit can differ depending on the State's broad-based categorical eligibility (BBCE) policy. BBCE allows States to align income and resource limits with their Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)-funded programs for households that get TANF-funded benefits. Regardless, all households must meet SNAP non-financial eligibility rules and have income low enough to receive SNAP benefits.

"Indiana uses BBCE and sets a $5,000 resource limit; other States have different resource limits or no resource limit. Therefore, in Indiana, if a SNAP participant receives a retroactive SSDI lump-sum payment that puts them over the $5,000 asset limit, their SNAP case may close. If so, this individual could reapply for SNAP at any time but would not be eligible until their countable assets are below $5,000."

Newsweek also contacted the Indiana SSA by email to comment on this story.

The SSA provides two types of disability assistance, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), a safety net for older people and people with disabilities with limited income and SSDI, general payments for individuals with disabilities, tied to a claimant's work history. To qualify for the payments, applicants must have a medical condition that prevents them from earning substantial income that will last at least a year or result in death.

Waiting times for these services are on the rise. In 2019, 600,000 people were on a list awaiting initial disability determinations. In 2023, this figure surpassed 1 million for the first time.

Meanwhile, the nationwide average for processing initial disability claims is 347 days despite the government agency having a processing goal of 7 months (215 days) by the end of fiscal year 2025 and completing SSDI appeals within 270 days.

During fiscal year 2023, 30,000 people died while waiting for disability determinations at either initial, reconsideration or hearing levels, Social Security Commissioner Martin O'Malley told Nextgov/FCW.

Soni Slater, 48, who lives near San Francisco in California said she made an SSDI claim in August 2022 having lived with physical and mental disabilities including arthritis for most of her life and working part-time in communications roles. She said she was initially rejected in May 2023 with the SSA saying she was well enough to work. She told Newsweek she appealed in July 2023 and is still waiting for a decision one year later.

"It's terrible," she said. "You're treated like you're lying and you have to convince someone that you're not."

She added: "I have no doubt that I qualify for SSDI and that if I were to go on to a hearing I would be approved, but they really put me through the ringer trying to prove they can't work, taking years while we lose everything and destroy our credit. I have no family to help me. If I am not approved in reconsideration, I will have to wait another year for a hearing."

Meanwhile, Patrick Bruck, who is 35 and lives in Maryland, has also been embroiled in legal battles with the SSA since 2012 to receive SSDI. He said he lives with "severe spinal deformities", which cause chronic pain, as well as bipolar, depression and anxiety.

Bruck told Newsweek he applied three times but has been denied by assessors who claim he is able to work.

"They pretty much make the disabled person do all the work," he said. "It feels like a criminal trial."

"Being disabled is like having a full-time job that costs you money," he added. "A lot of people die while waiting."

According to the then-acting Social Security Commissioner Kilolo Kijakazi, writing in the Social Security Administration annual performance plan for fiscal year 2024, wait times are increasing because of both an increasing number of disability claimants and staffing challenges at the agency.

"One of the most critical issues we face right now is the significant number of people who are waiting too long—over seven months on average—for a disability decision, which is now a service delivery crisis," she wrote.

When asked for comment, an SSA spokesperson told Newsweek the agency was taking steps to reduce its average initial disability processing time for customers including by reducing administrative burdens for applicants and helping more people with disabilities receive government benefits and services if they are eligible.

*Names have been changed to protect sources who spoke to Newsweek under the condition of anonymity.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines