
...

By Gabe Whisnant
News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Justice Neil Gorsuch broke with the Supreme Court’s conservative majority on Tuesday in a closely divided ruling that shields the U.S. Postal Service from lawsuits, even when employees are accused of deliberately refusing to deliver mail.
Gorsuch, appointed by President Donald Trump during his first term, joined the court’s three liberal justices in dissent as the court, by a 5‑4 vote, rejected a lawsuit brought by a Texas landlord who said her mail was intentionally withheld for nearly two years.
How did the Supreme Court Rule on the Case?
Writing for the majority, Justice Clarence Thomas said a long‑standing legal provision that generally protects the Postal Service from lawsuits covers claims involving the intentional non-delivery of mail. Congress, he wrote, chose broad immunity to prevent litigation that could interfere with postal operations.
Read More on U.S.
“In 2024, the Postal Service’s more than 600,000 employees delivered more than 112 billion pieces of mail—over 300 million a day—to more than 165 million delivery points. Unsurprisingly, given this volume, not all mail arrives properly and on time,” Thomas wrote.
The decision bars Americans from suing the Postal Service over missing, delayed or undelivered mail under federal law.
In dissent, Justice Sonia Sotomayor said the majority’s reading of the law went too far. While Congress provided sweeping protection for routine mail problems, she wrote, it did not clearly intend to bar lawsuits when the failure to deliver mail was allegedly driven by malicious motives. Gorsuch joined Sotomayor and the court’s other liberal justices without writing separately.
“Contrary to the majority’s suggestion otherwise, adhering to the text Congress enacted would not flood the Government or courts with frivolous lawsuits," Sotomayor wrote. She continued, “Even if ruling for Konan today would mean more suits against the Government for mail-related intentional torts tomorrow, that would not provide this Court with authority to change the text Congress enacted.”

...
What is Postal Service v. Konan?
The case was brought by Lebene Konan, a Black real estate and insurance agent who owns rental properties in Euless, Texas, in the Dallas‑Fort Worth area. Konan alleged that two postal employees deliberately refused to deliver mail to one of her properties because of racial bias.
According to court documents, Konan discovered that the mailbox key for one of her rental properties had been changed without her knowledge, preventing her from collecting tenants’ mail. When she contacted the local post office, she was told mail delivery would not resume until she proved ownership of the property. Konan provided the requested documentation, the filings say, but mail delivery problems continued.
Konan alleged that postal employees marked mail as undeliverable or returned it to senders, even after a Postal Service inspector general instructed that delivery should resume. As a result, Konan and her tenants failed to receive important items such as bills, medications and vehicle titles, according to the lawsuit. She also said some tenants moved out because of the disruption, costing her rental income.
After filing dozens of complaints with postal officials, Konan sued under the Federal Tort Claims Act, a 1946 law that allows some lawsuits against the federal government. The dispute centered on a specific exemption in the law that limits liability for claims arising from postal operations.
The Trump administration had urged the court to rule against Konan, warning that allowing her lawsuit to proceed could open the door to a wave of similar claims against the financially strained Postal Service.
The ruling leaves Konan without a federal damages remedy and underscores the breadth of legal protections afforded to the Postal Service.
Updates: 2/24/26, 6:20 p.m. ET: This article was updated with new information and remarks.
This article includes reporting by the Associated Press.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines