Lauren Giella

By Lauren Giella

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Massachusetts State Auditor Diana DiZoglio found that UMass Memorial Health Care (UMMHC) failed to provide proper accounting for how it spent $6.2 million in COVID relief grants.

Earlier this month, the Massachusetts Office of the State Auditor (OSA) published a report of an audit of UMMHC activities from July 1, 2020, to June 30, 2023. One of its findings looked into how the health system spent funds from the Executive Office of Health and Human Services (EOHHS) intended to help with pandemic recovery needs.

The health system told the state that the funds were used to pay COVID bonuses to staff, but OSA states in its report that UMMH could have used the funds to save one of its maternity units from closing.

Read More on Business

Why It Matters

In a statement to Newsweek, DiZoglio said the audit highlights "significant concerns regarding UMass Memorial Health Care’s management of public funds intended to support essential health services."

"When an organization cannot account for how millions of taxpayer dollars were spent, it raises questions not only about financial oversight but also about whether communities are receiving the healthcare support they need," she said. "Transparency and accountability are not just administrative requirements — they are vital to maintaining public trust and ensuring that state resources deliver measurable benefits for residents."

UMMH is a private, nonprofit healthcare provider in Central Massachusetts with four hospitals in the region. It has a health equity strategy that focuses on addressing and reducing health disparities in the communities it serves

According to OSA, MassHealth, the state’s Medicaid program, paid UMMH $5.48 billion for medical services at its four hospitals during the period of the audit, adding that the total Medicaid revenue received by UMMH increased during each year of the audit period.

By using the EOHSS funds for bonuses instead of investing in the maternity center at HealthAlliance Clinton Hospital’s Leominster from closing in 2023, OSA said UMMH “created a health disparity for its patients, of whom 20 percent are MassHealth members.”

“This is just one example of a loss of a service that may have been prevented if grant funds were used in a different way,” OSA said in its report.

What To Know

The state auditor found that UMMH could not provide the necessary documents to show how it spent the money from the EOHHS grant. After the investigation, lawyers for UMMH informed the state that the funds were used to reimburse the health systems for money spent on employee bonuses from 2020 and 2021, totaling $10.6 million. According to the auditor's office, UMMH did not provide any accounting records to corroborate that the grant revenue was used to offset the bonus expenses.

OSA said the lack of source documentation is “troubling” and does not appear to be consistent with the intent of the payment agreement between UMMH and EOHHS. UMMH’s representation said the COVID retention bonuses fell under “increased cost of workforce” consideration in the payment agreement.

In September 2023, UMMH closed the maternity center at its HealthAlliance Clinton Hospital’s Leominster Campus due to a shortage of necessary staff. According to OSA, the maternity ward could have been saved.

“UMMH could have considered allocating those funds to maternity care or other critical healthcare services, rather than spending these taxpayer-funded grants to reimburse itself for UMMH’s prior year expenditures, such as employee bonuses,” the report said.

The state recommended that the health system maintain detailed accounting records and an audit trail, use taxpayer funded grants to maintain operations of essential services and reassess the need for maternity care in the community HealthAlliance Clinton Hospital serves and “work towards mitigating health disparities caused by a lack of maternity care in the region.”

In a statement to Newsweek, UMMH said the funds were allocated to fiscally strained hospitals designated by the Centers for Health Information Analysis as high public pay hospitals.

“As documented in records provided to the OSA, these funds were used to provide appreciation bonuses to thousands of front-line employees, including nurses and other staff, in recognition of their dedication and sacrifices during an unprecedented global health crisis,” UMMH said. “By doing so, UMMH fully complied with all provisions and requirements related to its receipt of these funds.”

UMMH also said that it disagrees with OSA’s assertion that it could have used the funds to save HealthAlliance-Clinton Hospital’s inpatient maternity unit. It noted that well-documented workforce shortages exacerbated the challenges of fully staffing the unit for several years, “despite our persistent attempts to recruit and retain clinicians in this region.”

“This, along with the steadily declining number of births in North Central Massachusetts, had a significant impact on our unit’s ability to continue to provide the best possible labor and delivery care to our patients and contributed to the need to close the unit,” the health system said.

What Happens Next

Looking ahead, State Auditor DiZolgio said her office urges UMMH to adopt its recommendations for improvement. She told Newsweek that her office will be revisiting UMMH’s progress in about six months as part of our post-audit review.

Have an announcement or news to share? Contact the Newsweek Health Care team at health.care@newsweek.com.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines