WWE

Andrew Ravens‎

By Andrew Ravens‎

Contributing Sports Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Have you ever wondered if the absolute buzz around a mystery reveal could actually work against the debut of a new babyface performer? WWE likely had a different thought when they decided to have new star Danhausen revealed as the secret inside the mystery crate at Elimination Chamber.

The event, which took place at the United Center in Chicago on February 28, 2026, was one of the most anticipated stops on the road to WrestleMania 42. However, the introduction of the "very nice and very evil" star did not go exactly according to the plan of the creative team. Minutes after CM Punk successfully defended his World Heavyweight Championship in a technical match with Finn Bálor, WWE unveiled the 35-year-old former AEW standout to a crowd that was not kind in their response.

Placement Was Everything — And It Was Wrong

The reaction from the WWE fans in Chicago was a complicated mix of confusion and frustration. The segment began with an elaborate entrance preceded by a group of dancers wearing black leather and face paint, which initially drew a partial cheer. However, as the reveal of Danhausen from a coffin inside the mystery crate became clear, the cheers were quickly replaced by loud and sustained boos.

Read More on Wrestling

The transition from the high-stakes, 21-minute title defense of CM Punk—who entered to the Chicago Bulls' "Sirius" theme and was introduced by Ray Clay—to the eccentric debut of a comedy character proved to be a hurdle the company could not overcome. Following a hometown performance by a star as large as Punk is a near-impossible task, and the exhausted audience was not prepared for the tonal shift.

WWE

The Hype Created Expectations WWE Couldn't Meet

The buildup to this moment had been extensive, with the mystery crate appearing on television for several weeks. This created an exponential level of hype that led to wild speculation, with marquee names like Chris Jericho circulating heavily as potential candidates. When the mystery produced Danhausen instead of a legendary veteran, the crowd felt underwhelmed.

Furthermore, while the character has a dedicated niche following, he lacked the necessary familiarity with a mainstream WWE audience. The segment ended abruptly; after Danhausen handed a jar of teeth to Michael Cole, the lights went out and he vanished along with his dancers, leaving many in attendance to wonder if that was the entire presentation.

What Happens Next is Important

Despite the rocky start, the debut has become a polarizing topic that is driving significant engagement. While the live crowd expressed frustration, the digital metrics tell a different story. The video of the debut has surpassed 1.4 million views on TikTok and over 520,000 views on YouTube, outperforming the viewership for both CM Punk's defense and Randy Orton’s massive Elimination Chamber win. Triple H addressed the backlash during the post-show press conference, noting, "Michael Cole's got a nice bucket of teeth. I think we're in for a fun time."

As the roster heads toward WrestleMania 42 in Las Vegas, officials are reportedly evaluating how to leverage this social media success to overcome the live reaction hurdle.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines