Aila Slisco

By Aila Slisco

Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch has agreed to recuse himself from an upcoming case following a pressure campaign from activist groups and Democratic lawmakers.

Gorsuch, part of the court's current 6-3 conservative majority, indicated on Wednesday that he would not be participating in Seven County Infrastructure Coalition v. Eagle County, Colorado, a case that will determine whether the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) requires federal agencies to consider "downline impacts" of projects like oil drilling operations.

Calls for the justice to recuse himself intensified due to his relationship with Philip Anschutz, a Colorado billionaire who built his fortune in the oil industry and could benefit from the court's ruling. Gorsuch represented Anschutz while working as a corporate lawyer in the early 2000s.

Read More on News

News that Gorsuch recused himself broke in the form of a memo sent to lawyers involved in the case by Supreme Court Clerk Scott Harris on Wednesday.

It announced that "Justice Gorsuch has determined that he will not continue to participate in this case" due to the court's code of conduct, which was enacted last year following criticisms of Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito for refusing to remove themselves from other cases.

The current case is set for oral arguments on December 10 and arrived at the Supreme Court after a federal appeals court sided with Eagle County's lawsuit to block the Seven County Infrastructure Coalition-sponsored construction of a rail line in rural Utah. The decision hinged on a claim that the project violated NEPA by not considering indirect environmental impacts.

In September, the Anschutz Exploration Corporation filed an amicus brief, or "friend-of- the-court" brief, urging Supreme Court justices to limit the scope of NEPA and to allow the rail line to be constructed by overturning the lower court's decision.

"Because NEPA applies to every major federal action—including the authorizations Anschutz needs to develop federal oil-and-gas reserves—far more is at stake in this case than the 88-mile rail line in rural Utah," the brief states.

Newsweek reached out for comment to the Anschutz Exploration Corporation via email on Wednesday evening.

Accountable.US and 14 other groups including Greenpeace USA argued that "the cozy relationship" between Gorsuch and Anschutz "requires Justice Gorsuch to recuse from this case as Anschutz's businesses could financially benefit from how the case is decided" in a letter sent to Chief Justice John Roberts in October.

"The blatant conflict of interest is clear–therefore, we urge you to take appropriate action to ensure Justice Gorsuch recuses himself from this case," the letter states. "This relationship that creates a conflict of interest is just the latest example of countless violations in the years-long Supreme Court ethics crisis."

Last month, Democratic Representative Hank Johnson of Georgia and 12 of his House colleagues sent a letter to Gorsuch, demanding his recusal, arguing that Anschutz "played a significant role" in his ascent to the Supreme Court in addition to ongoing personal ties.

"To show the American people that the Supreme Court is impartial, you must recuse yourself from any case that directly impacts the financial fortunes of Philip Anschutz, the man who was your previous legal client, who helped raise you to the Supreme Court, and who now treats you to lavish vacations on his exclusive 60-square-mile ranch," the lawmakers wrote.

"You must do the honorable thing and recuse yourself from any decisions in the case of Seven County Infrastructure Coalition v. Eagle County, Colorado," they added.

Following the announcement that Gorsuch had recused himself, Johnson issued a statement praising the justice for doing the "honorable thing" by showing that he was "not in the pocket" of Anschutz.

"I think it is essential to maintaining the public's respect in the integrity of the Court, and I applaud Justice Gorsuch for doing the right and honorable thing," Johnson said. "It is important that the Court show the public that it is not in the pocket of billionaire benefactors."

Neil Gorsuch

...

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines