10
Loading video...
By Ronan Sayburn
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Budget pressures often lead restaurants to cut the sommelier first, or just never hire one. Owners see the salary saved and assume someone else can manage the wine list. Over 25 years on restaurant floors, I have seen where that leads.
Some of London’s newest luxury hotels stretch one or two sommeliers across up to 10 restaurants, raise wine prices to compensate, then watch cash sales fall. Removing the person whose sales add profit at almost no extra cost is a financial mistake, not a saving.
Hospitality is under intense pressure, with rising wages, energy, food prices, and taxes. Total restaurant expenses have risen 36 percent since before the pandemic, and 42 percent of U.S. operators said their restaurant was not profitable in 2025, according to the National Restaurant Association.
Read More on Leadership Insights
Under such pressure, roles that look like luxuries are the first to be downsized.

...
Why Sommeliers Matter
Kitchens carry heavy overheads, including staff, ingredients, energy, and waste. The median full-service restaurant kept just 2.8 percent of its sales as pretax profit, according to the National Restaurant Association’s latest data.
With margins that thin, every additional sale that costs little to deliver matters. Hiring five more chefs rarely adds much profit, but selling a second bottle of wine, another glass of champagne, or a glass of dessert wine adds revenue with almost no extra cost.
That’s why a skilled beverage specialist is one of the few roles on the floor that directly pays for itself.
Owners, hoteliers, and hospitality group executives can fix this. Keep a dedicated beverage lead on the floor during service, watching for the moments guests are ready to order.
An overworked general manager will always miss those moments. If a full-time specialist isn’t affordable, train an enthusiastic team member with strong selling skills, ideally in exchange for a six- to 12-month commitment to stay.
Give that person ownership of the wine list, with a set budget and sales targets, so stock doesn’t pile up in the cellar.
The Cost of Cutting
Even as apps and AI take over parts of service, guests still want personal advice from someone who has studied the craft. Hospitality is often treated as a temporary job for students and weekend shifts.
Skilled beverage roles give people a reason to build a long-term career, as many do in mainland Europe for 30 or 40 years. Where pay is limited, training costs little and builds loyalty, especially when trained staff help shape the wine list they want to sell.
When the specialist goes, the salary savings show up at once, but the losses build slowly over the next three to six months. Second bottles and dessert wines go unsold.

...
Waiters with no training are pushed to sell wines they can’t explain, and guests notice. Delivery mistakes go unchecked, and faulty bottles aren’t returned for credit. It is a short-term fix for a long-term problem.
If operators keep cutting specialists over the next five to 10 years, I expect wine lists to become generic, filled with mass-produced bottles guests can find in any supermarket. Smaller producers, growers, and independent merchants that rely on knowledgeable buyers may lose their route to diners.
The pipeline of skilled professionals could shrink as fewer people see a career in the craft. If that happens, restaurants risk losing the very thing that makes guests choose them over a night at home.
Investing in Expertise
The damage starts with a single missed moment at the table, an empty glass no one spots, or a pairing no one offers. If it isn’t offered, it isn’t sold. Sales fall, so management raises wine prices or cuts corners on details like glassware. Guests see the markups and buy less, so the margin percentage looks healthy while cash takings shrink. Bookings drop, and a hard-won reputation begins to slip.
Hong Kong offers a useful model, where employers commonly expect formal wine qualifications for drinks roles and higher levels for anyone running a program. Restaurants already accept that a serious kitchen needs a pastry chef, and the front of house deserves the same specialist standards.

...
Guests get a night out tailored to their tastes and budget, without aggressive upselling. Restaurants that make this shift see better margins, more loyal guests, and hospitality professionals who see a future in the industry.
A restaurant can take 10 years to build its reputation and six months to lose it. The sommelier isn’t a luxury to cut in hard times; they are one of the best investments a restaurant can make when times are hard.
Ronan Sayburn is chief executive of the Court of Master Sommeliers Europe, which trains and certifies sommeliers across 29 countries. The views expressed in this article are the author's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines