WASHINGTON, DC – OCTOBER 07: United States Supreme Court Associate Justice Elena Kagan poses for an official portrait at the East Conference Room of the Supreme Court building on October 7, 2022 in Washington, DC. The Supreme Court has begun a new term after Associate Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was officially added to the bench in September.

...

Jenni Fink

By Jenni Fink

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Some former Supreme Court clerks have spoken out about Justice Elena Kagan's approach to being a boss, going so far as calling it "abusive," but one of her former clerks is defending the justice, saying the comments are "overblown."

Alito: The Justice Who Reshaped the Supreme Court and Restored the Constitution, by Mollie Hemingway, was published Tuesday, providing an inside look into what some former clerks think of the justices. The book's release comes at a time when confidence and trust in the Supreme Court have dipped, and while some former clerks have negative impressions of Kagan, she has one of the highest favorability ratings among Supreme Court justices.

According to the book, Kagan—widely regarded as the intellectual leader of the Court’s liberal bloc—is admired for her sharp legal mind, strategic skill in oral arguments, and ability to build coalitions with conservative justices. But that reputation is paired with repeated accounts from clerks and court insiders describing her as emotionally abusive and demoralizing inside chambers.

Read More on News

Multiple former clerks—speaking anonymously—describe Kagan as a deeply demanding boss whose treatment of staff crossed professional lines. According to the book, clerks and others at the Court characterized her as "emotionally abusive," and "demanding, demoralizing, demeaning."

"'Kagan's clerks had fear in their eyes,' recalls someone who clerked for a different justice," Hemingway wrote in the book. "Other clerks compared her to Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, moving from extremely kind to extremely angry."

United States Supreme Court Associate Justice Elena Kagan poses for an official portrait at the East Conference Room of the Supreme Court building on October 7, 2022, in Washington, D.C.

...

However, a former Kagan clerk told Hemingway that the negative reputation people have of her was "overblown by clerks who had never had other tough bosses." Another former clerk for the Supreme Court justice said she has higher standards for her clerks than other justices do and that Kagan has "deep relationships" with her former clerks.

"Permanent staff report that her treatment of them is better, though they acknowledge that her reputation for treatment of clerks is not good," Hemingway wrote in the book.

Newsweek reached out to the Supreme Court via email for comment, but did not receive a response in time for publication.

While Kagan may have a mixed reputation in the Supreme Court, according to Hemingway's book, she's popular with the American public. A Marquette University Law School poll in February found Kagan has a net favorability rating of 9 percent, making her the second most popular justice behind Justice Sonia Sotomayor. While she has a net favorability among Republicans of -7, she's the most popular liberal justice on the Court with Republicans. Sotomayor has a net favorability among Republicans of -21 and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson has a net favorability with Republicans of -28.

View content

https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/28638135/

View content

https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/28638173/

Hemingway's book contrasts clerks' views of Kagan with their views of Alito. While Kagan got mixed reviews from clerks, Hemingway's book describes Alito in a much more favorable light. A former clerk described Alito as potentially the "smartest person I've ever met," and clerks praised how "meticulous" the justice is. Another former clerk told Hemingway that drafting opinions for Alito is "no more than formatting a document" because he takes out so much of the text the clerk puts in.

"Ever courteous, the judge would often apologize to his clerks for changing their work and express appreciation for what they had done," Hemingway wrote.

Even when Hemingway writes about Alito being frustrated with his staff for missing a conflict of interest in reviewing cases, she notes his soft approach in admonishing his team.

"When mistakes like this occur, Alito sits the team down and politely tells them they have to be more diligent," Hemingway wrote.

Alito is one of the least popular conservative Supreme Court justices, with only Justices Clarence Thomas and Brett Kavanaugh having lower favorability ratings. When it comes to Republicans, Alito also isn't very popular, according to the Marquette poll. Alito's net favorability rating among Republicans is 24 percent, lower than every conservative justice except Chief Justice John Roberts.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines