0.cached.png

0.cached.png

Ellis Cose

By Ellis Cose

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Never apologize and never explain" may have been a fine creed for the cavalry officer played by John Wayne in "She Wore a Yellow Ribbon," released in 1949. But today, public figures reject such counsel out of hand. When caught with their better judgment down, they typically beg forgiveness, albeit with a caveat: "I'm so sorry I offended you, but that wasn't the real me."

When Flip Wilson declared "The Devil made me do it" years ago, he was trying to be funny. Michael

Richards, explaining how he was caught on tape acting like a KKK recruiter on crack, apparently was not. Nor was Mel Gibson, George Allen, Ted Haggard or Mark Foley. They, instead, were trying to make us understand how decent folks like themselves could have gone so wrong with America watching.

Read More on News

Public apologies can do some good--and not only for the career of the offender. No country has more compellingly shown that than South Africa, which some 10 years ago, as it emerged from the dark era of apartheid, convened its Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Time and again South Africans witnessed scenes in which people who had been terribly abused tearfully reconciled with perpetrators--once an apology and explanation had been offered. The encounters made for breathtaking drama--many were nationally televised--and fueled the notion that a personal apology, publicly accepted, could help heal a nation.

One of my more haunting memories from that period is of a conversation with a woman, Thandi Shezi, who had been active in a community group that worked against apartheid. A few years before South Africa's political transition, police swarmed Shezi's poor township and took her into custody. They raped her, beat her, subjected her to electroshocks and strangled her to a point just short of death. Then they tossed her into solitary confinement, where they held her for roughly a year, never charging her with any crime. When the TRC convened, Shezi told her story and waited for her torturers to confess. She was prepared to forgive them but never got her chance; her tormentors refused to admit any wrongdoing. "I managed to reconcile with what happened to me," she told me, "but I haven't reconciled with the perpetrators ... I didn't get anything out of [the process]."

Wherever such commissions have convened, they have produced stories like Thandi Shezi's, stories of people who didn't receive the satisfaction they felt they were owed--whether an apology was offered or not--and who continue to carry the pain inflicted by their transgressors.

The young men who were the target of Richards's racist rage have already pronounced themselves unsatisfied with his first public apology. And Richards, essentially conceding that he has not yet done enough, hired a publicist to help him make amends --which, in this case, for some odd reason, meant calling Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton. It's the same strategy employed by Mel Gibson, who pronounced himself ready to "meet with leaders in the Jewish community, with whom I can have a one-on-one discussion to discern the appropriate path for healing."

Certainly, people of good will, whatever the race or religion, hope that Richards and his kindred spirits find their way to a better place. But it's impossible to know how sincere their apologies are. And it doesn't really matter very much. The more interesting fact is that they felt compelled to apologize at all.

As Richards nostalgically pointed out, there was indeed a time when he could have stuck a fork in his hecklers and hanged them from a tree (and, in fact, done much, much worse). In certain parts of the country, no one would have raised a voice in protest. That era is clearly no more--just as the era of casual public anti-Semitism is gone. The apologies, in other words, serve as markers of where we have come as a society. Clearly, there is something very different in scale from undergoing torture at the hands of apartheid's enforcers--or watching family members whisked away by Peru's militia, loved ones massacred in East Timor orinnocents lynched in the American South--and sitting through a Michael Richards rant. What links them is the fact that, once upon a time, all were tolerated--or considered tolerable--in societies where they no longer are.

That the public demands an apology from such people as Richards is healthy. For the ritual helps to remind us what we, as a nation, as a people, stand for, or stand against, and what will not be lightly tolerated--regardless of whether Mel Gibson really means it when he sheepishly says, "I'm sorry."

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines