
...


By Dan Gooding and Gabe Whisnant
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor warned Monday that the Supreme Court is being asked to choose between “two extremes” as it considers whether Cox Communications can be held liable for music piracy by its users.
During arguments, Sotomayor and other justices pressed Cox on its claim that awareness of customer infringement cannot trigger contributory copyright liability. But the court also questioned whether holding the company responsible for failing to cut off infringers could jeopardize internet access for innocent users.
"We are being put to two extremes here," Sotomayor told Paul Clement, the attorney representing the music labels, on Monday. "How do we announce a rule that deals with those two extremes?"
Read More on U.S.
The case, brought by major record labels, could expose Cox to as much as $1.5 billion in damages.
Why It Matters
The case centers on whether internet providers can be held liable for online music piracy, potentially leaving companies with billions of dollars in damage payments to artists and record labels. In previous cases, the U.S. Supreme Court has left that liability in the hands of users rather than the technology platforms they use.

...
What To Know
Sony, Warner Music, and Universal Music are suing Cox for failing to shut down customer accounts found to be downloading and sharing songs without permission.
The plaintiffs previously successfully argued that many of Cox's subscribers were flagrantly infringing copyright following the initial 2018 filing. A jury awarded plaintiffs $1 billion in damages, and the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the ruling in part in 2024.
Then, judges found that Cox Communications was liable for contributory copyright infringement because the company had not done enough to cut off users who were allegedly pirating content. Cox appealed, sending the case to the Supreme Court to decide a secondary liability issue.
In a case involving Twitter—now X—two years ago, the court ruled that the social media platform was not liable for facilitating terrorist activity merely because it provided a platform and algorithm, and that the company had not acted with ill intent.
That ruling was discussed during opening remarks on Monday, with justices hearing from Cox's team that the company had limited ability to monitor users' activity compared to Twitter. Sotomayor pushed back on that argument, saying the company did have that capability.
Cox did not necessarily have to terminate users found to have infringed copyright, but accusations of failing to do more to stop pirated content have persisted. During the hearing on Monday, Cox argued it had initiated a program that penalized thousands of customers linked to the activity.
While Sony and the other media companies have had backing from artist groups, and those seeking to stop copyright infringement, other groups including the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) have warned that penalizing internet providers and forcing stricter regulations could impact First Amendment rights.
What People Are Saying
Cox Communications, in a press release following Monday's hearing: “We appreciate the opportunity to present our case to the Supreme Court and are grateful for the Solicitor General’s participation in today’s arguments. As we have said throughout, internet service providers should not be held liable for the infringement of few customers when the internet provider did not aid, foster, encourage or profit from the alleged conduct. Today’s argument showed how the lower court ruling, if untouched, could jeopardize internet access for all Americans.”
Song Music Entertainment, et al, in their filing to the court: "At bottom, Cox may not think that helping 60,000 of its subscribers distribute more than 10,000 copyrighted works for free is a very big deal, but Congress, at least a century’s worth of this Court’s cases, and respondents’ experiences with the real world effects of infringement beg to differ."
Evelyn Danforth-Scott, staff attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union, in a press release Monday: “This case is bigger than one company paying penalties to another. This is about incentivizing service providers to shut off internet access first and ask questions later. In our increasingly connected and digital world, where we use the Internet to speak, listen, research, and create, that threatens all of our First Amendment rights.”
What Happens Next
A decision has yet to be made in the case, but the justices could leave internet service providers with greater responsibility to cut off users' internet access if they are found to have infringed copyright in the future.
Update 12/01/25, 2:53 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines