JJ McCarthy, Minnesota Vikings

...

Tyler Erzberger

By Tyler Erzberger

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


J.J. McCarthy is in an awkward position.

After the Minnesota Vikings let Sam Darnold go his way in the 2025 offseason to make McCarthy feel confident in his position within the Vikings organization, the entire fanbase had to watch as Darnold joined the Seattle Seahawks and won the Super Bowl in his first season out west.

To make matters worse, McCarthy wasn't great in 2025. Nor was he good. Nor was he average.

Read More on NFL

He was historically bad, even for a rookie, during his first season with the Vikings, and injuries also plagued him, already missing what should have been his rookie year due to injury.

As we start the 2026 year, McCarthy is no longer the protected asset he was a year ago; the Vikings have signed former No. 1 overall pick Kyler Murray and are ready to move on from the Michigan Wolverine if needed.

McCarthy is in a similar weird spot to another young, highly-touted quarterback at this time a decade ago. His name was Jared Goff.

More news: No More Drama: It’s Time for the Eagles to Trade A.J. Brown

Jared Goff

...

More news: The Pittsburgh Steelers Need to Move On From Aaron Rodgers

Goff was the No. 1 pick in the 2016 NFL Draft, and he was outright awful in his first year in Los Angeles with the Rams, their inaugural campaign back after relocating from St. Louis. In his first (and only) season under Jeff Fisher, pundits were ready to write him off as the biggest bust since JaMarcus Russell with the Raiders.

Then came a 30-year-old with a remarkable memory and an intense attitude, Sean McVay, who changed everything for Goff, who, now with the Detroit Lions, has established a remarkable career for himself.

The Rams need a plan for when Matthew Stafford retires, be it next year or in the future, and they shouldn't be shy about taking as many shots as possible as an organization to set up the passing of the torch.

McVay's team is set up to contend for a long time with a relatively young roster aside from QB, and setting up McCarthy as the heir for Stafford could be one of their optimal choices. It shouldn't be their lone choice, but in a shallow QB draft and the pedigree McCarthy has, there might not be another head coach in football better trained to get the most out of the former national champion than the Rams' head man.

The Vikings are already side-eyeing the exit door for McCarthy without making it too uncomfortable.

If McVay, as a teacher, along with the reigning MVP Stafford as a mentor, isn't enough to turn McCarthy into a franchise QB, then nothing is.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines