Joseph Fons holds a pride flag outside of the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, D.C. on June 15, 2020.

...

Andrew Stanton

By Andrew Stanton

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a new case filed by Catholic preschools in Colorado that argue the state violated their rights by excluding them from a state-funded program because of their admission policies regarding LGBTQ+ families.

Why It Matters

It's the latest case the court has agreed to hear pertaining to religious rights. The conservative-leaning court has sided with religious groups against LGBTQ+ rights in recent cases, including a ruling against Colorado in a legal dispute over a conversion therapy ban. The court's ruling on the case could have implications for LGBTQ+ nondiscrimination laws.

Read More on Politics

St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy: What to Know

The court agreed to take the case St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Lisa Roy in its orders list released on Monday.

The case involves facilities arguing it is unconstitutional for Colorado to prohibit them from a taxpayer-funded free preschool program because of their admission policies on LGBTQ+ families and children. The state has said it allows religious schools to participate in the program, but that they must follow nondiscrimination laws.

Dan and Lisa Sheley, Catholic parents involved in the case, wrote in a statement on Monday, “All we want is the freedom to choose the best preschool for our kids without being punished for our faith. Colorado promised families a universal preschool program, then cut out families like ours because we chose a Catholic education. We pray the Supreme Court will remind Colorado that universal means everyone.”

In their petition to the Supreme Court, petitioners argued the state law requires schools to ensure families have an “equal opportunity” to enroll but have granted numerous exceptions.

“But Colorado excludes Catholic preschools because they admit only families who support Catholic beliefs, including on sex and gender,” the petition reads.

They said two Archdiocesan preschools have already closed since litigation began.

“Families like the Sheleys have been forced to either follow the dictates of their faith at the cost of thousands of dollars per year or abandon their religious exercise. Colorado is thus imposing enormous—and unconstitutional— pressure on religious preschools to conform or close, and it is doing so in a way that the Tenth Circuit held up as a ‘model’ to be replicated elsewhere. Allowing the decision below to stand will only fuel and expand this pressure campaign, which is damaging to religious groups, our country, and the rule of law,” the petition reads.

Joseph Fons holds a Pride flag outside the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., on June 15, 2020.

...

Attorney General Phil Weiser’s office wrote in a filing the universal preschool program “affirmatively welcomes faith-based providers while allowing no exceptions from its equal-opportunity requirements.”

“Because this case involves neither any exceptions nor the discretion to create exceptions, it is not an appropriate vehicle for addressing the question of what sorts of exceptions would render the government’s action not generally applicable,” he wrote.

He argued exceptions allowing providers to “prioritize children from low-income families and children with disabilities does not deny equal opportunity in violation of the statute.”

His office declined comment when reached by Newsweek.

Human Rights Campaign President Kelley Robinson wrote in a statement Monday that students “deserve to be accepted at school and treated equally regardless of their or their family members’ sexual orientation or gender identity.”

“To give public dollars to preschools that openly treat students with LGBTQ+ parents differently is state backed discrimination and has no place in Colorado or everywhere else. Colorado’s policy is sound and responsible, but this case is part of a dangerous, escalating path that takes aim at LGBTQ+ children, parents, and entire family units. This must stop,” she wrote.

What Is at Stake in This Case? Legal Analyst Weighs In

Ryan Thoreson, a University of Cincinnati law professor, told Newsweek the “broad question posed in this case is whether the state of Colorado must provide public funding to religious preschool providers even though the providers say they will not comply with the program's nondiscrimination requirements.”

“Since Employment Division v. Smith, decided in 1990, the Court has said that when a law like the nondiscrimination law is neutral and generally applicable, meaning that it applies to everyone and doesn't single out religion, it is typically permissible under the First Amendment,” he said, noting that case has been a “target for years.”

The court did not “expressly grant certiorari” on the question of whether to overturn Smith but instead took two other questions around what kinds of exceptions a state can grant on secular grounds before a law isn’t considered generally applicable, according to Thoreson. The second question centers around when courts should apply heightened review.

The court has been “incredibly friendly to religious litigants asserting the freedom of speech and the freedom of religion, and has consistently downplayed the state's compelling interest in requiring religious litigants to comply with LGBTQ+ rights protections,” he said.

However, the outcome of this case could change “an entire framework for how we evaluate free exercise cases, one that has guided the Court for thirty-five years,” Thoreson said, adding, “It isn't at all clear how the Court would refashion it or what it would replace it with."

A broad ruling in the case could mean that anytime a state entity partners with private groups to deliver services, granting exceptions for “secular entities” would “also allow religious entities to get an exception to discriminate against certain program recipients or decline to provide certain services,” he said.

Supreme Court Has Taken on LGBTQ+ Rights Cases

The court has handed down rulings on several major LGBTQ+ rights cases.

In March, liberal justices Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan joined the court’s conservative majority in a ruling in favor of a challenge of Colorado’s law prohibiting conversion therapy for minors.

The court held that the law, when applied to talk therapy provided by Kaley Chiles, who is a licensed counselor in Colorado, regulates speech based on viewpoint. The court said lower courts failed to apply "sufficiently rigorous" First Amendment scrutiny.

It also upheld Tennessee’s ban on gender‑affirming medical care for transgender minors in 2025.

However, the court also declined to hear a case challenging the constitutionality of same-sex marriage, which it rendered legal nationwide a decade earlier in 2015. It rejected a bid from Kim Davis, a former Kentucky county clerk who spent six days in jail for refusing to provide marriage certificates to same-sex couples on religious grounds.

Conservative Justice Clarence Thomas has signaled an openness to revisiting the case, writing in the 2022 case Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, "In future cases, we should reconsider all of this Court's substantive due process precedents, including Griswold, Lawrence, and Obergefell."

Conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett has described marriage rights as “fundamental,” comments legal experts have interpreted to mean she is not inclined to overturn same-sex marriage.

How Many Supreme Court Justices Are There?

There are nine Supreme Court justices. The justices are Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Samuel Alito, Justice Clarence Thomas, Justice Elena Kagan, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, Justice Neil Gorsuch, Justice Brett Kavanaugh, Justice Amy Coney Barrett and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson.

This article includes reporting by the Associated Press.

Update 4/20/26, 12 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.

Update 4/20/26, 1:46 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.

Update 4/20/26, 3:15 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines