
0.cached.png
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Paroled killers keep to the straight and narrow
In America, for the most part, we don't lock 'em up and throw away the key. Nearly everyone eventually gets out of jail: the multiple rapist, the gun-toting robber, even Leonardo Ramos Lopez. In 1971 Lopez and a partner ambushed five Dallas County sheriff's deputies who had come to arrest them on burglary charges. They bound the hands of the lawmen with wire and drove them to a desolate stretch of land at the banks of the Trinity River. Two escaped, but Lopez and his accomplice killed the other three. A jury swiftly dispatched them to death row. But like hundreds of other inmates across the nation who faced the executioner, Lopez and his partner were spared by Furman v. Georgia, a 1972 U.S. Supreme Court decision that temporarily ruled the death penalty unconstitutional. Resentenced to life imprisonment, Lopez sought parole 16 times before he was freed late last year. "This is the most horrible miscarriage of justice that ever walked," complained Wendell Dover, 69, one of the surviving deputies.
Dover's ordeal was one of unspeakable horror. But is the public safety compromised with Leonardo Lopez on the street? New studies indicate that once released, death-row alumni are more likely to stay straight than other ex-convicts. Of the 600 inmates plucked from death row by Furman who are now on parole across the nation, 80 percent remain free. Fewer than 1 percent have been convicted of another homicide. Just 18 of 68 Texas parolees have returned to prison for another crime-only one for homicide. The parolees' recidivism rate (26 percent) is conspicuously lower than that of Texas's general prison population (45 percent). "When you line murderers up against thieves and dopeheads, the risk comes from the latter group," says James Marquart, a criminal-justice professor at Sam Houston State University. "Murderers very rarely do it again."
Read More on News
Texas politicians find cold comfort in the numbers. Fearful of appearing soft on violent crime, legislators have fallen over themselves denouncing Lopez's release. Last month, they summoned members of the state's Board of Pardons and Paroles for a grilling and postponed two pending reappointments to the panel. "This is absolutely shocking," said state Sen. Ted Lyon, an ex-cop. "If young punks see murderers getting out after 15 years, it does nothing to deter them." Gov. Ann Richards quickly endorsed legislation authorizing life sentences without parole for some murder cases. Last week the bill was sailing toward passage by an overwhelming margin.
Lost in the rhetoric are practical and economic arguments for parole. Like dozens of other states, Texas is under court order to reduce overcrowding in its prison system. To comply, it must release 750 inmates a week. The alternative may be politically popular, but prohibitively expensive. Parole board chairman James Granberry estimates that it would cost Texas taxpayers an extra $18 million a week--$6.5 billion a year--to eliminate paroles and house inmates earmarked for release. Those costs would escalate dramatically as aging prisoners developed chronic health problems requiring expensive medical care. "People cry for blood, but are they willing to bear the costs?" Granberry asks.
Why are these killers such good risks? Part of the explanation is age. Growing older tends to diminish the antisocial impulses that propel criminal behavior. Because they usually serve lengthy prison terms, most killers are into middle age and uninterested or unable to resume criminal careers by the time parole comes. Arthur Broussard, who killed a Houston grocery-store owner in 1970, says that's the story of his life. "I was a kid," says Broussard, now 46. "I have no excuses ... If they had executed me, I would have gotten what I deserved." Paroled in 1986, he's struggled to make ends meet by renovating houses and hauling trash.
Carl Harris, 44, who shot his foster mother and a friend during an argument in 1967, says 24 years in prison have changed him forever. "You change anyway between 20 and 40, but prison really changes you." Others have more difficulty on the outside. Calvin Sellars, convicted of torturing a Houston woman during a 1964 robbery, stumbled after his parole. In 1986, he returned to prison to do two and a half years for a pistol-waving episode in a bar. "I lost control. I made a terrible mistake, no excuses," says Sellars, 46. Free again, Sellars works as a paralegal in Houston.
None of these studies, of course, can guarantee that Leonardo Lopez or any other paroled killer will behave themselves. Nor do they resolve the main justice question: should some killers forfeit their freedom forever even though they may never strike again? But in an age when fear of crime is ubiquitous, it is some comfort to know that there can be a decent life after death row.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines