An illustration picture taken in London on May 8, 2022, shows a gold plated souvenir cryptocurrency Tether (USDT) coin arranged beside a screen displaying US dollar notes. Tether (USDT) is an Ethereum token known as a stablecoin that is pegged to the value of the US dollar, and is currently the largest stablecoin with a market value of USD 83 billion dollars. (Photo by Justin TALLIS / AFP) (Photo by JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP via Getty Images)

...

Paul Brody

By Paul Brody

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Last month at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, the IMF’s first deputy managing director warned that rising stablecoin usage can put “competitive pressure” on countries with weak fiscal and monetary frameworks.

That is diplomatic language for a bigger and under-discussed shift. People and businesses are gaining a low-friction path into the U.S. dollar that can bypass local banking rails. The result is a growing risk of global dollarization by default, rather than by design.

That shift matters because currencies are not just symbols or policy tools. They might be the very oldest “platform” in technology. The “OG” (original) economic stack that allowed nations to scale their operations, build robust ecosystems and tax transactions that take place inside of their walled gardens. Considering that the first known paper currencies took shape in China in the Tang dynasty (seventh century), all this technology industry jargon sounds silly. But it is not.

Read More on Essays

If we invented them today, we would definitely talk about them as a technology platform. They provide a standardized piece of infrastructure on which it is possible to build an extensible economic model. No constant fussing with the exchange rate between rice and oxen. Just prices for both and a centralized network operator who is willing to redeem your paper currency for gold on demand, in theory.

An illustration picture taken in London on May 8, 2022, shows a gold-plated souvenir cryptocurrency Tether (USDT) coin arranged beside a screen displaying U.S. dollar notes. Tether (USDT) is an Ethereum token known as a stablecoin that is pegged to the value of the U.S. dollar. (Photo by JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP via Getty Images)

...

They also come with walled gardens. Governments have long pegged the value of their currencies to gold and often control the rate and scope of redemption opportunities. The U.S., U.K. and India all had bans on private individuals owning “monetary” gold instruments. At least some of India’s insatiable modern appetite for gold jewelry can be heavily attributed to the fact that gold jewelry was exempt from those restrictions.

In the digital era, governments have simply required people to hold their local bank accounts in local currency, or they have strictly limited when and how much people can legally obtain foreign currency. Since it’s nearly impossible to run any kind of modern economy based entirely on physical cash or without banking, regulatory control of a digital banking system allows governments to have control over foreign exchange. Those are the walls of the walled garden.

Just like any digital platform, currencies have network effects that help bring in new members and lock in participation. The more people who transact in a currency and price their goods in a currency, the more attractive it is to adopt that currency. Whenever you start dealing with foreign currencies, you must manage a new type of risk: that the relative prices of two currencies will change over time. Pricing and paying in one currency reduces that risk as much as possible.

Historically, the network effects of dominant currencies were limited by the friction imposed at the entry and exit points in walled gardens. Even in countries with hyperinflation, you will still see people trying to manage their finances in local currencies and even carrying around huge stacks of cash.

Today, however, thanks to stablecoins and self-custody, the walls around some of the world’s national currencies are looking very porous and there is a real danger that we’re heading toward some level of global dollarization without fully preparing for or understanding the consequences.

A stablecoin is a digital token designed to hold a steady value (most commonly $1) by being pegged to a currency and backed by reserves. Unlike bank deposits, stablecoins can be sent globally, 24/7, over public blockchains, and they can be held in self-custody wallets, meaning the user controls the private keys rather than relying on a bank.

The scale is no longer niche. In mid-January, the global stablecoin supply hit a record above $311 billion (about $309 billion after the peak), driven mainly by USDT and USDC. Stablecoins have become a major payments rail inside crypto markets, with estimates that they comprise about 30 percent of on-chain transaction volume, reaching over $4 trillion in volume for 2025 by August.

Global dollarization would bring with it both risks and rewards. The good news is that widespread dollarization will reduce the ability of bad governments to, in effect, confiscate wealth through hyperinflation. It will also give governments strong incentives to improve the quality and independence of their central banks since they are now, in effect, competing with the dollar.

The bad news is that changes in exchange rates are one of the most important tools for helping countries reset their economies and return to growth after a recession. Depreciating their currency makes exports more competitive and does so without forcing a pay cut in local currency terms on everyone. Without this escape valve for the economy, the alternatives are painful. If your costs are too high and you can’t depreciate your currency, you must find ways to reduce them—and this often ends up as real pay cuts for workers.

The experience of Greece during the global financial crisis is instructive. Because Greece is a member of the Euro zone, there was no option for the Greek government to unilaterally reduce the value of the currency to cut their costs relative to other countries. Instead, costs had to come down the hard way: The economy contracted by over 25 percent, which makes that a depression, not a recession. And real wages are estimated to have declined by nearly 30 percent. Unemployment rose to 28 percent at its peak. That’s what an economic reset looks like without the ability to devalue a currency.

For financial institutions, there’s another risk: Banking as an industry used to be one of the biggest beneficiaries of the walled gardens around currencies. In a dollarized world where consumers can pick any stablecoin from any country, the competition for customer assets will be global and intense.

So how likely is such an outcome? The U.S. dollar remains the world’s pre-eminent convertible currency. More than 99 percent of all stablecoins are U.S. dollars, and while people are launching many new local currency stablecoin options, much of the accelerating adoption of the U.S. dollar is coming in the markets with low central bank governance quality. People are choosing to dollarize wherever they lack confidence in their local governments and central banks. Although the average quality of central bank governance has been rising steadily, based on the Central Bank Independence Index, about 3.3 billion people live in countries that don’t meet the minimum standards for central bank governance quality.

Even in countries that have more recently cleaned up their act after a bout of hyperinflation, the distrust lingers. Indeed, mistrust of national financial institutions might last one to two generations. Germany only reluctantly agreed to give up the Deutsche Mark for the Euro in the 1990s, and that was 60 years after that country’s experience of hyperinflation.

What’s the end game? If banking, currencies and finance follow the same path as the internet, then in time, some level of national regulation and differentiation will re-assert itself, but in a weaker form than what exists today.

The internet started as a borderless global network. Over time, national regulations and differentiation started to play a bigger role and most businesses comply with regulations. However, the internet still makes it possible to hop borders and see competing prices and options in a way that was never possible before, and this acts as a kind of continuous feedback mechanism into local markets. That pattern may repeat, this time with the U.S. dollar.

Paul Brody is the Global Blockchain Leader for EY (Ernst & Young). He is also the chairman of the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance and the author of the book Ethereum for Business.

Note: These are the personal views of the author and do not represent the views of EY.

In a polarized era, the center is dismissed as bland. At Newsweek, ours is different: The Courageous Center—it's not "both sides," it's sharp, challenging and alive with ideas. We follow facts, not factions. If that sounds like the kind of journalism you want to see thrive, we need you.

When you become a Newsweek Member, you support a mission to keep the center strong and vibrant. Members enjoy: Ad-free browsing, exclusive content and editor conversations. Help keep the center courageous. Join today.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines