10
Loading video...

By Melonee Steele
Founder
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
If a dental practice has to replace the same position three times in a year, perhaps the vacancy is not the problem. Perhaps the workplace is.
Statistics Canada’s 2025 Survey of Oral Health Care Providers found that 80 per cent of oral health practices experienced at least one staffing or human resources challenge. Among dental offices, 64 per cent reported difficulty recruiting skilled employees.
The Canadian Dental Association has also highlighted approximately 7,200 unfilled dental assistant and hygienist positions in 2023. These numbers point to a workforce under considerable pressure, with patient demand continuing to grow.
Read More on Leadership Insights
For too long, recruitment has served as a reflex instead of a remedy for an industry-wide crisis. A vacancy opens, an advertisement goes out, interviews are conducted, and a new clinician is welcomed through the door.
Yet what happens when that person walks out a few months later?

...
The practice resets the hiring cycle, the remaining team absorbs yet another wave of disruption, and the root cause of the exodus goes entirely unaddressed.
Having spent more than a decade in dental recruitment, a perspective shaped by my own early career as a dental assistant, I have come to a clear conviction.
Dentistry cannot hire its way out of a retention problem.
The future of the profession depends just as much on the workplace culture we build for our current team as it does on bringing in new talent.
No recruitment strategy can indefinitely compensate for leadership that refuses to address the reasons employees leave. Hiring can fill a position, but leadership determines whether someone wants to keep it.
The Cost of Protecting Familiarity
I see this play out in my work. When a practice repeatedly approaches us to replace the same dental assistant, office manager, or associate, we pay attention.
We speak with the person who has left and try to understand what happened. One departure can have several explanations. Two or three people describing the same experiences, however, start to reveal a troubling pattern.
In my experience, persistent turnover can sometimes be traced to one or two individuals whose behavior has been allowed to affect the entire workplace.
A dentist may hesitate to address the situation because that employee has been there for 15 years and carries valuable institutional knowledge.
Losing that person could create another operational headache. Yet while leadership postpones the difficult conversation, other employees silently reach their breaking point.
I have seen how unresolved disagreements can lead to one resignation after another, while the original source of the tension remains in place. At some point, leaders have to recognize the cost of protecting familiarity at the expense of the wider team.
Patients Pay the Price
Dentistry is an intensely collaborative profession. Four-handed dentistry, in which the dentist and assistant work in close coordination, depends on anticipation, trust, and communication.
Instruments need to be ready, procedures need to flow, and team members must be able to rely on one another.
A disagreement that follows someone into the treatment room can affect their concentration, confidence, and ability to give a patient their full attention.
When people in the same department talk down to one another or shut down open conversation, patients pay the price, and research supports this.
A systematic review and meta-analysis of 41 studies in the Journal of Advanced Nursing shows that workplace incivility erodes teamwork and puts patient safety at risk in hospitals.
Anywhere people’s lives depend on smooth collaboration, everyday disrespect is a danger we cannot afford to shrug off.
A dental practice’s culture is often reflected in the smallest details: how colleagues communicate during a busy appointment, whether concerns are acknowledged, and how readily team members step in to support one another.
These everyday interactions shape the atmosphere in which quality care is delivered. Unresolved tensions, strained relationships, and the lingering effects of workplace disagreements can gradually erode that sense of collaboration, leaving employees distracted and patients exposed to the consequences.
A Human Issue
This is a human issue that reaches far beyond dentistry. Every patient depends on the people delivering their care being supported, focused, and able to work together.
Every employee deserves to spend their working day without feeling that their dignity is negotiable. Workplace culture ultimately finds its way into the quality of service people receive.
Of course, finding the right fit matters. I have placed candidates in environments that others might avoid because their personalities and working styles suited those particular practices.
I once worked with a quieter candidate who seemed an unlikely match for an outgoing, larger-than-life dentist. They went on to work together for more than a decade.
That experience reminded me that personality alone cannot determine compatibility. People need to be understood in the context of the team they are joining.
This is also why recruitment should involve honest conversations on both sides. When similar concerns emerge across different conversations, we bring those observations back to the practice.
It is our responsibility to approach those discussions constructively, because repeatedly placing people into an environment with unresolved problems serves nobody well.
An Active Responsibility
Ultimately, retention requires leadership to become an active responsibility.
Dentists and practice owners should conduct meaningful exit conversations, establish clear expectations before employment begins, schedule regular check-ins after onboarding, and create a safe route for employees to raise concerns.
Managers must also be prepared to act when behaviour repeatedly damages team relationships. A long-serving employee’s institutional knowledge has value, but so does the collective wellbeing of everyone who keeps the practice running.
Dental practice owners and leaders need to stop treating repeated resignations as an unavoidable recruitment expense.
Examine the reasons behind every departure, hold people accountable, including those who have been part of the practice for years, and make workplace culture a measurable management priority.
The next hire may temporarily solve a vacancy. The next leadership decision could determine whether another five people decide to stay.
Melonee Steele is a dental industry veteran with over 30 years of experience and the founder of Your Tooth Fairy, a premier Canadian dental recruitment agency established in 2013. All views are her own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines