10
Loading video...
By Andrew Gould
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Joel Klatt joined a loud chorus of critics upset with Tuesday's College Football Playoff rankings reveal.
The Fox Sports broadcaster didn't hold back his feelings on the CFP selection committee during an appearance on Wednesday's "The Herd" with Colin Cowherd.
"This is the worst playoff committee that we've had in 12 years," Klatt declared.
Read More on NCAA
Klatt was particularly dismayed by Alabama staying at No. 3 despite its previous SEC opponents losing on Saturday. The same circumstances caused Indiana to plummet to No. 9 last week.
The analyst argued that the committee won't own up to overrating the 8-2 Crimson Tide, so they're doubling down rather than correcting an initial miscalculation.
"There's absolutely no rationale for Alabama being No. 3," Klatt said. "There's nothing to point to. This is like, you and your wife are in the car, and you're driving. You take a wrong turn, and you know it's wrong. And then you're like, 'Ugh, but I can't admit it.' And she's like, 'Babe, are we going the right way?' And you're like, 'Yep. Absolutely. It's a shortcut. Don't worry, we'll get there.' And in the back of your mind, you're like, 'This is totally wrong.'
"The committee is just being stubborn. They put Alabama at three. They don't want to tell us they were wrong, so they keep them at three. The exact same rationale that they used to move Indiana down five spots for not playing because the rest of their schedule lost is exactly what happened to Alabama, and Alabama didn't play well on the road against Vanderbilt."

...
Klatt feels the committee is going in circles attempting to justify Alabama's placement.
"It's a feedback loop," Klatt said. "Why is Alabama No. 3? Because the SEC is really difficult this year and very strong? OK, well why is the SEC really strong? Well, because Alabama is No. 3."
However, it's not necessarily an SEC bias. Klatt noted that Alabama has lost to No. 9 Tennessee and feels No. 5 Texas has "far better wins" with the same overall record.
"Nothing about it makes sense," Klatt claimed. "This is a committee that is now being stubborn. They're driving the car, we're all passengers in it, and they won't tell us they took a wrong turn."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines